The Wall Street Journal - 09.07.2020
The Wall Street Journal - 09.07.2020
00
DJIA 26067.28 À 177.10 0.7% NASDAQ 10492.50 À 1.4% STOXX 600 366.48 g 0.7% 10-YR. TREAS. g 1/32 , yield 0.652% OIL $40.90 À $0.28 GOLD $1,815.50 À $11.30 EURO $1.1330 YEN 107.26
News
California, Texas and Florida, the U.S.
surpassed 3 million confirmed Covid-19
3 million cases
It took 28 days to
diners compared to same day
of the week a year earlier, U.S. Court
cases less than a month after crossing 100% 39%
World-Wide
U.S. NEWS
CAPITAL ACCOUNT | By Greg Ip
C
True, China’s overall sur- workers to generate high sav- 2003 ’10 ’20 2000 ’10 hina may have hoped its aim at global imbalances by
pluses have shrunk sharply as ings that can be invested in Sources: U.S. Census Bureau via Factset, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (trade deficit); U.S. “phase one” trade deal proposing a tax on foreign
a share of its gross domestic new industries, or abroad. Commerce Department via Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (U.S. spending); CEIC (China spending) with Mr. Trump and purchases of U.S. stocks and
product in the past decade. “The high savings model narrowing surpluses would bonds, intervention in cur-
But because GDP has grown forces ordinary people to dustries. It did so through an By definition, surpluses in damp protectionism. Coinci- rency markets to weaken the
so much, the surpluses, espe- spend less so that the govern- undervalued exchange rate one country must equal defi- dentally, in the first quarter dollar, and even repudiation
cially for manufactured ment and business elites can and a financial system that cits in another, so the trade its current account, which in- of some Treasury debt held
goods, remain enormous. spend more,” they explain. It’s subsidized industrial borrow- surpluses generated by China cludes trade in goods and ser- by China. If Joe Biden de-
Consumption is still under the same model used by Brit- ers by paying savers next to and Germany force the U.S. vices and investment income, feats Mr. Trump, it will be
40% of Chinese GDP, one of ain during the Industrial Rev- nothing. Both have been re- (and other low-saving coun- flipped from surplus to deficit as the head of a Democratic
the lowest percentages olution and the Soviet Union formed, but Messrs. Klein tries such as the U.K.) to run as the coronavirus hampered Party more comfortable with
among major economies. The in the 1920s and 1930s. and Pettis note that many deficits. Trade deficits don’t exports. interventionism and less at-
persistence of those imbal- features of China’s economy necessarily reduce employ- But events are going in the tached to free trade.
L
ances is why trade conflicts ike South Korea and still discriminate against ment, but they change its wrong direction. Through China has long sought to
aren’t about to go away even Japan before it, China workers and consumers: ad- composition. In the 2000s, May, Chinese purchases of tamp down trade frictions
if Mr. Trump isn’t re-elected. grew rapidly by chan- versarial unions are illegal, Chinese imports wiped out U.S. goods are running at just by making its economic
The consequences of neling people’s savings into taxes on labor and consump- millions of U.S. jobs while half its commitment, accord- model more consumer
global trade surpluses and high-return investments in tion are high, and millions of Chinese savings helped in- ing to Chad Bown of the Pe- friendly. It may find those
deficits are the subject of education, public infrastruc- migrant workers are deprived flate the housing bubble. In terson Institute for Interna- efforts are too little, too
“Trade Wars are Class Wars: ture and export-oriented in- of social benefits. that sense, Messrs. Klein and tional Economics. late.
CORRECTIONS AMPLIFICATIONS
disinfection efforts Senate Majority Leader
For Schools
CDC Guidelines • Require sick students and Mitch McConnell (R., Ky.) has
staff to stay home said getting children back in
school is a priority for the next
U.S. NEWS
Budget
Deficit
Local Governments Cut Spending
Education takes much
Ballooned of the reductions;
1.5 million jobs have
In June been shed since March
BY KATE DAVIDSON BY DAVID HARRISON
U.S. and would put them on a tinues to pose a risk of further eral and secretary of Home- back. A fourth keeps concerned
fast track to deportation in- transmission to the United land Security to declare future bystanders away.
stead. States, which otherwise has outbreaks as threats for the Mr. Chauvin has been
The new rules expand on a been making progress within purpose of judging asylum. charged with second-degree
provision of immigration law, its borders to stem the further There were 212,846 asylum murder and the other three, in-
which says applicants can be spread of the pandemic.” applications filed in the gov- cluding Mr. Lane, have been
denied asylum if they pose a The U.S. has the highest ernment’s 2019 fiscal year, ac- charged with aiding and abet-
danger to the security of the daily confirmed Covid-19 case cording to the government of- ting second-degree murder.
country, by classifying a pub- average in the world, at 19,854 fice that oversees immigration When officers first ap-
lic-health threat as a form of as of Wednesday, according to courts. proached Mr. Floyd—who was Former officer Thomas Lane with his attorney Earl Gray last month.
A4 | Thursday, July 9, 2020 P W L C 10 11 12 H T G K R F A M 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 O I X X ***** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
U.S. NEWS
cute police for civil-rights vio- and for our country,” Mr. Bi- he is retiring from the service. Col. Vindman’s decision to
lations, offering the latest evi- den said in a statement. He is leaving due to pressure retire came after his pending
dence the party is uniting Mr. Biden has been aiming from the White House, said Da- promotion to full colonel had
behind a common agenda for a more unified party than vid Pressman, his attorney. been held up at the Pentagon.
faster than in 2016. in 2016, when supporters of Col. Vindman, formerly as- Defense Secretary Mark Es-
The recommendations, re- Mr. Sanders and then-nominee signed to the National Security per said last year that he would
leased Wednesday by the Biden Hillary Clinton fought over Council at the White House, re- not retaliate against Col. Vind-
campaign and compiled by task policy during platform negoti- alized his future in the Army man. But an Army promotion
forces made up of people cho- ations. Some Sanders support- would “forever be limited,” Mr. list that included more than
sen by the former vice presi- ers walked out of the conven- Pressman said. “Through a 1,000 names, including that of
dent and the Vermont senator, tion hall. campaign of bullying, intimida- Col. Vindman, stalled as offi-
are expected to form the base Mr. Sanders said in an in- tion and retaliation, the presi- cials weighed how to proceed. A
of the Democratic Party plat- terview Wednesday that his dent of the United States at- defense official said Wednesday
form, which will be formally longtime relationship with Mr. tempted to force [Col.] that Mr. Esper on Monday ap-
voted on at the convention Task forces representing both camps compiled the recommendations. Biden has influenced the pro- Vindman to choose between proved the promotion list, in-
next month, according to peo- cess in a positive way this cy- adhering to the law or pleasing cluding Col. Vindman’s.
ple familiar with the plan. mendations, and the report push to defund police depart- cle. “We disagree on issues, a president.” The White House In the House inquiry, Col.
Mr. Biden, the presumptive Wednesday doesn’t touch on ments. Many of the policies in but we have…a sense of trust National Security Council de- Vindman testified that a call in
Democratic presidential nomi- some key areas of debate in the document had already and respect for each other, and clined to comment. July 2019 by Mr. Trump to the
nee, hasn’t promised to adopt the party, such as expanding been proposed by Mr. Biden, I think those feelings were car- The House approved two ar- Ukrainian president was “inap-
all of the task force recom- Medicare to all Americans or a including expanding the Af- ried over into the task forces.” ticles of impeachment against propriate and improper.”
U.S. WATCH
SOCIAL MEDIA book’s head of security policy, ernor were “fully packed.” A con- Hill neighborhood to take down
said. Some 260,000 accounts fol- servative Democrat, Mr. Mixson the monument, which towers
Facebook Removes lowed one or more of the pages. made close to 200 appointments 100 feet high and was installed
Pages Tied to Stone A lawyer for Mr. Stone didn’t before Republican Bob Martinez in 1894. It depicts a Confederate
respond to a request for com- was sworn in as governor. soldier standing atop a pillar.
Facebook Inc. said Wednes- ment. Mr. Stone was convicted Mr. Mixson was later per- Richmond Mayor Levar Stoney,
day it had removed a network of last year on charges of lying to suaded by longtime legislative citing his emergency powers on
more than 100 pages and ac- Congress, witness tampering and historian Allen Morris to have his July 1, ordered the removal of all
DOJ Hits
City Police
Unit’s Use
Of Force
BY SADIE GURMAN
Pratt Industries helps us raise
the bar for high-quality meat
Officers in the narcotics
section of the Springfield,
Mass., Police Department rou-
tinely violate the constitu-
tional rights of citizens by us-
U.S. NEWS
Plasma-Derived
Drug to Be Tested
BY AMY DOCKSER MARCUS cuss the design of the trial.
Convalescent plasma, as the
Drugmaker Emergent Bio- plasma taken from recovered
solutions Inc. plans to work patients is known, has emerged
with Mount Sinai Health Sys- as a promising, though un-
tem in New York City to test proven, treatment for Covid-19.
whether a drug derived from Recently published results from
the blood plasma of recovered an expanded-access study of
Covid-19 patients can prevent the therapy involving 20,000
infections in doctors, nurses patients found that the transfu-
and military forces. sions resulted in few serious
The proposed study, which side effects and that there
the partners announced wasn’t an excessive mortality
Wednesday, would add to ef- rate. But investigators can’t de-
CALLAGHAN O’HARE/REUTERS
WORLD NEWS
Hong Kong Security Office Opens Stimulus
Targets U.K.
Chinese agents move security office. “It’s such a vi-
U.S. Ready to Restart Talks With North Korea, Envoy Says boost to sentiment.
The package includes pay-
ments to businesses for retain-
BY TIMOTHY W. MARTIN U.S. deputy secretary of state, The two countries haven’t tions had “shifted into despair.” gun’s visit, North Korea said it ing furloughed workers and
reiterated Washington’s long- sat down for formal negotia- The two sides hold differing had no interest in talks with hiring young people, as well as
SEOUL—The U.S. stands held goal in negotiations with tions since October, when views on how and when the the U.S. before November’s grants to make homes and
ready to resume nuclear talks Kim Jong Un’s regime: elimi- North Korea abruptly cut off North should relinquish its nu- presidential election. public buildings more energy
if North Korea is willing to nate Pyongyang’s nuclear talks in Stockholm. Since then, clear arsenal. The Trump ad- If Mr. Kim appoints a coun- efficient. There also were cuts
make a deal, a top State De- weapons and bring peace to Mr. Kim has all but closed the ministration prefers the Kim terpart empowered to negoti- in taxes on hospitality and
partment official said Wednes- the Korean Peninsula. door to diplomacy and ordered regime agree to specifics be- ate, the North Koreans “will home purchases. Mr. Sunak
day, though Pyongyang has sig- “Dialogue can lead to ac- his citizens to prepare for a fore sanctions are relaxed. find us ready at that very mo- said the package could cost
naled it is in no mood to come tion, but action is impossible protracted life under economic Pyongyang wants the process ment,” Mr. Biegun said, adding the government up to £30 bil-
back to the negotiating table. without dialogue,” said Mr. sanctions. to unfold gradually, as the U.S. that the U.S. hadn’t requested lion ($38 billion) and that fur-
In his first visit to Seoul Biegun, after a meeting with North Korea’s foreign minis- removes some penalties. a meeting with the North dur- ther measures would be an-
this year, Stephen Biegun, the South Korea’s nuclear envoy. ter last month said U.S. rela- In the days before Mr. Bie- ing his visit. nounced in the fall.
Learn New
As a WSJ member, enjoy up to 60% on a subscription to
Babbel, the world’s most popular language learning app.
Access lesson content on 14 languages, led by experts and
Languages
voiced by native speakers. Plus, download a member-only
series of curated guides.
Babbel
©2020 Dow Jones & Co., Inc. All rights reserved.6DJ7932
A8 | Thursday, July 9, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
ciations said they were follow- get the full experience of the strict. That’s why we decided to fear. One asked if he was OK af-
ing the judgment of health park. “You don’t see Disney- release the video,” a Fuji-Q ter the ride. “The no-screaming
officials, who have said actions lands in other countries asking spokesman said. rule added another level of
such as coughing and singing people not to scream. It’s too The video inspired a trend shame, I guess,” he said.
can spread droplets widely. strict,” said Mr. Suzuki, noting on social media of people post- Kindergarten teacher Nat-
Florida’s Disney World is that reopened parks in Hong ing stone-faced, mask-clad pho- sumi Goka tried meditating to
due to start reopening to the Kong and Shanghai don’t have tos of themselves on roller avoid screaming on a Fuji-Q
general public Saturday, and such a rule. “If a scream comes coasters with the hashtag “seri- ride. By closing her eyes and
while face coverings are re- out, it comes out.” ous face challenge.” emptying her mind of any of
quired there’s nothing in the Walt Disney Co. didn’t re- Minoru Nagasawa, who the fear or fun she was experi-
rules about screaming. spond to a request for com- Thrill seekers at Tokyo’s Toshimaen amusement park on June 25. works for an auto-parts com- encing, she completed the ride
The rules in Japan are vol- ment. pany, aced the challenge on a successfully. But not happily.
untary, a formula the country Natsumi Kumasawa said that sawa. “It was Umi’s first time est acceleration—hitting 112 recent visit. He said he wanted “That’s the idea of a roller
has used largely successfully in she tried to keep her 3-year-old at Disneyland, so it really miles an hour in 1.56 seconds, to try again, this time with a coaster—you scream,” said Ms.
beating back Covid-19. Mask- daughter, Umi, quiet while on couldn’t be helped.” according to the park’s website. date who might be impressed. Goka. “I’m just waiting for the
wearing in Japan is optional, rides at Disneyland. “Basically At Fuji-Q Highland, west of The Takabisha ride held the “It would be great to find day when we can ride roller
but it is nearly universal—al- she ended up shrieking the Tokyo, the Do-Dodonpa ride world record for steepest drop, someone who sees my lack of coasters and scream our hearts
though cases are now rising in whole time,” said Ms. Kuma- holds the world record for fast- 121 degrees, according to the fear as cool,” he said. out again.”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * NY Thursday, July 9, 2020 | A8A
your car into human beings volunteer work at a Sikh tem- of clinical services for first re- are providing support to offi-
using their voices to improve ple in Lawrenceville, N.J., sponders at New Jersey’s Penn cers who need it, Mr. Shea said.
social conditions is reprehen- cooking food and giving it out Medicine Princeton House Be- “Historically we’ve had a
sible,” she wrote. to the city’s homeless and low- havioral Health, said the polic- number of programs available,
During the past month, income residents. Mr. Grewal ing protests are especially formal and informal, clergy
large-scale protests over po- was touched by Mr. Santiago’s challenging for officers now and counselors, things of that
lice brutality and racism have good work and agreed to join because many have been nature,” he said. “Clearly we
occurred across the U.S., in- him for a volunteer day at the lauded for their work during had to do more and do better.”
cluding in New York City. The temple. But the two never met the pandemic. “In March, Ten NYPD officers killed
protests were spurred by the again. Three weeks later, Mr. April, and May, they were he- themselves in 2019, according
May 25 killing of George Floyd Santiago, 42 years old, died by roes,” he said. “Now they are to the department. So far,
in Minneapolis police custody. suicide after shooting himself. being seen as villains.” three have died by suicide this
A driver was arrested in Se- “It absolutely floored me,” Police nationwide are more year. New Jersey lost four offi-
attle after he drove into dem- Mr. Grewal said. likely to suffer from post-trau- N.J. Attorney General Gurbir Grewal, right, was stunned when Pablo cers to suicide in 2019, and
onstrators on a closed high- In 2019, inspired by Mr. matic stress disorder, said Santiago, a Mercer County Sheriff’s Office detective, killed himself. there have been three in 2020,
way on July 4. One protester Santiago’s death, Mr. Grewal Karen Solomon, president and according to Ms. Solomon.
