HOSPITALS SAFE FROM
DISASTERS
JOINT HEMB and HFDB
PROJECTS
Structural Assessment Report for DOH
Hospitals, TRCs and Offices
as of February 18, 2018
CATEGORY
a It is likely that the hospital will function in emergencies
and disasters
b Intervention measures are needed in the short term
c Urgent intervention measures are needed
Source : DOH Hospital Safety Indicators (HSI)
prepared by HEMB/HFDB
in collaboration with the WHO
HOSPITAL/AGENCY Safety Index Category
NATIONAL CHILDREN’S HOSPITAL
Building 2 0.38 b
Building 3 0.46 b
Building 4 1.00 a
DR. JOSE FABELLA MEMORIAL HOSPITAL
Admin and Dorm Building 0.00 c
BATAAN GENERAL HOSPITAL 0.99 a
LAS PIÑAS GENERAL HOSPITAL AND
SATELLITE TRAUMA CENTER
Building 1 0.76 a
Building 2 0.76 a
Building 3 0.76 a
Building 4 0.51 b
PHILIPPINE CHILDRENS MEDICAL CENTER 0.66 a
HOSPITAL/AGENCY Safety Category
Index
OSPITAL NG PALAWAN
- 2 Storey Administrative Building 0.77 a
- 2 Storey Dormitory Building 0.48 b
- 2 Storey OB Pedia Building 0.55 b
- 2 Storey OPD Building 0.43 c
- 2 Storey ER and Laboratory Building 0.46 b
- 3 Storey Communicable Disease Building 0.74 a
- 3 Storey OR Complex Building 0.86 a
- Autoclave Housing 0.98 a
- Laundry Building 0.43 b
- Motorpool Building 1.00 a
- OR DR Building 0.48 b
- Oxygen Generating Plant 0.69 a
- Power House 0.98 a
- Sewage Treatment Plant 0.98 a
- Surgical Ward Building 0.43 b
HOSPITAL/AGENCY Safety Index Category
SOUTHERN ISABELA GENERAL HOSPITAL
Ancillary Building 0.86 a
Dietary Building 0.86 a
Emergency Building 0.86 a
Miranda Building 0.56 b
OPD Building 0.86 a
OR DR Complex and Dialysis Building 0.56 b
VETERANS REGIONAL HOSPITAL
Main Building 0.53 b
Maintenance Building 0.48 b
Morgue Building 0.48 b
Nightingale Building 0.83 a
Old Administration Building 0.55 b
Out Patient Department Building 0.98 a
TB Dots Building 0.99 a
Trauma Building 0.79 a
HOSPITAL/AGENCY Safety Category
Index
VICENTE SOTTO MEMORIAL MEDICAL CENTER
- Rabies Room/Morgue 0.32 c
- Four Storey Laboratory Building 0.87 a
- Communication ward (Re-emeging/ 0.36 b
emerging disease) b
- Renal Center 2 0.62 a
- Renal Center 0.79 c
- Warehouse Region 0.3 c
- House Keeping Section 0.35 c
- Laudry and Linen 0.3 c
- Power House 0.37 b
- Dietary Service 0.25 c
- CFI Building 0.67 c
- OB Pavilion 0.67 a
- Medical Records 0.37 b
- Chief of Hospital Residence 0.17 c
- Regional Blood Center 0.31 c
- Training Office 0.28 c
- Administrative Building 0.45 b
- Botica/Pharmacy 0.29 c
HOSPITAL/AGENCY Safety Category
Index
- Center for Behavioral Science (OPD) 0.47 b
- Child Survival Center 0.39 b
- Women and Children Protection Warehouse 0.39 b
- Engineering and Maintenance Building 0.41 b
- CECAP Building 0.48 b
- Pediatric Pavilion 0.63 b
- Philhealth Annex Building 0.72 a
- Surgical Pavilion 0.69 a
- Main Building Center Wing 0.30 c
- Trauma Center 0.38 b
- Out Patient Department 0.22 c
- Garage and Driver's Quarter 0.37 b
- Chapel and Traditional Medicine Bldg 0.23 c
- Center for Behavioral Science (In PD) 0.04 c
HOSPITAL/AGENCY Safety Category
Index
DON EMILIO DEL VALLE MEMORIAL HOSPITAL
- Dietary Admin Building 0.70 b
- EBA wing Building 0.85 b
- Main Building 0.63 b
- OB Building 0.70 b
- Operating Room Building 0.80 b
GOV. CELESTINO C. GALLARES MEMORIAL HOSPITAL
- Main Building 0.11 c
- Medical Building 0.10 c
- OB Pedia Building 0.06 c
- OPD Lab Building 0.14 c
- Surgery Building 0.59 b
MAYOR HILARION S. RAMIRO SR. MEDICAL CENTER 0.55 b
HOSPITAL/AGENCY Safety Category
Index
TREATMENT REHABILITATION CENTER - BICUTAN
- Accounting/Auditor Building 0.56 b
- Administration Building 0.15 c
- Admission Building 0.45 b
- Dietary Building 1.00 a
- Engineering Fabrication Area 0.00 c
- Fitness Area 0.63 b
- Gymnasium 0.62 b
- Jose Fabella Memorial School 0.07 c
- Loudes Tuazon Arrogo School 0.00 c
- Magalang Dorm 0.62 b
- Magilas Dorm 0.62 b
- Maginoo Dorm 0.47 b
- Magiting Dorm 0.47 b
- Mahinhin Dorm 0.54 b
- Makabayan Dorm 0.67 a
- Makakalikasan Dorm 0.62 b
- Makatao Dorm 0.62 b
- Makatarungan Dorm 0.62 b
HOSPITAL/AGENCY Safety Category
Index
- Mapagtimpi Dorm 0.62 b
