SCRIPT:
Barker: All rise, the Honorable Sixto Estudillo presiding. [The judge bangs the gavel
thrice.]
J. Estudillo: Call the cases.
Clerk of Court: No. 1 in the calendar your Honor is the case of Vladimir Putin
Serafin v. Kim Jun Longcop for Recovery of Possession:
J. Estudillo: Counsel for PLaintiff
Atty. Victor: For the plaintiff, your Honor, ready for Pre-Trial.
J. Estudillo: Counsel for defendant
Atty. Whoever: For the defendant, your Honor, ready.
The court notes that both parties had submitted their respective pre-trial briefs
The court then asks for the possibility of amicable settlement, submission of compromise
agreement
Insert script for amicable settlement
J. Estudillo: Atty Victor, may you state your theory of the partys claim?
Atty. Victor recites the theory
J. Estudillo: Atty Melvic, please state your theory of the defendants case.
Atty. Melvic recites theory
J. Estudillo: Atty. Victor, please state your request for stipulations.
Atty. Victor recites proposed admissions/stipulations of facts
(In this instance, we shall decide what facts must be admitted as part of the play,
including conditions precedent, prior repeated demand, jurisdictional facts, etc.)
Example:
Atty. Victor: Your Honor, as stated in our pre-trial brief, we request the following stipulations:
1) That the property in question is registered under the plaintiffs name as
appearing in TCT No. ____________.
Atty. Melvic: We cannot stipulate on that, your Honor.
Atty. Victor: 2) That a demand letter was sent and received by the Defendant on ___________
as shown in a copy of that demand letter with proof of receipt via registered mail attached to the
demand letter.
Atty. Melvic: Admitted, your Honor.
Atty. Victor: 3) That despite receipt of that demand letter the defendant refused to vacate the
property in issue.
Atty. Melvic: Admitted, your Honor.
Atty. Victor: That will be all for the plaintiff, your Honor.
J. Estudillo: Alright, Atty. Melvic, any proposed stipulations?
Atty. Melvic: Yes, your Honor.
1) That the property has not been offered for sale to the defendant who has the
right of first refusal.
Atty. Victor: Denied, your Honor.
Atty. Melvic; 2) That the defendant is able and willing to purchase the property in question at a
reasonable price.
Atty. Victor: We cannot stipulate on that, your Honor.
Atty. Melvic: That will be all for the defendant, your Honor.
Factual issues asked by Judge
Atty Victor: Your honor, as stated in our pre-trial brief, here are my factual issues:
Atty Victor recites the factual issues and provides evidence to support
J. Estudillo: Alright, please pick your available dates for the marking of your respective
documentary exhibits before the Branch Clerk of Court.
Atty. Victor: May we have October 20, 2017 at 1:30 p.m., your Honor.
Atty. Whoever: Available, your Honor.
Examples:
- On marking of evidence.
J. Estudillo: Atty. Victor, do you tend to adopt the evidence as part of your case?
Atty. Victor: Yes your honor we adopt the evidence as part of our case and request
that it be marked as exhibit 5 for the plaintiff.
- On admission of facts:
Atty Victor: Your honor we admit and stipulate that the Foreshore lease was duly issued
and executed in accordance with law and that it is genuine.
Judge E: Atty. Melvic do you submit to the due execution and genuineness of the
foreshore lease agreement?
Atty Melvic: Yes your honor, we submit to the genuineness and due execution but not
to the contents of said document.