was killed and another was se- created the New Jersey Resil- co-founder of Blue H.E.L.P., a the organization has recorded said. Mental-health programs in
riously injured. iency Program for Law En- nonprofit that advocates for 90 suicides nationwide for Dr. Bizzarro, a former offi- New Jersey also have shown
On Monday, a Long Island forcement, a program that more services for law-enforce- 2020. cer who regularly counsels promise, Mr. Grewal said. His
man was arrested after he trains officers to better handle ment members to prevent sui- Mr. Santiago was a detec- first responders, said some directive requires the appoint-
struck two Black Lives Matter the stress of police work. cides. The recent protests may tive for the Mercer County members of law enforcement ment of “Resiliency Program
protesters at a roadside dem- That same year, following a fuel a rise in officer depres- Sheriff’s Office in New Jersey. suppress their emotions and Officers” to teach techniques
onstration in Huntington Sta- string of officer suicides in sion and suicide, she said. He started his career in law internalize traumatic memo- to officers in their depart-
tion, said Suffolk County Po- New York City, New York Po- “There’s too many pres- enforcement in 1994. His wife, ries to get through their shifts. ments. The officers are trained
lice officials. The lice Department officials cre- sures on them, and they’re Jennifer, and his colleagues “When you’re responding to in areas such as suicide pre-
demonstrators who were hit ated a program to provide bet- scared,” Ms. Solomon said. said he never revealed any a traumatic situation such as vention and understanding the
there suffered minor injuries, ter psychological support to “They’re scared they are going problems before killing him- an armed robbery or a child effects of stress-induced
they said. The driver in that officers. to get fired and scared that self. She said her husband hid drowning in a pool, could you trauma on the brain.
case was charged with assault Officials in the NYPD and in they’re going to accidentally much of his pain, including imagine if you allowed your “I have been around law en-
and released, officials said. New Jersey say the programs hurt somebody.” childhood trauma. “There emotions to come out?” he forcement for at least half of
The New York City protests have been helpful, with an in- Nationwide, the number of weren’t any signs,” she said. asked. “If it’s a robbery, you my career,” Mr. Grewal said.
mostly have been peaceful, al- creasing number of officers suicides involving law-enforce- Ms. Santiago praised Mr. run the risk of not making it “It took my experience with
though there has been some taking advantage of therapy. ment members jumped from Grewal’s efforts to better sup- home. And if you can’t save meeting Pablo Santiago and
violence, and hundreds of dem- These efforts are especially 142 in 2016 to 230 in 2019, ac- port officers. “I wish it could the child, you have to go home his death to really bring home
onstrators have been arrested. needed now, say police and cording to the group. So far, have helped my husband,” she and look your son or daughter how real of an issue this is.”
A8B | Thursday, July 9, 2020 NY * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
Since 1985, we’ve been cooking and home-delivering nutritious, individually tailored meals
to people living with serious illness in the NYC metropolitan area.
Being sick and hungry is a crisis. You can help.
Donate, volunteer, or just learn more at glwd.org
godslovewedeliver @godslovenyc God’s Love We Deliver is a member of the Food is Medicine Coalition (FIMC).
To learn more about FIMC’s work around the country, visit fimcoalition.org
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, July 9, 2020 | A9
LIFE&ARTS
Nearly all gates at Dallas-Fort Worth
International Airport will be used at
peak hours, CEO Sean Donohue says.
T
here’s an occasional its home at DFW, has been pushing Chengdu has seen larger pas- The airport has what it calls a can reduce its operating costs fur-
line at the Chick-fil-A connecting service more than its senger airplanes, so it has more strike team of 150 workers on pa- ther by taking advantage of lower
counter, and an occa- competitors, focusing mainly on departing seats, Cirium says. And trol to continuously clean high- interest rates and refinancing
sional line of airplanes DFW and Charlotte, N.C. American counting cargo flights, it has more touch areas. It’s added some 300 debt. He says the North Texas
waiting to take off, too. even announced it was dropping total takeoffs. Among U.S. airports, hand-sanitizer dispensers on ad- community, which owns and oper-
Dallas-Fort Worth International five routes to Asia from Los Ange- scheduled flights at DFW in June vertising displays and all kinds of ates the airport, is basically in-
Airport looks…sort of busy. les, making DFW its main trans- topped Atlanta, Denver, Charlotte other locations. By the end of July, vesting to keep its economic en-
And that’s enough to make DFW Pacific gateway. and Chicago O’Hare, in that order, restrooms will be all touchless— gine running so it can help the
the busiest airport in the world. From a low of about 200 flights according to OAG Aviation World- hands-free paper, soap, toilets, wa- local economy recover.
The sprawling Texas hub, with a day at DFW, American will hit wide, another data firm. ter fountains, etc. Sensors in pa- The airport stopped work on a
seven runways and five terminals, 667 flights a day later this month. At DFW, American’s airport per-towel dispensers alert workers huge new terminal—it may be
has more than 90% of its gates and Last summer it flew more than 900 clubs have reopened, and while the to low supplies. many years now before that’s
half its restaurants in operation. a day, and with larger airplanes. passenger flow rises and falls with Masks are now required at the needed. But it’s actually acceler-
DFW typically ranks behind Atlanta, In May, DFW had 12,109 depart- each bank of connecting flights, airport. Employees can get tested ated some construction projects,
Chicago O’Hare and Los Angeles in ing passenger flights, edging out terminals can look downright nor- at no cost when they want. including a four-gate expansion to
takeoffs and landings. But due to Chengdu, China, by 86 flights for mal at times. About 90% of gates It takes strong demand to fill the airport’s main international
the instant transformation of the the title of busiest in the world, are used for the late-afternoon planes on nonstop routes without terminal and a rebuilding of some
airline business, DFW finds itself at according to Cirium, a London- rush, and because American ex- connecting passengers. That gates at one of American’s termi-
least temporarily on top, with long- based travel data and analytics panded its schedule again on Tues- doesn’t exist today, and may not nals. Reconstruction of one of the
lasting implications for travelers. firm. In June, DFW widened its day, Mr. Donohue says, utilization for several years. So airlines are runways was moved up, starting in
For the past two decades, air- lead over Chengdu, Cirium says. will approach 100% at peak hours. back to the future emphasizing June instead of December.
lines have moved to more nonstop World’s busiest is a dubious ti- The traffic surge means that at hubs, where the number of possi- “I am pleasantly surprised by all
flights, bypassing big hubs in the tle in the middle of a pandemic— peak periods, travelers won’t be ble connections often drives just this, but also realistic,” Mr.
middle of the country. Now the even DFW has lost half of its busi- able to socially distance in domes- how full flights are. Donohue says. “After Labor Day,
midcontinent hub is back. For ness. It’s still seen more passenger tic terminals, he says. Sending ex- The airport says it expects July we are going to have to be very ef-
years to come, many travelers will flights than anyone else. tra travelers around the country passenger traffic to be down only ficient at how we run the airport,
find they must connect rather than “It does feel weird to be busy,” and beyond may prove to be a big about 45%. That’s far better than because we are not going to see
go nonstop. says Sean Donohue, DFW’s chief concern, especially if coronavirus the 95% plunge it saw in early traffic like this post-Labor Day.”
To minimize risk, the house has The sale will begin at 8:30 p.m. in fore discovering his own avant- that evoke cocoons. Auction record: Six years ago,
pledged to buy a dozen works and Hong Kong (8:30 a.m. in New York) garde style that involved painting For sale: “Untitled (S.401),” Christie’s sold his 1961 “Black Fire
lined up investors to buy 18 more with the sale of several works in- flat geometric shapes floating in 1953-54 (asking price: $3 million- I” for $84.2 million.
unless others outbid them during cluding an estimated $10 million black backgrounds. His works have $5 million) Trophy hunters may go after
the sale. That means 37% of the painting by Zao Wou-ki from 1963, been collected by the Solomon R. Auction record: Last November, this example by an abstract master
lots, or 30 works, are essentially “21.10.63.” Then an auctioneer in Guggenheim Museum, and his min- Christie’s sold “Untitled (S. 387),” in part because Newman’s works
presold. With a few exceptions, the Paris will take over, followed by imalism influenced contemporary a shorter hanging piece from seldom come to market.
A10 | Thursday, July 9, 2020 NY THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
The traumatic carnage of the seller-turned-movie, enth season last month. Here, he
Normandy invasion is barely be- “Crazy Rich Asians.” His new novel, recommends two novelistic TV
hind them, and there’s a war to be “Sex and Vanity,” was released in shows created by Steve Conrad.
won. But U.S. Army Capt. Miller’s June. Here, he recommends a series “I thought you really couldn’t get
unit has orders to locate PFC in which East meets West. better in the novel form of television
James Ryan and get him home be- “I absolutely have been in love with than ‘Breaking Bad’ and ‘Better Call
fore he becomes the fourth Ryan ‘Giri / Haji,’ a series that takes place in Saul’ or ‘Fargo.’ Then I stumbled upon
brother killed in action. The cap- England and Japan. It’s about a Tokyo two shows created by Steve Conrad—
tain, a Pennsylvania schoolteacher, cop who’s sent to London on a special also trying to do. I’m trying to create TV ‘Patriot,’ and ‘Perpetual Grace, LTD’ picture, what damage would that do to
must keep his team on mission mission to find someone who is hiding projects that really are a fusion of East (available on Amazon and Epix), which you psychologically? It is the show that
while they question the sense of there. He infiltrates the Japanese under- and West, and he sort of beat me to it he created with Bruce Terris. I’ve laughed the hardest at, that I’ve
risking eight men’s lives to save world that exists in London and meets and did it so beautifully. He was able to ‘Patriot’ is about an intelligence offi- cried over and that has kept me on the
one. When sharpshooter Jackson an amazing cast of characters who help authentically portray all these people in cer named John Tavner (Michael Dor- edge of my seat in every way.
complains the job is a waste of his him and become like family. a very real, very honest, beautiful way man) who’s also a folk singer. His psy- ‘Perpetual Grace, LTD’ is the same
skills, Capt. Miller jokes to the sol- It’s amazing fusion of East and West. that shows off differences in cultures, chosis from being a spy trips out into heart and the same mind, but this time
diers, “Pay attention to Jackson, There are Japanese characters who are but also the universal commonality in all folk songs. So you have essentially starring Ben Kingsley and Jimmi Simp-
this is the way to gripe.” A tragedy so authentically Japanese. And British of us. I don’t want to give away too James Bond going on stage in coffee son. It is about a con man running a
illustrates the peril of straying characters who are so authentically Brit- many spoilers, but there’s something so houses and pouring out his heart. It has church and someone trying to rip him
from the mission. “Get your gear. ish. I was just in awe watching it and spectacular that happens in the final ep- something I’ve thought about, which is off. Together, the two shows are just
Let’s go,” Capt. Miller tells the sol- also a little bit jealous. So much of what isode that takes it from a level of just that if you made the decision to for- the greatest things I’ve seen.”
diers after one of them nearly des- creator Joe Barton accomplished I’m great TV to absolute brilliance.” sake personal morality for the bigger —Chris Kornelis
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, July 9, 2020 | A11
cause of her. It is, but not entirely: Tyler Hoechlin (“Supergirl”), and
Cristin Milioti as Sarah and Andy Samberg as Nyles in ‘Palm Springs,’ streaming Friday on Hulu He’s reached the end of his rope while one is tempted to say they
on repeat viewings of his own life. have little to do but do it repeat-
So what’s the use of living at all, edly, that’s not really true: Each
TELEVISION REVIEW | JOHN ANDERSON Sarah asks him later, after a few time around the block for Sarah
too many reruns of her own day. and Nyles the landscape and the
‘Palm Springs’: ‘I Do,’ Again and Again “There might be some way to kill
yourself,” Nyles says, “but I ha-
ven’t figured it out yet.”
circumstances are changed (some-
times by them), and the actors
around them are really giving a
So they make the best of it, different performance each time.
BASED ON PURELY anecdotal evi- None of which is untrue, ex- Sarah (Cristin Milioti), screams, taunting the police, driving head- The sweet thing about “Palm
dence, the hunger for brainless but actly, and events do follow the disappears into a vortex of time on into a tractor-trailer, and steal- Springs” is what it says about
amusing content right now seems rom-com blueprint for at least 12 and space, and wakes up in the ing a plane and crashing it into the weddings, romance and perfect
very high, and “Palm Springs” minutes—with a riot of pre-nuptial morning. On the day of the same ground. The only repercussion is matches: As we see, Tala and Abe
would, at first glance, appear to sex; eye-rolling, cringe-inducing wedding. that they wake up, again, on the don’t really know each other well
qualify: Two guests at a destina- speeches at the reception; and “This is today,” Nyles explains day of the wedding. enough to get married. But are
tion wedding in the California des- small-caliber sniping between the to his bewildered and not-quite- For a few years, Mr. Samberg Sarah and Nyles meant for each
ert take a contemptuous attitude principals. Then a guy with a time-traveling companion. “Today was the Cast Member Who Over- other? You might say they have
toward everything they see, in- crossbow (J.K. Simmons) appears is yesterday. And tomorrow is also does Everything on “Saturday an eternity to find out.
cluding each other, but seem ulti- out of the darkness and plants a today. It’s one of those infinite Night Live,” a position held at one
mately destined to spend eternity few bolts in our hero, Nyles (Andy time-loop situations you might point or another by performers Palm Springs
together. Samberg), while his new frenemy, have heard about.” ranging from Chris Farley to Leslie Friday, Hulu
A12 | Thursday, July 9, 2020 * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
SPORTS
FRED KFOURY III/ICON SMI/ZUMA PRESS
The Harvard-Yale football rivalry will be put on hold until at least 2021 due to the pandemic. The Ivy League didn’t rule out the possibility of playing football and other fall sports in the spring.
OPINION
A Fourth of July Election BOOKSHELF | By William Anthony Hay
If you believe
every presi-
dential elec-
Alone, the pan-
demic or protests
would be enough
protesters are
voices of light (re-
ally), and the re-
Political Man,
tion is a big public drama to viving economy is
Pivotal Moment
C
a permanent path to the golf election. public is focused
course for the president. Gal- Let’s return to what was in beaten-down population pro- on finding an upside and an urrent debates about liberalism—especially about
lup’s most recent presidential the public’s mind before this, duced a hard-to-miss outpour- exit from what they’ve just whether a free society can thrive alongside ever more
approval number is 38%. specifically the Democrats’ ing of patriotism in towns been through. urgent calls for government action—bring to mind an
Yes, Mr. Trump needs to competition for the party’s across the U.S. Meanwhile, the Trump al- episode from the Edwardian era. It was then that the Liberal
put up an agenda for 2021. nomination. A special word here about ternative, Joe Biden, increas- Party in Britain underwent a kind of identity crisis over
And yes, there’s never been a It featured multiple debates, the traditional Macy’s fire- ingly looks like a man trapped policy and principle. Richard Burdon Haldane, later Viscount
president who can’t sleep if he saturation coverage and com- works display in New York inside a party that has gone Haldane, stands out as a key figure in that story. Haldane
hasn’t shot himself in the foot pelling figures in Bernie Sand- City. Recall that the chain’s from what are now the obvi- (1856-1928) was “a picture of the well-fed but poorly slept”
before turning out the lights. ers, Elizabeth Warren, Cory flagship in Herald Square was ously irrelevant primary votes lawyer, John Campbell says, a man who combined profes-
Booker and Pete Buttigieg (re- looted on June 9. Not a for moderation to the defining sional success and public service. Now largely forgotten,
member him?). And who won? month later, Macy’s and Uni- vision of the party’s protesters Haldane embodied a political type that is familiar to
Polls won’t tell you Joe Biden, because he was a versal Television produced a in the streets. On Wednesday Americans in the high-minded figures of the Progressive Era
known moderate and promised broadcast of almost unimagi- the Biden campaign released and in their descendants today, who possess an almost
how the beaten-down normalcy as respite from Mr. nable beauty, all-American the “Biden-Sanders Unity Task missionary zeal for human betterment.