- Marangal Dorm 0.62 b
- Masigasig Dorm 0.62 b
- Masigla Dorm 0.85 c
- Masikap Dorm 0.47 b
- Matapat Dorm 0.79 a
- Matino Dorm 0.47 b
- Matiyaga Dorm 0.56 b
- Matulungin Dorm 0.79 a
- Mayumi Building 0.56 b
- Medical Building 0.24 c
- Mess Hall 0.79 a
- New Power House 1.00 a
- Old Mess Hall 0.00 c
- Old Motorpool 0.00 c
- Old Powerhouse 0.00 c
- Psychology Building 0.40 b
- Public Comfort Room 0.62 b
HOSPITAL/AGENCY Safety Category
Index
- Security Outpost 0.46 b
- Sewage Treatment Plant 0.67 a
- Social Service Building 0.49 b
- Staff House Quarter 0.23 c
- Trail Reventry Building 0.52 b
- Worship Hall 0.85 a
TREATMENT REHABILITATION CENTER – ARGAO
- Admin and Dorm Building 0.77 a
- Dorm C Building 0.77 a
- Multi Purpose Covered Court 0.80 a
TREATMENT REHABILITATION CENTER – MALINAO
- 16-Beds Female Dormitory 0.97 a
- Public Toilet 0.64 b
- 100-Beds Male Dormitory 0.97 a
- Guard house and Frisking area Building 0.97 a
HOSPITAL/AGENCY Safety Category
Index
- Elevated Concrete Water Tank 0.66 b
- Covered Court Building 0.97 a
- Administration Admission Building 0.97 a
- Activity Building 0.97 a
DID NOT USE HOSPITAL SAFETY INDEX TOOL
SAN LAZARO HOSPITAL
- Frontline Service Building No cracks found
- Pavilion 1-4 Building Crack seen, for detailed structural
assessment
- Pavilion 5-8 Building No cracks found
- Gavino Hall and Medical Records Building No cracks found
- Administration Building No cracks found
- OPD Complex No cracks found, under renovation
- Power House No cracks found, Newly Renovated
- ASACCL Annex No cracks found, Proposed area for 5-
storey geriatric building
- SLH Nurse's Dormitory Building No cracks found
- COOP canteen 1 No cracks found, Proposed area for 5-
storey geriatric building
- COOP Canteen 2 No cracks found
- Pelota Court No cracks found
- Executive Staff House No cracks found
- Property and Supply Building Under renovation
- SACCL/JICA Research Laboratory No Cracks found
- Dietary and Seminar Hall Building Crack seen, for detailed structural
assessment
DID NOT USE HOSPITAL SAFETY INDEX TOOL
- IDCCU Building Crack seen, for detailed structural
assessment
- Engineering and Facility Management No cracks found, under renovation
Building
- Watcher's Waiting Area No Cracks found, newly constructed
- Linen and Laundry Building No Cracks found
- Was Water Treatment Plant No Cracks found
- Pavilion 10 Biuilding No cracks found, under renovation
- MDR Building No Cracks found
- Motorpool No Cracks found
- Pavilion H4 No Cracks found
- Extended Child Care Building No cracks found, Newly Renovated
- H4 OPD Building No Cracks found
- Microbiology Building No Cracks found
- SLH Morgue No Cracks found
- SLH Chapel No cracks found, under renovation
- H4 Waiting Area No Cracks found, newly constructed
- Public Tolet (infront Admin Building) No Cracks found
- Tennis Court Open area
DID NOT USE HOSPITAL SAFETY INDEX TOOL
- Chapels under renovation
- Tienda under renovation
- Mercury Storage No Cracks found
- Pump Station No Cracks found
- Public Toilet (infont IDCCU) No Cracks found
- Warehouse Building No Cracks found
- Triage No Cracks found
- HEMS Office No Cracks found
- Waste Treatment Disposal No Cracks found
REGION I MEDICAL CENTER
- Medical Building
- OPD Building Per structural testing/visual
- Rehab Building inspection/actual site investigation -
- Supply Building structurally fit but needs a more
- Laundry Building detailed structural assessment
- BAC Building Engineering and
Motorpool Building
- OB-Surgical Building
- Special Areas Building
- Admin Building
- FQD Conference Building
DID NOT USE HOSPITAL SAFETY INDEX TOOL
MARIANO MARCOS MEMORIAL HOSPITAL
AND MEDICAL CENTER
- Laboratory and Diagnostic Building New Building, good condition
- OPD Complex with certificate of annual inspection
- Training Center Building from City Engineers Office,
- Chapel Block Good Condition
- Mortuary/Morgue
- Property and Supply Building For Demolition/Renovation
- Surgical Annex Building with certificate of annual inspection
- Pharmacy Building from City Engineers Office, Good Cond.