American population Trump’s personality. music and patriotic fervor, Force” recommendations for In “Haldane: The Forgotten Statesman Who Shaped
Those primaries weren’t with stunning shots of the the Democratic platform. The Britain and Canada,” Mr. Campbell, an investment banker
will vote this year. opinion polls. They were a de- Statue of Liberty, the Coney document is 110 pages long. with childhood ties to Haldane’s family, makes a persuasive
cision by Democratic voters in Island Ferris wheel and fire- Every voter should read it. case for his subject’s importance and, along the way, touches
diverse states to choose mod- works shooting from the Hud- Coalitions may be shifting on larger questions of culture and governance. The book’s
Still, I’m not sure tradi- eration. Surely that counts for son River and Empire State beneath the weight of these structure—less chronological than propelled by themes and
tional metrics and analysis ap- something as an expression of Building. events. The people moving out causes—may challenge readers new to the story, but its
ply in this election. We are in the American mind. But if you tuned in to the of unsettled cities to the sub- wealth of detail and insightful character sketches will
a constantly shape-shifting By March 19, the coronavi- evening news Saturday or urbs may not be new Trumpi- reward the effort.
campaign that has been over- rus was shutting down the Sunday, it told a different ans, but they don’t sound like As Mr. Campbell shows,
whelmed by the unprece- country. Mr. Trump turned out story. You saw a catalog of enthusiastic Biden voters. Haldane’s family heritage
dented intensity of events and to be an unreliable guide to vi- weekend violence, killings and Since the surge of shootings, adumbrated his public role.
how people are processing the rus information, fumbling an more protests. Not least was some black leaders and pas- His English mother was
experience. opportunity for presidential the toppling in Rochester, N.Y., tors have pushed back against descended from an eminent
In mid-March, normal life leadership with his all-about- of a statue of Frederick Doug- police defunding. Tory jurist and lord chancellor
stopped in America. The me briefings. His coronavirus lass, a founding father of black We may have an October (a position Haldane would
workforce was sent home. approval among independent American pride. surprise every month until himself occupy). On his father’s
Schools were closed. Life went voters has been below 40% for These are times—and emo- November. The Durham report side, his grandfather and great-
on through Zoom and Google two months. tions—that don’t lend them- looms. There will be debates. uncle both retired from military
Hangouts. People got Covid-19, Amid all this downer-ism, selves to conventional politi- Mr. Trump could decide it’s service to promote the evangel-
and many died. something politically signifi- cal analysis. more important for him to ical movement in Scotland.
Then on May 25, George cant happened—the Fourth of For example, one may ask: pick fights with more Bubba Though strict Calvinism was at
Floyd died during an arrest in July weekend. Is never-Trumpism finally Wallaces than elaborate the the center of the family’s Scottish
Minneapolis. There have been On Friday, Mr. Trump deliv- overplaying its hand? With Mount Rushmore argument home, Haldane lost his faith as a
constant protests since, ered his Mount Rushmore the election near, the Trump- for his re-election. But we teenager. Over time, and perhaps
watched nightly by a stay-at- speech, a detailed, articulate wallowing media has decided don’t need a political reset. without realizing the change, he transformed it into a secular
home nation. They’ve seen defense of American history its commitment to “truth” re- The pandemic and the pro- commitment to reform and social progress.
monument smashing, CHOP in and values. The next day—af- quires distortions of reality, tests have been enough reset Haldane studied classics and philosophy at Edinburgh
Seattle and calls to defund the ter weeks of watching protests such as that his Mount Rush- for a generation. University, but his six months at Göttingen, in Germany,
police. and overturned statues—a more speech was “dark,” the Write henninger@wsj.com. had a greater effect. Idealist philosophy, with Hegel as its
leading figure, came to guide his worldview, as did German
social policies. His outlook was less empirical than that of
Democrats Are Committing Unforced Errors his English counterparts—more inclined to abstract
reasoning and arguing from first principles.
Even so, Haldane was a man of the world. After practicing
By Karl Rove measures. This passed the erybody. I think we should lis- Sanders and his allies to offer law in London and making a good deal of money, he was
A
Senate by unanimous consent ten to the argument there.” unity. This could be another elected to Parliament in 1885—at a pivotal moment, as Mr.
s the mainstream media in 2018 but died in the House. When a prospective Demo- opening for the GOP, but it Campbell shows. The Liberal Party had dominated British
all but declares the By pressing for the Scott cratic running mate says must seize it effectively. politics since 1830, but tensions among its members were
2020 election for Joe Bi- bill now and the Cornyn-Peters Americans should consider re- Then there’s Mr. Biden’s re- growing even before William Gladstone split the party in
den, Democrats are making commission to follow, Republi- moving statues of the man sponse to “America First.” The 1886 over Irish Home Rule.
mistakes. They’re saying and cans can show they’re deter- who made our country possi- former vice president says Mr. Campbell describes Haldane as a living embodiment
doing things that could cause mined to turn the nation’s pain ble, the party is surrendering that “when America is first, of such tensions—between an older liberalism of laissez-faire
problems—if Republicans step into something good. If every- to its lunatic fringe. The it’s America alone.” This isn’t economics and limited government and a new kind, which re-
up their game. body mobilizes, the GOP can Trump campaign put out a surprising from someone sponded to the rising spirit of socialism and organized labor.
Consider the congressional regain the offensive. statement Tuesday, but the whose administration prac- (It was around this time that Marx’s ideas were being popu-
logjam over police reform. Af- Another opening for Repub- moment was worthy of an im- ticed “leading from behind” larized in England.) The young politician sought a rationally
ter George Floyd’s death in licans came Sunday, when mediate presidential state- and undertook an interna- organized state along German lines, what his friend Beatrice
Minneapolis, the nation was CNN’s Dana Bash asked Sen. ment and sustained criticism. tional apology tour. Republi- Webb called “a deliberately organized society.” Haldane’s lib-
angry and aghast. Then Ray- Tammy Duckworth—who’s be- It would have been a better cans can counter that America eralism went beyond the ideals of an earlier Liberal Party,
shard Brooks was killed in At- ing vetted as a possible run- way to start the week than at- First means putting workers, which had sought to minimize the state’s checks on individ-
lanta, and the demand for ning mate for Mr. Biden—if tacking Nascar driver Bubba families and communities ual action. He preferred to follow Wilhelm von Humboldt’s
change grew even stronger. statues of George Washington Wallace and defending the first. Besides, the world de- idea that government intervention, especially in education,
Yet when the Senate moved Confederate flag. pends on America leading the helped citizens cultivate themselves. He thought property
to take up the comprehensive There was also Mr. Biden’s way. The GOP can point to Mr. owed a debt to society for guaranteeing the wealth it earned.
police reform bill introduced Republicans must Sunday tweet: “We won’t just Trump’s successes on trade, While this new liberalism inspired Haldane and his colleagues
by Tim Scott (R., S.C.), Demo- rebuild this nation—we’ll getting allies to step up on to press for costly social reforms, it drove others toward the
crats blocked its consider- seize the opportunities transform it.” The former vice military spending, and U.S. Conservative Party.
ation, despite the bill’s many to regain the offensive president won his party’s nom- toughness in dealing with Iran
similarities with the Demo- ination because he seemed to and China, contrasting these
cratic House’s measure. Sen. in the campaign. be a mainstream Democrat. He with Obama-Biden failures. He found his party moving from the idea of
Scott guaranteed votes on any draws support from indepen- So much of this campaign limited government to a new agenda, one aimed
amendments Democrats dents and some conservatives has been nontraditional. Amer-
wanted, but no matter. should be taken down. For 141 for the same reason. He won’t ica’s attention has been riveted at responding to the rising spirit of socialism.
This intransigence is an op- tortured words, Ms. Duckworth keep it if he pushes “transfor- on the pandemic, economic
portunity to argue that Senate ducked the question before mation,” the pet phrase of Sen. fallout and racial tensions.
Democrats are more interested claiming President Trump Bernie Sanders and Rep. Alex- That has benefited Mr. Biden, Early in his career, Haldane helped establish the London
in election talking points than “spent all his time talking andria Ocasio-Cortez. as the polls attest. But the 77- School of Economics, and he guided the University of
giving meaning to the deaths about dead traitors” in his July One tweet does not a melt- year-old isn’t an imposing po- London toward its becoming a true teaching institution.
of Floyd, Brooks, Breonna Tay- 3 speech at Mount Rushmore. down make, but it could fore- litical talent—this will become He advised colleges in provincial cities to extend their
lor and others by passing leg- Actually, Mr. Trump didn’t shadow trouble. On Wednesday clearer as the campaign un- access to a wider range of students and social classes, and
islation that reforms policing. mention a single Confederate, Mr. Biden’s six “unity task folds—and he and his compa- he drew on German models to improve technical education.
Republicans can broaden but the Illinois Democrat may forces” released recommenda- triots regularly provide ammu- Oddly, though, it was in military matters that Haldane’s leg-
the issue by pointing out that have hoped an incendiary at- tions that will shape his plat- nition for Republican attacks. If acy is most notable. When, in 1905, a Liberal prime minister—
while a new law can solve cer- tack would distract Ms. Bash. form. Though Mr. Sanders had the GOP wants victory this fall, Henry Campbell-Bannerman—reached an impasse with his
tain pressing problems, the The interviewer pressed a seat at the table, he didn’t it had better figure out how to party’s grandees, he offered Haldane the War Office, hoping
criminal-justice system needs again, saying “but George get his way on several issues, exploit this. Time’s a-wasting. that “Schopenhauer,” as he called him, could manage what
a systematic review. A bill by Washington—I don’t think including Medicare for All. He was viewed as the cabinet’s most thankless job. The post
Sens. John Cornyn (R., Texas) anybody would call him a trai- and other leading progressives Mr. Rove helped organize gave Haldane plenty to reform. He restructured the army to
and Gary Peters (D., Mich.) tor. And there are moves by won’t stop pressing socialist the political-action committee cut costs and created an expeditionary force that could be
creating a National Criminal some to remove statues of nostrums simply because American Crossroads and is quickly sent abroad with reserves at home to reinforce it. He
Justice Commission would do him. Is that a good idea?” Ms. they’ve been promised good in- author of “The Triumph of also created a General Staff to facilitate planning. These
that, reporting to the next Duckworth responded blandly, augural tickets. It may take fur- William McKinley” (Simon & changes helped Britain stop the German invasion of France in
Congress on additional reform “I think we should listen to ev- ther policy concessions for Mr. Schuster, 2015). 1914 and led Sir Douglas Haig to call Haldane “the greatest
secretary of war England ever had.”
A career capstone came with Haldane’s elevation to lord
These Days, It All Feels Like Yesterday chancellor in 1912—the head of Britain’s legal system. As a long-
time member of the judicial committee of the privy council,
which heard appeals from the empire’s dominions, he played
By Peter Funt I remember the last meal I neutral ones. Something as sim- Research has shown that the a “leading role” in shaping the development of Canadian law,
L
ate in a restaurant: with my ple as the last time I got a hair- act of remembering is fre- according to Mr. Campbell. For a time, his knowledge of
ike many people, I’m wife, our daughter and our cut (Feb. 12) now qualifies as an quently enhanced by forgetting. Germany, and fluency in the language, gave him a liaison role.
usually better with long- son-in-law, at Zero Zero on emotional benchmark, because We clear space in our minds by After Wilhelm II asked him to join a meeting with the kaiser’s
term memories than the Folsom Street in San Fran- I have no idea when I’ll again replacing older memories with ministers, he joked about Haldane’s being the only Englishman
short-term kind. Mention cisco. It was March 6. The day feel safe visiting my barber. more recent occurrences. Right to sit in a German cabinet. But tensions with Berlin made his
sports, and I’ll deliver details my friends and I had our last For people with a rare con- now there is a lot that I look position difficult. On a visit to London, the kaiser invited
about the time I hit a homer in dition known as hyperthyme- forward to forgetting. himself to lunch at Haldane’s home, intensifying doubt about
high school: the look on the sia, the trivia has always been My short-term memory his loyalty—“doubt that would, in time of war, bury Haldane’s
pitcher’s face when he released Our last haircut and impossible to shake. For them, does seem to have improved reputation and political career,” Mr. Campbell writes.
the ball, the sight of my man- dinner out bear a new every detail of every day—pan- during the pandemic. Mention If Haldane’s career anticipated later technocrats and
ager jumping up and down in demic or not—is remembered a date, any date, since mid- reformists, as Mr. Campbell argues in this splendid portrait,
the coach’s box as I rounded emotional weight. in vivid detail. Mention a date, March, and I’ll be able to tell World War I made him an outsider in the Britain of his day.
third. no matter how long ago, and you the color sweatpants I After the war, few looked to Germany for models of any
Lately, however, I’m dwell- they’ll tell you what they were wore, when I walked out to the kind. Despite his sociability, Haldane, with his Continental
ing on lesser things from the baseball practice in the park: wearing that day or what they mailbox, and what I saw on my orientation and intellectual bent, never quite fit Britain’s
fairly recent past. The memo- March 11. The last time I saw had for lunch. The actress walk around the neighborhood. political culture. In retrospect, he seems more akin to
ries seem distant, yet they’ve my son: March 1. I dropped Marilu Henner has this condi- Memories like these are John Dewey and other Progressive leaders in America
barely gone by. Sheltered in a him two blocks from the rail tion, which is stressful because easier to preserve when noth- than aligned with the British liberal tradition—which may
pandemic, new memories are station in Stamford, Conn., so it creates an overdose of use- ing changes. account for why, though his accomplishments have lasted,
hard to come by—and the ones he could run for the train. less memories. Now we all the man himself has faded from view.
I’m stuck with are mighty Emotionally charged events have a better idea how people Mr. Funt is a writer and
mundane. are easier to remember than like Ms. Henner feel. host of “Candid Camera.” Mr. Hay is the author of “Lord Liverpool: A Political Life.”
A14 | Thursday, July 9, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Religious Liberty Lives at the High Court Military Bases, Ships, Heroes and Traitors
R
eligious Americans sometimes fear that of the church’s teachings. Regarding Rep. Mike Garcia’s Confederate generals after whom 10
intolerant secular progressives will soon Justice Neil Gorsuch’s opinion in Bostock dis- “Name Bases For Heroes, Not Trai- Army bases are named. Those bases
tors” (op-ed, July 3): If Matthew Fon- were built during the World Wars and
try to ruin them for holding traditional missed such concerns with a pat line about how
taine Maury was a traitor, then George named in the spirit of Lincoln’s inten-
views. They can take heart in a those “are questions for future Washington and the signers of the tion of binding up the nation’s
pair of 7-2 rulings Wednesday In two 7-2 rulings, the cases.” There will be a blizzard Declaration of Independence were also wounds by showing respect for South-
from the Supreme Court, in Supreme Court upholds of them, no doubt. It’s a hope- traitors. Maury renounced his alle- ern valor and sacrifice in the Civil
which the Justices upheld con- ful sign for religious liberty giance to the U.S.; Washington re- War, not to exonerate the South for
science protections for nuns conscience protections. that even liberal Justices Ste- nounced his allegiance to King George waging an insurrection to defend slav-
and parochial schools. phen Breyer and Elena Kagan III. Maury was neither a slave owner ery. Fair-minded Northerners recog-
The issue in the first opin- joined the Guadalupe majority nor a proponent of slavery. His views nized that although the Southern
ion, Our Lady of Guadalupe School v. Morrissey- to expand the ministerial exception. of slavery were very similar to those cause was tainted by rebellion and
Berru, was whether two teachers could sue for The second opinion Wednesday, Little Sisters of Abraham Lincoln, who would have slavery, its soldiers and commanders
discrimination after Catholic schools didn’t renew of the Poor v. Pennsylvania, involved employers accepted slavery to preserve the merited esteem.
Union, and whose views would un- Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr.,
their contracts. In 2012 the Court in Hosanna-Ta- who object to providing contraceptives under a
questionably be considered racist to- who was twice wounded in battle and
bor said a fourth-grade teacher could not sue her mandate from ObamaCare. The Little Sisters, an day. Maury is honored by the Navy not supported abolition, wrote: “We be-
Lutheran school. She was covered by a “ministe- order of Catholic nuns, have been fighting this because he was a Confederate but be- lieved that it was most desirable that
rial exception,” based on the First Amendment for years. The Trump Administration put forth cause he was a great scientist with the North should win. We believed in
right of churches to be free of government med- regulations in 2017 and 2018 to expand exemp- long and distinguished service in the the principle that the Union is indis-
dling. That teacher had religious training and a tions for employers with good-faith objections. U.S. Navy. soluble. We, or many of us at least,
formal title as a commissioned minister. Pennsylvania and New Jersey sued, calling it an Rep. Garcia claims to read history. also believed that the conflict was in-
How far does the ministerial exception reach? abuse of discretion. Yet he never seems to have asked him- evitable and that slavery had lasted
In Guadalupe, the two teachers at Catholic ele- Not so, wrote Justice Clarence Thomas for the self how he would have thought and long enough. But we equally believed
mentary schools prayed in class, instructed stu- Court’s five conservatives. The Affordable Care acted had he been in the shoes of the those who stood against us held just
men he condemns, and he attempts to as sacred convictions that were the
dents in doctrine, and took them to Mass. They Act’s text doesn’t mention contraceptives here,
draw a wholly unhistorical and illu- opposite of ours, and we respected
had less-substantial religious training, however, but rather empowers the executive branch to de- sory line between “traitors” and “true them, as any man with a heart must
and no special titles. cide what preventive health coverage is manda- heroes.” When the left comes for the respect those who give all for their
“What matters, at bottom, is what an em- tory. That “capacious grant of authority,” Justice true heroes, as they already have, he belief.” Tragically, the humanity of
ployee does,” wrote Justice Samuel Alito for the Thomas wrote, includes “the ability to identify will discover that he has no principled Lincoln and Holmes has become a ca-
majority. Focusing on clerical titles “would risk and create exemptions.” position from which to defend them. sualty of our hyperemotional political
privileging religious traditions with formal orga- This is a victory, but a narrow one. Justice Ka- JON JEWETT times.
nizational structures.” An amicus brief by Jew- gan concurred in the judgment, joined by Justice Ashland, Va. THOMAS L. PURVIS
ish organizations, for example, said that “Juda- Breyer. But as the case moves back to lower Independence, Ky.
ism has many ‘ministers.’” The same problem courts, she wrote, the Trump Administration’s Abraham Lincoln’s hope was that
applies with trying to use religious training as opt out might “prove arbitrary and capricious.” the nation be reunited by treating the Perhaps, as a student of history,
vanquished South “with malice to- Rep. Garcia should read President Lin-
a key distinction. That reads like an invitation to keep the Sisters
ward none, with charity for all.” In- coln’s Second Inaugural Address again
The ministerial exception is not subject to a in court. Justices Alito and Gorsuch signed a stead, the woke progressives’ rancor- and think about the president’s mean-
“rigid formula,” Justice Alito wrote, citing Ho- concurrence saying they also would have held ous contempt for all things Southern ing.
sanna-Tabor. The teachers here clearly “per- for the Sisters under the Religious Freedom Res- only serves to incite malice toward all STEPHEN WEEKS
formed vital religious duties,” and their schools toration Act, which would end their “legal odys- and charity for none, especially the Houston
“expressly saw them as playing a vital part in sey.” But progressives today exhibit a growing
carrying out the mission of the church.” hostility to religion, and they are likely to pursue
Don’t forget the context. Last month’s ruling the nuns to the end of the legal earth.
in Bostock v. Clayton County extended federal A President Biden would be under pressure No Plot by Venezuela’s Interim Government
antidiscrimination law to sexual orientation from the left to undo protections for religious
and transgender status. A religious school in employers, so the fight could start anew in 2021. As Venezuela’s ambassador to the Maduro regime where innocent Vene-
U.S., I write regarding “Venezuelan zuelans were scammed to shock the
progressive California might worry about be- A question for Joe Biden: How much do you want
Opposition Politician Led Planning to international community and divert
ing sued for dismissing a lay math teacher who to force Catholic nuns to violate their conscience Topple Maduro” (World News, June attention from the crippling, complex
began living a proudly gay lifestyle in defiance to appease the secular left? 27) instead of Leopoldo López, coordi- humanitarian emergency generated by
nator of the National Government the dictatorship in Venezuela.
W
duro regime continues to deny both Venezuela from the dictatorship that
ashington is mulling a variety of jing’s hands. The United Kingdom and other his freedom of speech and freedom of oppresses our rights, pilfers our na-
ways to punish Beijing for violating countries recognize that one effective way to movement. The article put him at even tional resources, kidnaps our demo-
Hong Kong’s autonomy. But one new push back against Beijing’s imposition of a dra- greater risk. Less than one day after cratic institutions and tortures and
idea should be off the table: the story was published, the regime kills its political opponents. We re-
conian security law is to allow
Weaponizing the dollar Hong Kongers to emigrate. used it to attack and slander Mr. Ló- main resolute in our effort to disman-
weaponizing the U.S. dollar to pez and pressure the Spanish govern- tle the worst dictatorship that the re-
undermine Hong Kong’s cur- to hurt Hong Kong Washington can do its part by ment to hand him over to the dictator- gion has ever suffered. We are fighting
rency. avoiding a crippling deprecia- ship. This is not only a risk to Mr. for 9.3 million people who are starv-
News reports Tuesday sug- would backfire. tion of the Hong Kong dollar López but also to thousands of activ- ing; for 5.1 million people who have
gested some Administration that would wipe out emigres’ ists of the Voluntad Popular, one of fled the country; for more than 15,000
officials are contemplating savings as they leave. the foundational allies of the interim people who, like Leopoldo, have suf-
cutting off Hong Kong banks’ access to U.S. dol- The bigger risk from such economic warfare government. fered arbitrary detention and torture.
lar funding. The aim would be to undermine the is to the U.S. Washington derives enormous in- We want to reaffirm that no mem- We are fighting for a country that de-
Hong Kong dollar, which since 1983 has been fluence from the free convertibility of the ber from Interim President Juan serves freedom and opportunity.
fixed to the U.S. dollar at a rate of about 7.8 greenback, which allows governments, institu- Guaidó’s government is linked to or CARLOS VECCHIO
participated in the false-flag operation Ambassador of the Bolivarian
Hong Kong dollars to $1. tions and individuals to use the dollar as a
“Gideon,” including Leopoldo López. It Republic of Venezuela
That peg is a currency board, which means global reserve currency. was an operation infiltrated by the Washington
that every single Hong Kong dollar in circula- The dollar’s global reach is why financial
tion is backed by around 13 cents held in a vault sanctions bite countries such as Iran and North
at the Hong Kong Monetary Authority. To main- Korea on the relatively rare occasions Washing-
tain the system, the HKMA and banks must be ton does cut off access to dollars. That influence
Cuomo’s Covid Response Was Never so Great
able to freely buy and sell U.S. dollars as de- also offers the Trump Administration better It’s hard to believe that anyone this has anything to do with pan-
mand for Hong Kong dollars rises or falls. Un- ways to impose financial penalties on Beijing, would attempt to defend New York demic response.
like mainland China’s currency, the yuan, Hong such as Magnitsky-style sanctions targeted at Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s ill-fated March It took until May 10 for Gov. Cuomo,
Kong’s money is stable and freely convertible, individual officials involved in human-rights 25 directive on returning Covid-in- facing increasing scrutiny from even
and has been the backbone of the territory’s abuses. fected patients to nursing homes (“On his political allies, to reverse his dev-
the Whole, Cuomo’s Managed Covid astating order.
prosperity for decades. The more creatively Washington wants to
Well,” Letters, July 2). The excuse of- ROBERT L. SMIALEK
That should be reason enough for the Trump think about how to hold Beijing accountable, fered by the letter writers and the Dublin, Ohio
Administration to leave the Hong Kong dollar the better. But the Administration should take Cuomo administration is that “a deci-
alone. The victims of any disturbance to the care to play to American strengths rather than sion was forced by the rapidly over-
currency board would be the people of Hong undermining them in the process. One of the whelming demand for hospital space Massive Drug Advertising
Kong, who are already suffering enough at Bei- biggest strengths is a fully convertible dollar. in New York for seriously ill patients.”
Then why were the emergency facili-
Budgets, Prices and R&D
Bonfire of the Liberals
ties set up around New York City never John Stanford’s argument that
fully used? Did we fear that President “Price Controls Would Throttle Bio-
Trump, who spared no effort to mobi- medical Innovation” (op-ed, July 2) is
A
merica’s liberal intelligentsia thought denying having signed it) and asked that her lize public and private resources, a tired, old, specious argument de-
might get some positive press? signed to scare the health-consuming
the election of Donald Trump meant name be removed. Others may yet face conse- The Javits Center was never fully public. The R&D budget is actually
America would re-enact “1984,” but it’s quences. Matt Yglesias, a co-founder of the mil- occupied and was shut down in early often smaller than the budget for
starting to look more like lennial progressive website May, as was the USNS Comfort. The marketing—those annoying ads on
“Homage to Catalonia,” A defense of free speech Vox, was among the signato- Samaritan’s Purse field hospital expe- the nightly news which advise you to
George Orwell’s account of the leads to recriminations wrote ries. One of his colleagues rienced a similar fate, accelerated by tell your doctor if you have tubercu-
left’s internecine savagery in an open letter to the resistance from local politicians who losis or cancer before she prescribes
during the Spanish Civil War. on the left. publication’s editors that be- couldn’t abide Franklin Graham’s sup- you the product. We need to go back
Witness the spectacular on- cause the Harper’s letter was port for traditional marriage, as if to the days (mid ’90s) when advertis-
line meltdown that followed a signed by “several prominent ing drugs directly to the public was
liberal open letter opposing left-wing attacks anti-trans voices” Mr. Yglesias’s signature banned. The money saved could re-
on free speech. “makes me feel less safe at Vox.” Scholars From Elementary duce the costs of drugs and increase
R&D. Of course, this wouldn’t be
“A Letter on Justice and Open Debate,” pub- Tom Wolfe couldn’t have devised a more pun- School Reunite in Print good for Mr. Stanford, the venture
lished Tuesday by Harper’s, opens with anti- gent satire of mutual recriminations among lib- Walter Russell Mead’s review of capitalist.
Trump throat-clearing. It then accurately de- eral elites. There is a significant layer of hypoc- William A. Darity Jr. and A. Kirsten MICHAEL CUMMINGS, M.D.
scribes the ferocious campaign of coerced risy here; many free-speech liberals tolerate left- Mullen’s “From Here to Equality” New Smyrna Beach, Fla.
conformity sweeping America’s liberal institu- wing mobs when their furies are aimed at (Bookshelf, June 18) is filled with in-
tions as they purge dissent from the hard-left conservatives. But now that the purge of conser- teresting and important historical de-
line. “Editors are fired for running controversial vatives from America’s flagship intellectual insti- tails. Here is one more: Walter Mead Pepper ...
pieces; books are withdrawn for alleged inau- tutions is almost complete, new enemies are and “Sandy” Darity were classmates
at Glenwood Elementary School in
And Salt
thenticity; journalists are barred from writing needed, and it’s no surprise that the left is de-
on certain topics; professors are investigated scending into mutual back-stabbing. Chapel Hill, N.C., during the early THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
1960s. Mr. Darity was the first Afri-
for quoting works of literature in class,” says Our hope is that the moderate elements can
can-American to attend the formerly
the statement signed by more than 150 writers fend off the woke attack. Society benefits when all-white public school and often the
and academics. both its left and right coalitions accept basic smartest student in class; Mr. Mead
The online left, which can’t decide whether free-speech principles. Yet if the intolerance was a budding intellectual, who ri-
left-wing censorship is a myth invented by its turns out to be self-perpetuating and unstoppa- valed Mr. Darity for the top grades.
enemies or a necessary tactic for destroying ble, we have a humble suggestion for any remain- After more than a half-century of suc-
them, erupted at the betrayal. Jennifer Finney ing signatories of the Harper’s letter: Consider cess and contributions from each of
Boylan, a frequent New York Times contributor a political belief system that is not premised on them, it’s fun to see Walter and
who had signed the letter, pleaded for forgive- the transformation of society, that is built on the Sandy’s lives intersect again.
ness on Twitter. She had not realized that not sanctity of traditional rights, and that abhors the PETER BARNES
Chapel Hill, N.C.
all the signatories were of the caliber of the so- certainty of revolutionary vanguards.
cialist intellectual Noam Chomsky, she wrote. In the 1970s a handful of intellectuals, ap-
Letters intended for publication
“The consequences,” she added, “are mine to palled by the left’s viciousness and anti-Ameri- should be emailed to wsj.ltrs@wsj.com.
bear. I am so sorry.” canism, became neoconservatives and helped Please include your city, state and
A Tufts University historian, Kerri usher in decades of better governance. Maybe telephone number. All letters are sub-
Greenidge, tweeted that she did “not endorse” the conditions will soon be right for something ject to editing, and unpublished letters “And I’m telling you the curtains
cannot be acknowledged.
the counterrevolutionary document (without similar to happen again. always looked like that.”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, July 9, 2020 | A15
OPINION
W
and producing the lowest unemploy- tion of the economy.
ment rates on record for blacks, His- But now Democratic leaders want e are commercial rivals, but
panics, single women, the disabled to use the economic destruction of we’re united in the recogni-
and those with criminal records. the pandemic shutdown as an oppor- tion that, while Covid-19
Wages at the bottom were growing tunity to implement a leftist agenda, holds center stage today, another
faster than at the top. The once-disap- with enormous new taxes, federal potentially devastating pandemic is
pearing middle class was prospering control of the health-care system, looming, and a joint effort by bio-
PHIL FOSTER
and propagating again. According to crippling energy mandates, a bailout pharmaceutical companies is needed
the United Nations, the birthrate in of profligate states and cities, and an to address it. Antimicrobial resis-
the U.S. had started to rise for the overpowering regulatory state. Mr. tance is a growing health threat
first time in the 21st century. In short, Biden is the face of the Democratic that kills some 35,000 Americans
the postwar prosperity that we feared nary number given the president’s ipation has risen by 1.1% under Mr. Party, but Elizabeth Warren, Bernie and 700,000 people globally each
had been lost forever was coming overall disapproval rating of 51%. Trump while it fell by an astounding Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cor- year, with world-wide deaths pro-
home to America. The best of times for America 4.6% under Mr. Obama. tez are its heart. Their proposals go jected at 10 million annually in 30
were the worst of times for those In the first three years of the well beyond doubling down on a big- years.
whose rallying cries of class warfare Trump administration, total employ- government approach that didn’t Antibiotic-resistant “superbugs”
Before the shutdown, the increasingly rang hollow. When they ment was up 4.7% and real median work; they are to the left of any gov- have evolved to resist antibiotic
could no longer deny prosperity, household income was up $4,384, to erning socialist party in Europe. medicines, leaving the world almost
economy was booming. they claimed credit for it. President an all-time high. Who benefited The task of government in the as vulnerable as it was before the
Credit Trump’s policies, Obama congratulated himself on most? The groups Democrats claim next four years will be to rebuild the discovery of penicillin. We rely on
Twitter for his 2009 stimulus that to represent: blacks, Hispanics, sin- economy. The decision in November the availability of effective antibiot-
not Obama and Biden’s. paved “the way for more than a de- gle women, Native Americans, high- is which road leads to American ics to treat patients with conditions
cade of economic growth.” school dropouts, the disabled and prosperity. We tried a little socialism
But facts are stubborn things. Un- those with criminal records. Each of 12 years ago, and it produced stagna-
By January the Congressional der Mr. Obama’s policies of tax, those groups enjoyed the lowest un- tion and a failed recovery. Can we Without new medications,
Budget Office reported that the tax spend and regulate, real per capita employment rates on record. Blacks realistically expect that a lot more
cuts predicted to blow a hole in the income was up by only 5.6% and job and Hispanics had the lowest inci- socialism will work for us now? antibiotic-resistant germs
deficit had generated enough addi- growth was up only 5% some nine dence of poverty ever recorded. Unlike most elections, we have could kill 30 million a year
tional growth to add $7.4 trillion to years after the start of the 2007-09 Then the pandemic and shutdown more than promises to inform us.
gross domestic product over the next recession. Compare that with 21% in- hit. From the lowest unemployment We have 12 years of accumulated world-wide by 2050.