- Dietary Building For Demolition/Renovation
- Main Building With certificate of annual inspection from
City Engineers Office, with renovation,
Good Condition
- Emergency Room Building With certificate of annual inspection from
City Engineers Office, Good Condition
- Breast Feeding Building With certificate of annual inspection from
City Engineers Office, Good Condition
- Oxygen Generating Plant Not yet turned over, Good Condition
- Power House With certificate of annual inspection from
City Engineers Office, Good Condition
DID NOT USE HOSPITAL SAFETY INDEX TOOL
BAGUIO GENERAL HOSPITAL AND Per structural testing/visual
MEDICAL CENTER inspection/actual site investigation -
structurally fit but needs a more
detailed structural assessment
FAR NORTH LUZON GENERAL HOSPITAL
AND TRAINING CENTER
- Administration Building Good Condition, Structural members
- Dietary and Linen Building Good Condition, Structural members,
cracks on wall and slab on fill
- Ancillary Building Good Condition, Structural members
- OR/DR Building Good Condition, Structural members
- Supply Building Good Condition, Structural members,
cracks on wall and slab on fill
- Power House Good Condition, Structural members
- Mortuary Building Good Condition, Structural members
- Waste Management Building Good Condition, Structural members
- Old Ward Building (Dialysis) Good Condition, Structural members
- Main Building
DID NOT USE HOSPITAL SAFETY INDEX TOOL
REGIONAL HEALTH OFFICE NO. 2
- Main Administration Building
- Warehouse Building No signs of major cracks on its
- Conference Room members, scheduled for detailed
- Local Health Support Division (LSHD structural assessment
Building)
- Dormitory Building
- Licensing Regulatory and Enforcement
Division (LRED) and Collaborating
Center
- RESU/HEMS Building
- Warehouse extension facility
(Motorpool)
WESTERN VISAYAS MEDICAL CENTER
- Geriatrics and Hospice Care Building With structural defects. Initially
investigated by DPWH RO VI
WESTERN VISAYAS SANITARIUM For detailed structural assessment
DID NOT USE HOSPITAL SAFETY INDEX TOOL
SCHISTOSOMIASIS CONTROL & RESEARCH Used old structural indicators, No
HOSPITAL structural assessment/certification for
stability
MINDANAO CENTRAL SANITARIUM Used old structural indicators, No
structural stability certification, no
structural assessment every after
earthquake, No major cracks on
structural members.
REGIONAL OFFICE X - Used old structural
indicator/checklist
- Visible clacks on wall
- Building is top heavy, with
cantilever, not balanced loading but
per report structural resilient per
structural design
- No structural inspection annually
and after very strong earthquake
- Only ACT building has architectural
and structural plans
Plan of Action:
A. For DOH hospitals, TRCs and DOH
offices under category b and c:
1. Procure structural investigation services
and structural retrofitting design services
including detailed estimates.
2. See table (next slide) for procurement of
services
3. From derived detailed estimates of
retrofitting works, request for funding under
HFEP 2019
Cost Estimates for Structural Retrofitting Works
SCOPE OF WORKS COST PER
SQ. M.
A. Structural Investigation Works
Subcomponents:
ocular site inspection 5.00
as built plans -
rebound hammer test
15.00
concrete coring
10.00
rebar scanning
10.00
material testing factual report
15.00
rebar extraction 10.00
TOTAL COST 65.00 per sq. mt.
SCOPE OF WORKS COST PER
SQ. M.
B. Structural Retrofitting Design Works
Subcomponents:
structural design calculation
40.00
detailed structural retrofitting plan
90.00
TOTAL COST 130.00 per sq. mt.
B. For DOH hospitals, TRCs and DOH offices without
structural assessment report or did not use HSI Tool
1. Conduct structural assessment using HSI Tool
2. Submit to HEMB and HFDB
3. Should buildings fall within b and c category
follow above steps under item A
C. For DOH hospitals, TRCs and DOH offices with
buildings constructed in 2015 and earlier with
category a, seek certification from structural
engineer or procure structural engineering service
for evaluation of buildings to meet NSCP 2015
revised edition standard
D. For 2018 HFEP, hospital projects are classified into:
1. For upgrading – Structural Design of DAED
should be certified by structural
engineer to meet NSCP 2015
2015 revised edition standards
NSCP – National Structural Code of the Philippines
2. For Completion – Structural Design of DAED should
be certified by structural engineer
to meet 2015 NSCP revised edition
standards
3. For Development - Structural Design of DAED should
of Specialty be designed by structural
Centers engineer in compliance with
NSCP 2015 revised edition
standards
D. For 2019 HFEP proposed hospital projects,
ensure the above requirements for 2018 HFEP
will be met also.