10 years, raising average annual per come growth and 18% job growth un- rate in 50 years, America suffered evidence on the performance of
capita income by $2,250. Over the der President Clinton nine years af- the highest rate in 88 years. Joe Bi- these two competing visions. If
next decade, that increased growth ter the start of the 1990-91 recession, den claims Mr. Trump has “squan- presidential elections are about re- ranging from root canals and cancer
is projected to generate $700 billion or 24% income growth and 20% job dered” the Obama-Biden recovery. sults, let the guide be the biblical to Covid-related infections—leaving
more in state and local taxes and an growth under President Reagan nine He blames banks and businesses, ig- admonition: “Ye shall know them by nearly every aspect of our health
additional $1.438 trillion of new fed- years after the start of the 1981-82 noring that the government ordered their fruits.” system at risk. As insulin develop-
eral revenue, offsetting the tax cut’s recession. Real median weekly wages the shutdown that crippled the ers and manufacturers, we are par-
projected 10-year cost of $1.456 tril- have risen six times as much in three strong recovery. Mr. Biden wants “to Mr. Gramm is a former chairman ticularly concerned for the 34.2 mil-
lion. Gallup found that President years under Mr. Trump’s policies as transform” the economy, beginning of the Senate Banking Committee. lion Americans with diabetes, who
Trump’s economic approval rating they did in eight years under Mr. with a repeal of Mr. Trump’s tax cuts Mr. Solon is a partner of U.S. Policy are highly vulnerable to infections
was 63% in January, an extraordi- Obama’s policies. Labor-force partic- and deregulatory program. Metrics. that can be lethal without effective
antibiotics.
Unfortunately, few companies
Libya’s Foul Foretaste of the Post-American World produce antibiotics that fight super-
bugs. That must change, which is
why 20 leading pharmaceutical com-
Does Libya show us taking their recent setback lying The war also underlines the weak- port for Hamas angers Israel. Its panies have formed the $1 billion
the future of world down. Russia and Syria are sending ness of the Sunni Arab world and its purchase of the Russian S-400 mis- AMR Action Fund to combat antimi-
politics? seasoned mercenaries from the Syr- need for a strong relationship with sile system infuriated the U.S. And crobial resistance by supporting the
U.S. engagement ian battlefields to defend the oil. De- Israel. That the Emirates, Egypt and by threatening to turn Hagia Sophia development of new antibiotics.
there has been mini- spite a U.N. arms embargo, both Saudi Arabia can’t control political (one of the holiest sites in Eastern Despite the threat of AMR, new
mal since a 2012 ter- sides continue to receive supplies. developments in nearby Libya illus- Orthodoxy) back into a mosque, antibiotics are used sparingly to
rorist attack killed trates the depth of the Arab crisis. President Recep Tayyip Erdogan is slow the development of resistance.
GLOBAL
four Americans, in- These states also failed to steer the picking a quarrel with Russia. Under While this makes sense for public
VIEW
By Walter
cluding the ambas- Amid the chaos, the EU, course of the Syrian war or prevent normal circumstances this would health, it doesn’t create a viable
sador, and trauma- Lebanon’s collapse. They need allies look like a suicidal policy mix, espe- marketplace. This leaves only a few
Russell Mead
tized the Obama NATO and the Arab world to balance both Turkey and Iran, and cially for a country with a weak cur- antibiotic candidates languishing in
administration. In are all divided over which as the U.S. withdraws, Israel is the rency and other economic problems. the pipeline, while developers, con-
America’s absence, over half a dozen only real option they have. But Mr. Erdogan clearly thinks he fronted with the high cost of drug
powers are struggling to control warlords to support. All this—plus the growing evi- sees a Mediterranean power vacuum, development, scramble for financing.
Libya’s future, carving up its terri- dence that Vladimir Putin’s financial and he’s seizing the chance to fill it. In recent years, several antibiotic-fo-
tory, and subsidizing militias and and political troubles are growing in Finally, the Libyan war shows that cused biotechs have declared bank-
warlords as they compete for control It is hard to predict what will hap- the wake of the Covid pandemic and a “post-American” world, one in ruptcy or exited the field.
over its oil and gas. No end to the pen next, other than that the inno- the oil-price collapse—helps explain which the U.S. retreats from its post- What we urgently need now is
war is in sight. cent and the weak will suffer horrifi- the boldness of Turkey’s recent pol- World War II policy of global en- collective leadership, from both in-
On one side Turkey and Qatar, cally as the factions and their icy moves. Ankara has crossed the gagement, is unlikely to be peaceful. dustry and governments, to solve
with some discreet Italian cheerlead- sponsors roll the dice. But the im- EU by exploring for gas in waters Zero-sum power games, weakening the antibiotic innovation challenge
ing, back the Tripoli-based warlords portance of this war is less about claimed by Cyprus. Its alliance with institutions, cynical power grabs: and ensure that we have effective
and affiliated tribal leaders whom who wins than what it reveals about Qatar puts it in direct opposition to More of the world will start looking medications.
the United Nations has anointed the the state of the world. Saudi Arabia and its friends. Its sup- like Libya and Syria. In 2018 Novo Holdings launched
“legitimate” government of Libya, The first point is that the U.N. is the Repair Impact Fund (an acro-
the so-called Government of National increasingly losing its moral legiti- nym for Replenishing and Enabling
Accord, or GNA. On the side of the
challenger coalition of tribal leaders
and warlords stand France, Russia,
macy and political relevance. That
France and Russia, both permanent
members of the Security Council, feel
I Cited Their Study, the Pipeline for Anti-Infective Resis-
tance) to invest $165 million in com-
panies involved in early-stage devel-
the United Arab Emirates and Egypt.
The latter coalition is led most visi-
bly by Khalifa Haftar, a rogue field
no qualms about supporting the reb-
els against the U.N.-backed govern-
ment speaks volumes about the place
So They Disavowed It opment of therapies targeting
resistant micro-organisms. Similar
investments, including the $500
marshal who heads what he calls the of international law in the world. The By Heather Mac Donald his administrative position. PNAS ed- million CARB-X (Combating Antibi-
T
Libyan National Army. 2011 Western intervention in Libya itorialized that Messrs. Cesario and otic-Resistant Bacteria) initiative—
No higher principles are at stake. was intended to take international he Proceedings of the Na- Johnson had “poorly framed” their led by Boston University and funded
Neither side stands for anything law to new heights by enshrining the tional Academy of Sciences is article—the one that got through the by the U.S. government and the
more noble than its own security and “responsibility to protect” civilians a peer-reviewed journal that journal’s three levels of editorial and Wellcome Trust, among others—
power. The GNA isn’t fighting for from mass atrocities. Instead, cynical claims to publish “only the highest peer review. have revitalized the early-stage
freedom, Islam, U.N. legitimacy or and lawless calculation is enshrined quality scientific research.” Now, Mr. Cesario told this page that pipeline and created several promis-
any cause greater than its right to as the new normal. the authors of a 2019 PNAS article Mr. Hsu’s dismissal could narrow ing approaches. But these efforts
make as much money as possible The war also reveals the West’s are disowning their research simply the “kinds of topics people can talk face a lack of investors willing to
selling hydrocarbons while taxing growing divisions. Two North Atlan- because I cited it. about, or what kinds of conclusions shoulder the high costs and risks of
the human traffickers and arms tic Treaty Organization allies (Tur- Psychologists Joseph Cesario of people can come to.” Now he and the complex and expensive later
smugglers operating in the country’s key and Italy) back the GNA. Two Michigan State and David Johnson Mr. Johnson have themselves jeop- stages of development. Without
chaos. The rebels want pretty much more, Greece and France, stand with of the University of Maryland ana- ardized the possibility of politically funding and partnership today, and
the same thing. Mr. Haftar. A fifth, Britain, tilts to- lyzed 917 fatal police shootings of neutral scholarship. On Monday the prospect of some return tomor-
In the most recent fighting, the ward the Turks. This isn’t how civilians from 2015 to test whether they retracted their paper. They say row, these products will wither on
beleaguered GNA has been able to healthy alliances work. the race of the officer or the civilian they stand behind its conclusion the vine.
beat back Mr. Haftar’s forces, driving Another casualty of the Libyan predicted fatal police shootings. and statistical approach but com- Recognizing this gap, the AMR
them from the outskirts of Tripoli war: any sense of a joint foreign pol- Neither did. Once “race specific plain about its “misuse,” specifically Action Fund was formed by nearly
toward the central coastal city of icy from the European Union. Few rates of violent crime” are taken mentioning my op-eds. two dozen leading pharma manufac-
Sirte, which the government vows to places in the world matter more to into account, the authors found, The authors don’t say how I mis- turers and will support development
recapture. If Sirte falls, the GNA will Europe than its Mediterranean there are no disparities among used their work. Instead, they attri- of the most promising antibiotics.
be poised to take control of economi- neighborhood. But France, Greece those fatally shot by the police. bute to me a position I have never The fund has set an initial goal to
cally valuable oil facilities, starving and Italy are pursuing their indepen- These findings accord with decades taken: that the “probability of being bring up to four new drugs to pa-
the Haftar forces of the revenue they dent courses in Libya as if the EU of research showing that civilian be- shot by police did not differ between tients by 2030. The fund can’t solve
need to carry on the war. didn’t exist. This isn’t what emerging havior is the greatest influence on Black and White Americans.” To the the challenge alone; success re-
But Mr. Haftar’s patrons aren’t power blocs look like. police behavior. contrary, I have, like them, stressed quires that governments make the
In September 2019, I cited the ar- that racial disparities in policing re- necessary policy reforms to enable a
ticle’s finding in congressional testi- flect differences in violent crime sustainable antibiotic pipeline and
mony. I also referred to it in a City rates. The only thing wrong with marketplace.
PUBLISHED SINCE 1889 BY DOW JONES & COMPANY Journal article, in which I noted their article, and my citation of it, is Encouragingly, two bipartisan pol-
Rupert Murdoch Robert Thomson
Executive Chairman, News Corp Chief Executive Officer, News Corp
that two Princeton political scien- that its conclusion is unacceptable in icy proposals have been introduced
Matt Murray Almar Latour
tists, Dean Knox and Jonathan our current political climate. in Congress. The Disarm Act of 2019
Editor in Chief Chief Executive Officer and Publisher Mummolo, had challenged the study This retraction bodes ill for the would increase federal reimburse-
Neal Lipschutz Karen Miller Pensiero DOW JONES MANAGEMENT: design. Messrs. Cesario and John- development of knowledge. If scien- ment for new antibiotics. The Pas-
Deputy Editor in Chief Managing Editor Ramin Beheshti, Chief Technology Officer; son stood by their findings. Even tists must disavow their findings teur Act of 2020 would give quali-
Natalie Cerny, Chief Communications Officer;
Jason Anders, Chief News Editor; Louise Story, Chief
Kamilah Mitchell-Thomas, Chief People Officer; under the study design proposed by because they challenge reigning or- fied new antibiotic makers a
News Strategist, Product & Technology Officer
Edward Roussel, Chief Innovation Officer; Messrs. Knox and Mummolo, they thodoxies, then those orthodoxies guaranteed reimbursement level.
Thorold Barker, Europe; Elena Cherney, News Christina Van Tassell, Chief Financial Officer wrote, there is again “no significant will prevail even when they are Millions of lives could be at stake
Features & Special Projects; Andrew Dowell, Asia;
Anthony Galloway, Video & Audio; Alex Martin,
OPERATING EXECUTIVES: evidence of anti-black disparity in wrong. Political consensus will drive without new antibiotics, and decades
Kenneth Breen, Commercial;
Print & Writing; Michael W. Miller, Features & Jason P. Conti, General Counsel;
the likelihood of being fatally shot scholarship, and not the reverse. of progress in modern medicine
Weekend; Emma Moody, Standards; Tracy Corrigan, Chief Strategy Officer; by the police.” The consequences for the policing could be squandered. The AMR Ac-
Shazna Nessa, Visuals; Matthew Rose, Frank Filippo, Print Products & Services; My June 3 Journal op-ed quoted debate are particularly dire. Re- tion Fund buys time that we can’t af-
Enterprise; Michael Siconolfi, Investigations; Kristin Heitmann, Chief Commercial Officer;
Stephen Wisnefski, Professional News Nancy McNeill, Corporate Sales;
the PNAS article’s conclusion verba- searchers will suppress any results ford to waste on inaction. The pri-
Gerard Baker, Editor at Large Thomas San Filippo, Customer Service; tim. It set off a firestorm at Michigan that contravene the narrative about vate sector is stepping up in an
Paul A. Gigot, Editor of the Editorial Page;
Josh Stinchcomb, Advertising Sales; State. The university’s Graduate Em- endemic police racism. That narra- unprecedented way. It is time for
Suzi Watford, Chief Marketing Officer; ployees Union pressured the MSU tive is now producing a shocking policy makers to take the bold ac-
Daniel Henninger, Deputy Editor, Editorial Page Jonathan Wright, International
press office to apologize for the rise in shootings in American cities. tions needed to prevent another
WALL STREET JOURNAL MANAGEMENT: Professional Information Business:
Joseph B. Vincent, Operations; Christopher Lloyd, Head; “harm it caused” by mentioning my The victims, including toddlers, are pandemic.
Larry L. Hoffman, Production Ingrid Verschuren, Deputy Head article in a newsletter. The union tar- almost exclusively black.
EDITORIAL AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS: geted physicist Steve Hsu, who had Mr. Ricks is chairman and CEO of
1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y., 10036 approved funding for Mr. Cesario’s Ms. Mac Donald is a fellow at the Eli Lilly & Co. Mr. Kutay is CEO of
Telephone 1-800-DOWJONES
research. MSU sacked Mr. Hsu from Manhattan Institute. Novo Holdings A/S.
A16 | Thursday, July 9, 2020 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
WORLD NEWS
27
them, officials say, was Mr. leader, Nemesio Oseguera, a 30-year-old son and heir ap- of the federal police when Mr. Mr. López Obrador’s gov-
García Harfuch, the Mexico City former Mexican municipal po- parent of the cartel leader, was Oseguera’s son was arrested in ernment has worked to stem
police chief. Another was En- lice officer who once served extradited to the U.S. to face 2015, the official said. the flow of migrants toward
rique Alfaro, the governor of Ja- time in a California prison for drug charges in Washington. The cartel’s growing asser- the U.S. border, helping Mr.
lisco, whose capital Guadalajara dealing heroin. Mr. Oseguera The Jalisco cartel operates in The younger Oseguera had tiveness presents Mexican Pres- Trump to achieve one of his
is Mexico’s second-largest city. is believed to be hiding in the most of Mexico’s 32 states been fighting extradition since ident Andrés Manuel López Ob- key campaign promises, and
“This is an example of the mountains in southern Jalisco. his arrest in 2015. But extradi- rador with a dilemma. The supported the renegotiation of
challenge the Mexican state is In its 2019 annual report, the tions by Mexico to the U.S. president took office in 2018 the trade pact. Mr. Trump, in
being confronted with,” Mr. DEA said the cartel has distribu- have soared this year after U.S. with the promise he would do turn, backed Mexico amid the
Alfaro said in a radio inter- tion hubs in Los Angeles, New more bold. Attorney General William Barr away with Mexico’s spiraling vi- coronavirus pandemic by
view last week, after disclos- York City, Chicago, Houston and The CJNG, as it is known for made them a priority in talks olence by attacking poverty. So sending it hundreds of ventila-
ing that federal officials had Atlanta. The U.S. Justice Depart- its initials in Spanish, now oper- with top Mexicans officials. far, violence has risen further, tors and taking on part of the
warned him his name was on ment considers it “the most ates in 27 of Mexico’s 32 states, In June, a federal judge and and Mexico posted a record oil production cut that Mexico
the hit list. “What we are see- well-armed cartel in Mexico.” up from 16 states in 2015, ac- his wife were shot and killed number of homicides in 2019. should have implemented as
ing is a threat to institutions.” For veterans of Latin Amer- cording to a recent Mexican in- in Colima state, which neigh- “López Obrador is in a co- part of a global deal in April
Last week, gunmen burst ica’s drug wars, the attacks on telligence report. While rival bors Jalisco. The judge played nundrum,” said Falko Ernst, a to shore up oil prices.
into a drug-rehabilitation cen- Mexican security forces are an cartels have been weakened by a role in one of the cases security analyst with non- White House officials say
ter in the city of Irapuato, in unsettling reminder of the cam- internal conflicts, the Jalisco against the younger Oseguera. profit International Crisis illegal migration is down con-
the central Mexican state of paign waged by cocaine kingpin cartel has kept a broadly uni- Ruben Oseguera has said he Group. “If he acts boldly, he siderably and that drug sei-
Guanajuato, and killed 28 peo- Pablo Escobar against the Co- fied leadership, a Mexican intel- is innocent of all charges would be undermining his own zures have totaled more than
ple. Guanajuato, home to thou- lombian state in the late 1980s. ligence official said. against him. rhetoric. If he doesn’t act, the $1 billion—factors the officials
sands of American retirees, as Others think the Jalisco car- The gang is known for its In June, Mexico’s Finance cartels would see it as a mes- say contribute to the stronger
well as major auto-manufactur- tel is still a long way off from paramilitary training and tac- Ministry said it had frozen sage of impunity.” relationship.
WORLD WATCH
U.N. Official Calls U.S.,
RUSSIA
Company Refuses
IVORY COAST
Presidential Nominee Iran Strikes Unlawful
To Pay for Arctic Spill Of Ruling Party Dies BY SUNE ENGEL RASMUSSEN of attacks across the Middle
East, including on U.S. troops
The Russian mining company Prime Minister Amadou Gon A top United Nations inves- and interests. The U.S. desig-
that saw a massive fuel leak at Coulibaly, the presidential candi- tigator condemned the U.S. nated him a terrorist in 2005.
one of its Arctic installations in date of Ivory Coast’s ruling party, killing of Iranian Maj. Gen. After the U.S. on Jan. 3
May is refusing to pay some $2 died Wednesday just days after Qassem Soleimani in January struck Gen. Soleimani’s convoy
ANDREJ ISAKOVIC/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE/GETTY IMAGES
billion in damages sought by the returning from two months of as unlawful, saying Washington in Baghdad with a drone, kill-
Russian government to cover medical treatment in France, failed to provide sufficient evi- ing him and several others,
the cleanup, and has questioned where he previously had under- dence that he posed an imme- White House officials said
how the figure was calculated. gone a heart transplant. diate threat to American inter- they had acted in self-defense.
At least 20,000 tons of fuel Mr. Coulibaly’s death throws ests to justify the drone strike. “Soleimani was plotting im-
seeped from a holding tank at a the October presidential election Agnes Callamard, the U.N.’s minent and sinister attacks on
power plant run by a subsidiary into disarray, raising concerns special rapporteur on extrajudi- American diplomats and mili-
of Norilsk Nickel, or Nornickel, about who now will represent cial, summary or arbitrary exe- tary personnel, but we caught
contaminating a swath of land the party of President Alassane cutions, also deemed illegal him in the act and terminated
and several ecologically impor- Ouattara, who is required to step Iran’s retaliatory missile strikes him,” President Trump said on
tant bodies of water in what the down after his second term. five days later, which targeted a Jan. 3. However, in a letter sub-
Russian branch of environmental Mr. Coulibaly, 61 years old, base in Iraq housing U.S. troops. mitted to the U.N. Security
group Greenpeace called the hadn’t spoken publicly about “To the extent that evidence Council on Jan. 8, which
worst spill the Arctic had seen. why he went to France back in points to the U.S. and Iranian formed the basis for the U.N. in
Nornickel said it would pay May. Many speculated that his strikes being retaliations or determining the legality of the
for the cleanup itself and work Protesters opposed to a weekend curfew to combat a coronavirus health problems were related to reprisals, each would be un- strike, the U.S. didn’t mention
with the state’s environmental resurgence protested Wednesday in Serbia’s capital Belgrade. his 2012 heart transplant. lawful,” the U.N. rapporteur any imminent threat and
watchdog, other federal bodies Mr. Ouattara’s party has been said in a report focusing on pointed solely to past incidents,
and independent experts “to SERBIA backtracked on his plans to rein- in power since postelection vio- the use of armed drones, and Ms. Callamard’s report said.
completely restore the ecosys- state a lockdown in Belgrade, lence a decade ago left some in particular the killing of Gen. The definition of self-de-
tem of the accident area.” President Backtracks but it didn’t stop people from 3,000 people dead after then- Soleimani, that she is set to fense used by the U.S. to jus-
Nornickel has also suggested On Pandemic Curfew firing flares and throwing stones President Laurent Gbagbo re- present Thursday in Geneva, a tify the drone strike against
the disaster was caused by melt- while trying to storm the parlia- fused to acknowledge his defeat copy of which was seen by The the general was in “complete
ing permafrost, echoing environ- Police fired tear gas at pro- ment building. Several people in a runoff vote. Wall Street Journal. contradiction” with interna-
mentalists and scientists who say testers in Serbia’s capital during were injured during the chaotic Mr. Coulibaly returned home six As head of a clandestine tional jurisprudence, she said.
global warming might pose a a second day of demonstrations clashes in front of the parlia- days ago. He attended a ministe- wing of Iran’s Islamic Revolu- A spokeswoman for the U.S.
threat to other oil and gas installa- against the president’s handling ment on Wednesday, including rial meeting in Abidjan Wednes- tionary Guard Corps responsible State Department said the re-
tions across the region of Siberia. of the coronavirus outbreak. some of the opposition leaders. day, but fell ill, officials said. for military operations abroad, port undermined human rights
—Ann M. Simmons President Aleksandar Vucic —Associated Press —Associated Press Gen. Soleimani ordered dozens by “giving a pass to terrorists.”
TECHNOLOGY: TWITTER SIGNALS INTEREST IN DEVELOPING SUBSCRIPTION SERVICE B4
WSJ $ IDX g 0.43% LIBOR 3M 0.273 NIKKEI (Midday) 22486.01 À 0.21% See more at WSJ.com/Markets
Thursday, July 9, 2020 | B1
Discounters like Southwest, Ryanair, Wizz and easyJet have returned capacity
quicker than legacy airlines.
U.S. airline capacity by number of seats, 5 Seat capacity, in millions:
Audit Assails
Facebook
in millions By selected U.S. airlines By selected European airlines
4 Southwest Ryanair
American Wizz Air
20 Delta Air France
3
On Content
United easyJet
Legacy carriers 2 2
16
1 1
BY JEFF HORWITZ also calls Facebook’s efforts in-
adequate.
0 0 Facebook Inc. and its de- “Unfortunately, in our view
12 March April May June March April May June tractors tried to win over ad- Facebook’s approach to civil
vertisers Wednesday, after a rights remains too reactive and
company-commissioned audit piecemeal,” said the report, re-
found continued problems with leased the day after Facebook
how the social media company Chief Executive Mark Zucker-
8 polices hate speech and other berg met with civil-rights ad-
problematic content on its vocates who have organized an
platform. advertiser boycott of the plat-
The auditors’ report, by form.
civil-rights attorney Laura “Many in the civil rights
4 Low-cost carriers Murphy and a team from law community have become dis-
firm Relman Colfax PLLC, heartened, frustrated and an-
praises the social-media com- gry after years of engagement
pany for undertaking a self-ex- where they implored the com-
amination and making some pany to do more to advance
0 meaningful changes, including equality and fight discrimina-
Source: OAG March April May June instituting rules against voter tion, while also safeguarding
suppression and creating a free expression,” the report
The largest U.S. drugstore physical stores. coronavirus pandemic. Patients lowing the path of rivals
ABDOLLAH HEIDARI/REUTERS
chain by stores is pairing with Insurers and hospitals, are putting off visits to their Apollo Global Management
primary-care provider Vil- meanwhile, have been expand- health-care providers for fear Inc. and Blackstone Group Inc.
lageMD to open 500 to 700 ing their clinics or buying up of catching the virus during When the firms take over man-
clinics at Walgreens sites physicians’ practices, making visits. Walgreens is part of a agement of the assets, they
across the country over the more primary-care doctors em- coalition behind an ad cam- help insurers in their aim to
next five years. Walgreens will ployees of larger companies. paign to encourage people to earn more money than they
pay VillageMD $1 billion in eq- For example, UnitedHealth return to their medical provid- have to pay out to policyhold-
uity and debt over the next Group Inc. has acquired a net- ers as the pandemic continues. ers, a task that has become
BUSINESS COMMODITIES three years in exchange for a work of doctor practices, sur- Walgreens in April said store more difficult in an era of low
Bayer’s Roundup Gold ETF inflows 30% stake in the Chicago-based gery centers and urgent-care sales had begun to fall sharply interest rates.
startup by the end of that term. clinics. following an initial surge in de- Estimates put the assets of
settlement hit record Walgreens and rival CVS “We heard from patients mand in March as Americans Please turn to page B10
heads back to as bullion rally Health Corp. are in a race to that they trust their local doc- rushed to stock up in the pan-
negotiations. B3 continues. B11 become go-to treatment cen- tor and they don’t like chang- demic’s early days. The com- Allstate acquires rival insurer
ters, particularly for patients ing their doctor,” said Alexan- Please turn to page B2 for $4 billion ............................ B11
B2 | Thursday, July 9, 2020 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
A
AirAsia Group Bhd......B2
G
General Motors...........B1
Omnicom Group..........B4
P
Bed Bath & Beyond to Close Stores
Alcoa............................B3 H PepsiCo........................B4 BY MARIA ARMENTAL
Alibaba Group.............B4 R
Hennes & Mauritz....B12
Allegiant Travel..........B1
Allstate ..................... B10
Hertz Global HoldingsA1 Relman Colfax.............B1 Bed Bath & Beyond Inc. said
AMC Entertainment A2, I S it would permanently close
B11 ................................ iHeartMedia................B4 Saudi Aramco............B12 roughly 200 stores, a bet that
American Airlines.....B11 ImmunoTek Bio Centers Semiconductor the home-goods chain can ride
Andreessen Horowitz.B6 A6 Manufacturing out the coronavirus pandemic
Apollo Global ........B1,B6 J International.............A2 by shrinking its bricks-and-
Apple.........................B12 Sensor Tower..............A8
J.C. Penney..........A1,B12 mortar footprint.
Athora Holding ......... B10 Simon Property Group
AT&T............................B4
JD.com.........................B4
B12 Bed Bath & Beyond, which
Johnson Controls operates roughly 1,500 stores,
B Sirius XM Holdings .... B4
International.............B5 had to shut many of its loca-
Spotify Technology.....B4
Bank of America.......B10 JPMorgan Chase.......B10
Barrick Gold..............B11
SVB Financial Group...B6 tions starting March 23 be-
K T cause of Covid-19 restrictions
Bayer...........................B3
KKR..............................B1 Tailored Brands...........A6 in the U.S. Despite a jump in
Blackstone Group ....... B1
A Wirecard spokeswoman
declined to comment.
Wirecard, once a fast-grow-
filing, prosecutors said the
conspirators used the phony
merchants’ offshore bank ac-
Doctors pharmacy operator, is also add-
ing medical services. The com-
pany has opened a handful of
portfolio with
ing German fintech company counts to disguise payments, clinics with doctors and den-
that appeared to thrive with
the rise of online commerce,
tricking U.S. banks into pro-
cessing tens of millions of dol-
Continued from page B1
pany will report financial re-
tists that offer flat-fee primary
care, such as $25 dental X-rays
Fractional Shares
served as a financial middle- lars in marijuana purchases sults for its May-ended quarter and $40 office visits. The com-
man for online businesses, in- made through Eaze’s platform. on Thursday. pany plans to expand the clin-
cluding processing electronic In a search-warrant applica- VillageMD, a network with ics broadly across Walmart’s
payments for retailers, gam- tion for Mr. Weigand’s elec- more than 2,800 physicians, 4,700 U.S. stores, said Sean
bling sites, travel companies tronic devices, an FBI agent has had a 15% to 20% drop in Slovenski, president of Walmart Invest in stocks you want
and other services. said the government was seek- primary-care visits amid the U.S. health and wellness, in an
But Wirecard has long been ing evidence of charges includ- pandemic, said Tim Barry, the interview. regardless of the share price
dogged by allegations from in- ing bank fraud, money laun- startup’s co-founder and CEO. “The intent is to spread
vestors that the company used dering and conspiracy. He said the drop-off is less se- across the majority of the fleet,
third parties and shell compa- “We are aware of this mat- vere than declines of 40% or but the clinics won’t be the IBKR offers Fractional Shares on
nies to generate fake revenue, ter and are fully cooperating more in the broader industry. same across the entire fleet,”
or claimed to hold cash that with the relevant authorities,” Executives from both com- he said last October, soon after more US Stocks, ETFs and ADRs
wasn’t there. The company California-based Eaze said last panies said the deal was ad- the first new clinic opened in than any other broker1
filed for the German equiva- week. Eaze wasn’t named in vancing before coronavirus. Georgia. The first locations
lent of bankruptcy last month, the indictment and hasn’t In adding primary-care doc- were stand-alone clinics next to
days after it disclosed the been charged. tors to its model, Walgreens is Walmart supercenters. Newer
missing $2 billion. Wirecard wasn’t named in diverging from CVS, which has versions are inside existing PICK PICK YOUR
Its chief executive, Markus the indictment or in any public said that physicians aren’t stores. YOUR
Braun, resigned last month court filings. The people famil- needed to create so-called Critics, including some in- $ AMOUNT
and is out on bail after being iar with the investigation said health-care hubs. CVS is creat- dustry analysts, health-care ex-
STOCK
arrested over accusations he Wirecard executives worked ing hubs inside its stores where perts and physician groups, ar-
inflated Wirecard’s numbers. with Messrs. Akhavan and patients would go to seek medi- gue that Americans aren’t Share Price2 Share %
Mr. Braun has consistently de- Weigand to create a payment cine, consultations and lab tests ready to accept their local
nied wrongdoing. His lawyer processing network that au- drugstore as a trusted health
didn’t respond to a request for thorities say skirted banking provider. Some also say the NFLX $
25 $
493.81 5.06%
comment. A second, unnamed rules and defrauded U.S. banks.
The chain is in a depth and complexity involved
executive was arrested in Mu- Mr. Weigand has been held in successfully treating chronic TSLA $
25 $
1,371.58 1.82%
nich this week under suspicion at a Southern California jail race with rival CVS conditions can’t be addressed
of conspiracy to commit fraud.
Munich prosecutors said
since his arrest. Manhattan
federal prosecutors have ar-
to become go-to by pharmacy chains.
Health-care industry lines GOOG $
25 $
1,495.70 1.67%
they are investigating former gued for his continued deten- treatment centers. are being redrawn and provid-
managers to determine tion, saying he poses a sub- ers are under pressure to re- AMZN $
25 $
3,057.34 0.82%
whether they faked income to stantial flight risk. vamp themselves. A high-profile
fool investors about the com- In an April letter to U.S. health venture backed by Ama-
pany’s health. District Judge Jed S. Rakoff to manage chronic conditions zon, JP Morgan Chase & Co. $
100 Stock Portfolio
The U.S. case appears to re- seeking their client’s release, such as diabetes and hyperten- and Berkshire Hathaway Inc.
late to Wirecard’s work in Mr. Weigand’s lawyers pro- sion. has shown little to the public
emerging markets, its banking posed a bail package including Both drugstore giants say three years after it was an-
arm and its payment process- a $4 million bond, secured by their ubiquity in American nounced. The venture’s chief ex-
ing services. U.S. authorities’ Mr. Weigand’s Luxembourg communities makes pharmacies ecutive recently stepped aside.
interest in Wirecard indicates home, and $1 million in cash a logical hub for people seeking Walgreens has been working
an investigation of far larger provided by Mr. Weigand’s treatment for chronic ailments, with VillageMD since last year, Start Investing Today!
scope than suggested in the friends. One of those friends, which are often exacerbated as when the companies opened
initial charges involving the Markus Fuchs, offered to con- patients struggle to take their five joint VillageMD locations
marijuana marketplace. tribute $150,000 toward the medications regularly and ad- in Houston. Walgreens’ Mr.
ibkr.com/fractional
On March 9, Ruben cash package, according to the here to medical regimens. Gourlay said patients’ adher-
Weigand, a 38-year-old Ger- court filings. Mr. Fuchs is vice CVS, which acquired insurer ence to medications improved
man citizen and resident of president of global sales at Aetna Inc. in 2018, said its at the pilot locations, convinc-
Luxembourg, was arrested at Wirecard Global Sales GmbH, health-hub model will drive ing the company the model
Los Angeles International Air- based in Munich, according to down the cost of health care, should expand. Available for
port on his way to Costa Rica. his LinkedIn account. He was savings that will then be cap- VillageMD, which has bought
His co-defendant, Hamid also named as a director of tured by its new insurance arm. up primary-care offices across
Individuals and Advisors3
“Ray” Akhavan, was arrested Wirecard’s holding company in It aims to have 1,500 health the country, will move existing
Member - NYSE, FINRA, SIPC – Any trading symbols displayed are for illustrative purposes only
later that month. Both were the U.K. in a September bond hubs opened by 2021. physicians into the Walgreens- and are not intended to portray recommendations. [1] Source - Investopedia.com. Fractional
charged with one count of prospectus. Walgreens, which has opted adjacent clinics. Trading Availability by Broker, as of June 9, 2020. Competitor offers subject to change without
notice. Services vary by firm. For complete information, see ibkr.com/info. [2] Share prices as of
conspiracy to commit bank Mr. Fuchs also wrote a letter to partner with rather than ac- The cost of a VillageMD of- 07/06/2020 [3] Restrictions apply. Nothing contained herein should be construed as investment
fraud in connection with the of support for Mr. Weigand, de- quire insurers or other compa- fice visit will vary based on the advice, either on behalf of a particular security or an overall investment strategy. Neither
Nasdaq nor any of its affiliates makes any recommendation to buy or sell any security or any
marijuana transactions and scribing him as one of his clos- nies, said the VillageMD pairing patient’s insurance coverage representation about the financial condition of any company. Investors should undertake their
have pleaded not guilty. est friends. will benefit it financially by and services rendered. own due diligence and carefully evaluate companies before investing. © 2020. Nasdaq, Inc.
All Rights Reserved. nasdaq.com ADVICE FROM A SECURITIES PROFESSIONAL IS STRONGLY
Lawyers for Messrs. Akha- Mr. Fuchs didn’t respond to driving up prescription sales as —Sarah Nassauer ADVISED. 07-IB20-1336
van and Weigand have de- requests for comment. well as sales of related medical contributed to this article.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * Thursday, July 9, 2020 | B3
BUSINESS NEWS
Bayer’s Roundup
Settlement Heads
Back to Negotiation
BY SARA RANDAZZO and try to blame Bayer.
The Environmental Protec-
Bayer AG is scrapping a tion Agency and other regula-
LANGLEY ROBY
pended on the creation of a for decisions in the appeals that mother’s womb as her first and Hong Kong have already
panel of scientists that would Bayer is pursuing in the three visit to the theme park in Or- reopened, allowing revenue to
definitively conclude whether Roundup cases that have gone lando, Fla. Her mother was six start flowing back to what had
Roundup and its active ingredi- to trial. Those appeals rest on months pregnant, but that been the company’s fastest-
ent, glyphosate, are carcinogens. the idea that the jury verdicts didn’t stop her from riding Langley Roby, second from right, is eager for Disney World to reopen. growing division. In May, Dis-
U.S. District Judge Vince are in contrast with the conclu- Space Mountain, says Ms. Roby. ney said the coronavirus had
Chhabria said this week he was sions of the EPA, which has told Ms. Roby’s next visit to Dis- World carries a symbolic pull, theme-park safety guidelines. taken about $1 billion in reve-
skeptical that a science panel Bayer it can’t put a cancer ney World may end up being with its closures and reopen- Far less opposition has nue from its parks division in
could fairly replace judges and warning label on the weedkiller even more unusual. Ms. Roby, ing plans serving as something emerged among the Walt Dis- the January-to-March quarter,
juries in the case, and that he since the agency determined from Owensboro, Ky., plans to of a barometer for the eco- ney World workforce, though when a majority of parks were
was unlikely to sign off on the the product isn’t carcinogenic. arrive at the park early Thurs- nomic resuscitation at large. the company has faced push- closed for only a few weeks. In
idea. “Although the court is not The problem for companies day morning to be among the The timing is particularly back over plans to have work- August, the company will dis-
aware of any Plan B, it would be trying to resolve any mass first guests welcomed back fraught, as the number of cor- ers self-screen for coronavirus close earnings from the fol-
surprising if none existed given tort, Ms. Lahav said, is how to into the Magic Kingdom since onavirus cases in Florida symptoms. lowing quarter, when the do-
the stakes involved and the nov- put an end date on liability. the coronavirus pandemic reaches record levels. Disney The Actors’ Equity Associa- mestic parks were shut down
elty of Plan A,” the judge wrote “What is a way to cabin it and closed its gates in March. is introducing safety measures tion, which represents some and the international locations
after expressing his concerns. control it, while still being fair “It’s never going to be that will inevitably disrupt the performers at the park, has open only for a limited time.
Bayer and plaintiffs’ law- to people?” she said. cleaner than it is that day,” escapist environment of the called on Disney to postpone Many of the most iconic as-
yers said Wednesday they will As Bayer works to recast the said Ms. Roby, who said she Happiest Place on Earth. the opening as cases in Florida pects of a trip to Disney World
work on refining the idea and class-action proposal, it contin- has visited Disney World The park is open to annual rise. “It is deeply disturbing have been reimagined for the
bring it back to the judge. ues to negotiate with lawyers about 40 times. “I feel like it passholders like Ms. Roby on that while coronavirus cases Covid era. Characters such as
Elizabeth Cabraser, a well- who have existing cases. At the will honestly be a safer envi- Thursday and Friday, with the in Florida surge, Disney is re- Cinderella or Gaston wave
known class-action expert rep- time of its June settlement, ronment than just going to the Magic Kingdom and Animal fusing to provide regular test- from balconies—or trot
resenting the plaintiffs, said Bayer said it had settled with grocery [store] or any place Kingdom areas opening to the ing to one of the few groups of through the park on horses—
they “remain strongly commit- lawyers representing 75% of the local because Disney has so general public on July 11, fol- workers in the park who by rather than walk the grounds
ted to a fair and just resolu- 125,000 known plaintiffs and much on the line.” lowed by Epcot and Disney’s the very nature of their jobs, and interact with guests.
tion.” Bayer echoed that, say- set aside between $8.8 billion Walt Disney Co. is counting Hollywood Studios four days cannot use personal protective If workers see customers
ing it will seek “a viable and $9.6 billion to cover the en- on die-hard fans like Ms. Roby later. equipment,” said Mary McColl, flouting the mandatory-mask
solution to manage and resolve tire batch of existing claims. to weigh the risks of traveling Workers at Disneyland Re- executive director of Actors’ rule, they are to approach
potential future litigation.” Plaintiffs’ lawyers unsatis- amid a pandemic and still de- sort in Anaheim, Calif., vocally Equity Association. them with the same demeanor
Bayer plans to continue sell- fied with settlement offers, cide to head to the park. In opposed Disney’s plans to re- A Disney spokeswoman said as when they see someone
ing Roundup with no change to meanwhile, are still signing up the most crucial test yet of its open there, culminating in a Actors’ Equity members won’t smoking in a nondesignated
its label for use in commercial new clients. Legal marketers ability to resume operations protest outside the park and a be called back to work during space, said Eric Clinton, presi-
farming and everyday garden- say television advertisements while keeping consumers safe, consortium of unions pleading the phased reopening. “We re- dent of an Orlando union local
ing. But doing so makes it dif- urging Roundup users with Disney will begin opening its with California Gov. Gavin gret that their union hasn’t ac- whose members operate rides
ficult for the company to fully non-Hodgkin lymphoma to call flagship park in phases start- Newsom to ask Disney to de- cepted the safety protocols.” and perform custodial work at
contain lawsuits filed over the number on the screen con- ing on Thursday and continu- lay. The company ultimately Disney is significantly re- the park. From there, things
Roundup’s safety since people tinue to air around the country. ing through July 15. Other did, saying it couldn’t reopen ducing its capacity at the park. can escalate to summoning se-
who use the product today —Micah Maidenberg theme parks have begun wel- on schedule after state offi- But any revenue is welcome curity or making the guest
could get sick years from now contributed to this article. coming visitors, but Disney cials delayed the release of after months of closures that leave the park.
SPOTIFY/GIMLET
Conal Byrne, president of the duced a method of letting ad- ware that would be accessible
company’s iHeartPodcast Net- vertisers know how many peo- to Twitter’s internal teams
work. ple heard a given ad in a looking to add subscription op-
But advertisers typically podcast, rather than through tions to their products, accord-
sponsor individual series when Carrie Coon records ‘Motherhacker,’ a scripted fiction podcast produced by Spotify’s Gimlet Media. the common method of count- ing to the job description. “This
it comes to podcasts, where ing downloads for an episode, is a first for Twitter!” the com-
advertising is growing rapidly several million dollars through podcast format may increase podcast unit for around $300 and to insert ads in podcasts pany said in the posting.
but remains relatively small. Omnicom to advertise in pod- metrics even further,” she million, The Wall Street Jour- that have already been re- Chief Executive Jack Dorsey
Marketers are projected to casts in 2019, she said. said. nal reported this week. The corded. The technology, is under pressure to boost re-
spend $863.4 million on ad- Omnicom Media Group, The deal also calls for col- company last year struck an Streaming Ad Insertion, also sults after a battle with Elliott
vertising in U.S. podcasts this part of advertising-agency laboration on research and a exclusive deal for podcasts provides insight into the audi- Management Corp. The activ-
year, up from $678.7 million in holding company Omnicom first crack at new shows for from Walt Disney Co.’s Marvel ences reached and marketing ist investor sought to remove
2019, according to the Interac- Group Inc., is increasing its Omnicom Media Group clients, Entertainment. outcomes, Spotify said. the part-time chief, who splits
tive Advertising Bureau and podcast investment now partly which include McDonald’s Spotify last month formed The spread of ad technol- his time with financial technol-
PricewaterhouseCoopers. By because audiences continue to Corp., PepsiCo Inc. and AT&T its own pact for superhero ogy and better measurement ogy company Square Inc. The
comparison, ad revenue from grow and partly because tech- Inc. podcasts from the DC unit of will encourage larger ad buys sides agreed to a truce with
digital video in 2019 was $21.7 nology is making the ads more Big media and technology AT&T Inc.’s Warner Bros. En- in podcasting, but it is still Twitter pledging to seek stron-
billion, the IAB said. targetable and measurable, companies have been trying to tertainment Inc., plus other early going compared with ger revenue growth.
“It’s a big deal, a very big Ms. Sullivan said. capture more of podcasts’ fiction podcasts using Warner other digital media, said Zoe The job description offered
deal versus what we’ve done “We know that audio works growth for themselves, and to Bros. properties. It also has Soon, vice president at IAB’s few details on the subscription
in the past,” said Catherine very well at increasing con- accelerate it. acquired podcast producer Consumer Experience Center project, but said the hire would
Sullivan, chief investment offi- sumer attitudes and driving Sirius XM Holdings Inc. is Gimlet Media Inc., podcast of Excellence. be working closely with the
cer at Omnicom Media Group action, but we believe that nearing a deal to buy E.W. publisher Anchor FM Inc. and “Those are all things to company’s payments team and
North America. Clients spent adding addressability to the Scripps Co.’s Stitcher Inc. the sports-and-pop-culture crack,” she said. the web-based Twitter.com
group. The job would be based
in New York, where Twitter al-
matches, including on its CBS the UEFA matches on hold. in the previous year.
broadcast network, the CBS The deal provides a popular U.S. television hasn’t always
Sports cable network and CBS live-sports property for CBS All been a happy home for the
All Access, the company said. Access, which ViacomCBS has Champions League. CBS will be
The deal also covers two other anointed as its flagship direct- the competition’s third broad-
competitions, the UEFA Europa to-consumer streaming service. caster in five years, following
DIA DIPASUPIL/GETTY IMAGES
In Audit “We do not condone hate
speech and believe in a world
where everyone is treated with
CNBC signed former Fox
News journalist Shepard Smith
to anchor a new one-hour eve-
dignity,” a State Farm spokes- ning news program, the net-
!"# $
!"## $%% %$ &# '(#" "$) %$##$!")* Continued from page B1 woman said, adding that the work said Wednesday.
!
! %& %'%' (( )) '$'+
*
+
,
#&&
<" )&& $!) (
Carolyn Everson, a Facebook insurer was reaching out to “The News with Shepard
(''-
! .
$!
$
"#
$&# 39#$'2) 3($ ") vice president, emailed adver- Facebook to rectify the ad Smith” will debut this fall in
! 9) 2 $#$ !"
/% 0 0 1 +"#) * )&)& ) (#"9& ( 2,& )$ tisers on Wednesday to explain placement. the 7 p.m. to 8 p.m. time slot
0 1 +
+ . '&)"$) $ !) & $ how it is responding to the The organizers said nearly on the cable business news
$ $! ! +
"
#$% !
&'( "
" )" * 0 2 " %3 44
$ $2'#)&& $)&" ## *")& ) #$&&&
'' )" "
5+ 6 5+ 6 $!"#) * #")* $ '2)& $22$)# % concerns raised by rights 1,000 companies were pausing channel. The Monday through
$
*+
& $ &( $ & )
2)& '" ")"# $
' $( +
+ ! /% 0 077
1 .
+"#) 3($ #")* $ ") )$)*2")* 9) groups and in the auditors’ re- advertising on Facebook, in- Friday newscast marks a sig-
*) ( ") &")$& #$ ") =)" port. “While we sometimes will cluding those offering public nificant shift in the evening
" &$' * * $*$' +' * * ! 077. & %$2 ) ( $! #) )")2)
&$'
$
'*
$&' "' +'
"# 077
1 + 1 disagree, especially when it support for the boycott and programming strategy for
$&' ( ! 8 $
!
) *
MANAGEMENT
Quicken Loans
Chief to Keep
Control After IPO
BY PETER RUDEGEAIR Mortgage Finance, beating out
longtime heavyweights like
Download
With tax deadlines now extended, take this opportunity to catch
up with the recent changes to the law with our updated e-book,
“Your Money 2020: The WSJ Tax Guide.” Learn what the current
tax laws mean for you, your company and the country.
WSJPLUS.COM/TAXES2020
DOWNLOAD NOW AT
Tax Guide
©2020 Dow Jones & Co., Inc. All rights reserved.6DJ7795
B6 | Thursday, July 9, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
BUSINESS NEWS
Paycheck Protection
nesses. In Silicon Valley, some Rescue Program’s tify that they needed the loans ees, then either they should asked about the April tweet
investors and startup execu- because of the economic uncer- be laid off or the business and Benchmark portfolio com-
Program despite tives have said that venture Aid Came Amid tainty. should be shut down,” Mr. panies’ involvement in the
investors’ opposition
capitalists shouldn’t be pro- Venture-Capital Halt In late April, the mood in Galloway said. “Every bailout PPP program. A “broad-based
tected from losses by taxpay- Silicon Valley changed, as up- leads to moral hazard, which program” for small companies
ers, and that companies with dated Treasury Department leads to a bigger bailout is “quite different” from a
BY ROLFE WINKLER access to cash shouldn’t get Technology startups raced guidance indicated that compa- later.” large public company “calling
rescue funding. to apply to the Paycheck Pro- nies with access to capital mar- Supporters of the program on Washington for a negoti-
Billionaire tech entrepre- Others argued hard-hit tection Program when it was kets or other sources of liquid- said one of its chief virtues ated bailout,” he said in the
neur Tom Siebel said last startups genuinely needed the announced in April, fearing the ity likely didn’t qualify and all was keeping workers off un- new tweet.
month that his software com- money to help keep people pandemic’s economic impact loans over $2 million would be employment rolls. Car rental startup
pany, C3.ai Inc., is growing employed because investors and seeing venture-capital mar- audited. But the program failed to Getaround Inc. got at least $5
sales 80% annually. It has stopped writing checks. kets freeze. Meanwhile, a debate raged reach many of the hardest-hit million. It has raised more
raised hundreds of millions of The newly released Trea- Some companies viewed over whether the funds were businesses, including those than $600 million from ven-
dollars from big-name ven- sury data show that venture- the loans as grants because meant for venture-backed com- that closed for prolonged pe- ture capitalists and other in-
ture-capital investors includ- capital firms including New the debt can be forgiven if panies or for hard-hit busi- riods or were overwhelmed by vestors, according to Pitch-
ing early Facebook Inc. backer Enterprise Associates, An- used largely to retain employ- nesses on Main Street like res- non-payroll costs. Harvard Book, and counts among its
Jim Breyer. It also received at dreessen Horowitz, Khosla ees. taurants and salons. economists concluded that the backers SoftBank Group
least $5 million from the gov- Ventures and Kleiner Perkins The application didn’t re- Many worried about public program had little impact on Corp.’s $100 billion Vision
ernment’s Paycheck Protection each had dozens of portfolio quire important information criticism or possible legal liabil- employment at small busi- Fund. Financial technology
Program. companies receive the forgiv- such as bank statements show- ity for taking taxpayer funds. nesses. company Upgrade Inc. took in
C3 is among thousands of able loans, according to an ing applicants’ cash balances, Some startups that had applied Bill Gurley, of venture firm at least $2 million of govern-
venture-backed startups that analysis by research firm CB though companies had to cer- for funds changed their minds. Benchmark, railed against ment money, then last month
took money from the rescue Insights. bailouts in April, saying on raised $40 million from inves-
program meant to help small SVB Financial Group’s Sili- Twitter: “Let’s be candid. If tors including Santander
businesses weather the eco- con Valley Bank, which counts clined to comment. A spokes- bility. you believe in business & cap- Group, one of the world’s larg-
nomic hit from the pandemic, many startups among its cli- woman for Silicon Valley Bank Scott Galloway, founder of italism, then there are zero est banks.
according to data released by ents, processed nearly 2,200 said it processed loans on a a startup with venture back- circumstances where the gov- A Getaround spokeswoman
the Treasury Department on loans for more than $150,000 first-come, first-served basis. ing and a marketing professor ernment should bail out eq- said its business was hit hard
Monday. each, distributing $1.7 billion, Jarrett Streebin, co- at New York University, criti- uity holders.” by Covid-related lockdowns
C3 was valued at $3.3 bil- including loans to more than founder and chief executive of cized investors whose compa- About a dozen Benchmark- and the program “helped re-
lion last year, according to 30 companies it has a stake shipping-software company nies took government rescue backed companies received a duce the otherwise severe im-
data firm PitchBook. in, CB Insights said. EasyPost, said his company money, saying it boosted their loan through the program, CB pact on the health of our or-
The rescue program has C3, based in Redwood City, returned its $6 million loan returns at taxpayer expense. Insights said. Mr. Gurley and ganization.” Upgrade didn’t
proven controversial, with Calif., has raised $300 million because there was too much “If a venture-backed com- Benchmark didn’t respond to respond to a request for com-
funds going to well-heeled in venture capital, including gray area around who quali- pany either can’t survive this requests to comment this ment.
and politically connected $50 million in September, ac- fied and he feared his com- pandemic or can’t convince week. Tuesday evening, Mr. —Peter Rudegeair
firms across the economy cording to CB Insights. C3 de- pany could face potential lia- investors to put in more Gurley posted again on the contributed to this article.
Workforce Cuts
Threaten Pipeline
Of Digital Tools
BY ANGUS LOTEN 25,500 jobs, including layoffs
at high-profile companies such
Technology startups have as Uber Technologies Inc.,
been laying off tens of thou- Groupon Inc. and Airbnb Inc.,
sands of workers to cope with the report said.
the economic fallout of the Uber in May announced
pandemic, potentially blunting more than 6,500 layoffs, cut-
a key innovation pipeline for ting roughly a quarter of its
the enterprise information- workforce. A month earlier,
technology market, according Lyft Inc. said it would cut
DAVID PAUL MORRIS/BLOOMBERG NEWS
Lenders Extend Trucker’s Debt Terms GM Suit sor at Wayne State University
in Detroit, said GM could ap-
peal the decision, but it is diffi-
million term loan from a plaint with prejudice earlier to- health crisis and period of so-
group led by affiliates of day vindicates our position.” cial unrest.
Apollo Global Management The case’s dismissal is a re- GM appealed the decision
Inc. buke to GM Chief Executive asking a higher court to toss
Those deals were negoti- YRC Worldwide was struggling to turn its operations around before the coronavirus pandemic. Mary Barra, who believed Fiat out the initial order, arguing
ated as YRC was working out Chrysler intentionally took Mr. Borman had overstepped
the terms for a planned $700 the $2.2 trillion coronavirus back into this company, and agreement, YRC has agreed to steps to put GM at a disadvan- his authority, and asked that
million federal loan announced stimulus bill, will over time invest in the fleet and the roll- issue about 15.9 million shares tage, and felt strongly about the case be moved to a differ-
last week, YRC Chief Financial nearly double its debt load to ing stock,” he said, which will of common stock to the Trea- pursuing a legal case, people ent judge. On Monday, the
Officer Jamie Pierson said in around $1.6 billion, Mr. Pier- reduce the company’s operat- sury Department, according to familiar with the matter said. court sided with GM on the
an interview. son said. ing costs. a Tuesday securities filing, Legal experts had described meeting between Ms. Barra and
Altogether, the agreements The trucker plans to use a Buying new trucks will save giving the government a 29.6% GM’s civil-racketeering suit as Fiat Chrysler Chief Executive
give YRC “3½ years to focus $300 million tranche of the YRC between $10,000 and stake in the business and di- unusual and a long shot, noting Mike Manley, but denied the
on the business, with no ma- government loan to pay off $12,000 per tractor “on main- luting the shares of existing that such cases often are set- request to reassign the case.
turities at all,” Mr. Pierson health, pension and other obli- tenance alone,” he said. It is investors. tled or dismissed because of GM based much of its racke-
said. “It’s a new day. We’ve gations, and for working capi- “not only refreshing the fleet, That equity will be deliv- the difficulty of proving the teering suit on evidence from a
just got to not blow it up.” tal, Mr. Pierson said. Another but it’s also additional liquid- ered to a voting trust, and company was the primary vic- long-running federal investiga-
YRC, the fifth-largest truck- $400 million will go toward ity to operate the business.” once a one-year holding pe- tim of the alleged corruption. tion into union corruption that
ing company in the U.S. by buying new trucks and trailers YRC serves big retail ship- riod expires the government is In a civil-racketeering case, a has led to the convictions of
revenue, according to SJ Con- for YRC’s aging fleet, accord- pers such as Walmart Inc. and free to sell or hold the stock court typically considers claims Fiat Chrysler’s former top bar-
sulting Group Inc., carries ing to the filing. That loan will Home Depot Inc., along with as it sees fit, Mr. Pierson said. from only the primary victim of gainer and several United Auto
some $880 million in long- mature on Sept. 30, 2024. automotive and industrial cus- The boost from the govern- the alleged corruption, legal ex- Workers officials.
term debt and was struggling YRC doesn’t plan to pay the tomers. The company gener- ment loan will offset the dilu- perts have said. In his dis- JPMorgan Chase had esti-
to turn its operations around debt down during the life of ated $4.87 billion in operating tion to existing investors’ missal, the judge said any com- mated that GM could seek dam-
when the coronavirus pan- the loan, intending instead to revenue last year but has long shares “in spades,” Mr. Pier- petitive disadvantage suffered ages from Fiat Chrysler in ex-
demic hit, delivering a signifi- either pay it off or refinance struggled with heavy debt and son said. “The market value of by GM as a result of Fiat Chrys- cess of $6 billion if the case
cant blow to its business. at maturity, Mr. Pierson said. pension liabilities for its the company has in- ler’s lower labor costs would were to move forward.
The Treasury Department “We are going to take every largely unionized workforce. creased … since the deal was have been an indirect injury. —Nora Naughton
loan, through a provision of penny we can and invest it Under the federal loan announced.” Peter Henning, a law profes- contributed to this article.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, July 9, 2020 | B7
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
26067.28 s 177.10, or 0.68% Trailing P/E ratio 22.16 18.47 3169.94 s 24.62, or 0.78% Trailing P/E ratio * 27.38 23.10 10492.50 s 148.61, or 1.44% Trailing P/E ratio *† 31.95 24.49
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 23.94 16.50 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 25.12 17.89 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate *† 30.59 21.75
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 2.50 2.21 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield * 1.97 1.89 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield *† 0.86 1.03
All-time high 29551.42, 02/12/20 All-time high 3386.15, 02/19/20 All-time high: 10492.50, 07/08/20
note yield Macau pataca .1253 7.9825 –0.4 Egypt pound .0624 16.0205 –0.2
Hanscom AFB, MA 800-656-4328 1 3 6 1 2 3 5 7 10 20 30 2019 2020
0.00 month(s) years Malaysia ringgit .2342 4.2695 4.4 Israel shekel .2900 3.4488 –0.1
J A S O N D J FM AM J J STAR Financial Bank 2.88% New Zealand dollar .6575 1.5209 2.4 Kuwait dinar 3.2472 .3080 1.6
Fort Wayne, IN 765-622-4185 maturity Pakistan rupee .00598 167.150 7.8 Oman sul rial 2.5974 .3850 unch
2019 2020
Sources: Tradeweb ICE U.S. Treasury Close; Tullett Prebon; Dow Jones Market Data Philippines peso .0202 49.502 –2.4 Qatar rial .2746 3.641 –0.1
Yield/Rate (%) 52-Week Range (%) 3-yr chg Singapore dollar .7188 1.3912 3.4 Saudi Arabia riyal .2666 3.7510 –0.01
Interest rate Last (l)Week ago Low 0 2 4 6 8 High (pct pts)
Corporate Borrowing Rates and Yields South Korea won .0008384 1192.75 3.3 South Africa rand .0590 16.9383 21.0
Federal-funds rate target 2.00-2.25 2.00-2.25 1.75 l 2.25 -1.00 Sri Lanka rupee .0053813 185.83 2.5
Yield (%) 52-Week Total Return (%) Taiwan dollar .03397 29.439 –1.6 Close Net Chg % Chg YTD%Chg
Prime rate* 3.25 3.25 3.25 l 5.50 -1.00 Bond total return index Close Last Week ago High Low 52-wk 3-yr Thailand baht .03206 31.190 4.8 WSJ Dollar Index 90.83 –0.40–0.43 1.41
Libor, 3-month 0.27 0.30 0.27 l 2.34 -1.03
U.S. Treasury, Barclays 2478.880 0.490 0.520 2.040 0.480 10.78 5.77 Sources: Tullett Prebon, Dow Jones Market Data
Money market, annual yield 0.27 0.27 0.27 l 0.78 -0.06
1.290 25.81 12.81
Five-year CD, annual yield 0.72 0.73 0.71 l 1.97 -0.68 U.S. Treasury Long, Barclays 4890.980 1.340 2.570 0.980
Commodities
30-year mortgage, fixed† 3.22 3.28 3.22 l 4.22 -0.83 Aggregate, Barclays 2270.530 1.210 1.270 2.590 1.210 9.21 5.59 Wednesday 52-Week YTD
Pricing trends on someClose
raw materials, or commodities
Net chg % Chg High Low % Chg % chg
15-year mortgage, fixed† 2.76 2.83 2.76 l 3.57 -0.51 Fixed-Rate MBS, Barclays 2225.420 1.290 1.360 2.790 0.930 5.68 4.09
Jumbo mortgages, $484,350-plus† 3.26 3.33 3.26 l 4.71 -1.19 DJ Commodity 578.83 2.66 0.46 647.86 433.70 -7.50 -9.88
High Yield 100, ICE BofA 3036.252 5.540 5.837 10.740 4.516 –1.373 2.694
Five-year adj mortgage (ARM)† 3.13 3.15 3.11 l 4.78 -0.32 TR/CC CRB Index 141.96 0.40 0.28 187.39 106.29 -22.92 -23.59
Muni Master, ICE BofA 582.324 1.171 1.201 3.441 0.959 4.767 4.209 Crude oil, $ per barrel 40.90 0.28 0.69 63.27 -37.63 -32.32 -33.02
New-car loan, 48-month 4.29 4.44 4.17 l 4.70 1.16
Bankrate.com rates based on survey of over 4,800 online banks. *Base rate posted by 70% of the nation's largest EMBI Global, J.P. Morgan 875.381 5.011 5.106 7.480 4.523 2.507 4.006 Natural gas, $/MMBtu 1.824 -0.052 -2.77 2.862 1.482 -25.37 -16.67
banks.† Excludes closing costs.
Sources: FactSet; Dow Jones Market Data; Bankrate.com Sources: J.P. Morgan; S&P Dow Jones Indices; Bloomberg Barclays; ICE Data Services Gold, $ per troy oz. 1815.50 11.30 0.63 1815.50 1404.30 28.75 19.48
Get real-time U.S. stock quotes and track most-active stocks, new highs/lows and mutual funds. Plus, deeper money-flows data and email delivery of key stock-market data. Available free at WSJMarkets.com
B8 | Thursday, July 9, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
COMMODITIES wsj.com/market-data/commodities
End of Payday Lending Effort Faulted KKR Deal relationship with Blackstone in
conjunction with a deal by Fi-
delity National Financial Inc. to
enter the market for high-in- regulators on how to cater to Co-President Scott Nuttall said reinsurance group. It separated
terest consumer loans. lower-income consumers who on an investor conference call from Goldman in 2013.
The Consumer Financial Pro- don’t qualify for conventional Wednesday. “It’s an enormous Global Atlantic has a history
tection Bureau on Tuesday for- credit cards or other lending market and in this low-rate of expansion through acquisi-
mally repealed a key provision products because they have im- world, we’ve been finding that tions, completing 20 reinsur-
of a proposed regulation re- paired or no credit history. insurance companies are look- ance transactions covering
quiring lenders to verify bor- The Consumer Bankers Asso- ing for alternative investments about $27 billion in assets
rowers’ incomes to ensure that ciation, which represents big within their portfolios.” since its founding. KKR said it
they can afford to repay the banks including JPMorgan Investors cheered the news, plans to continue to build the
loans, which charge annual in- CFPB Director Kathleen Kraninger said the action would ensure that Chase & Co. and Bank of Amer- with KKR’s shares rising 10% in business through deals.
terest rates as high as 400%. At consumers have access to credit from a competitive marketplace. ica Corp., said the amended rule trading Wednesday. Like Athene and FGL, the
the same time, the bureau said will help banks provide “much- Apollo, the original archi- company focuses on fixed an-
it would move ahead with an- law against bad actors.” The Community Financial needed small-dollar loans to tect of the strategy, joined with nuities, which pay owners a set
other provision that limits how Consumer advocates criti- Services Association of Amer- consumers in need.” former American International
often lenders can access bor- cized the decision, saying it ica, a trade group that repre- Bank regulators, including Group Inc. executive James Be-
rowers’ bank accounts in their put vulnerable consumers at sents small-dollar, short-term the Federal Reserve Board and lardi in 2009 to build what
attempt to collect payments. risk of being mired in high-in- lenders, said the new rule will the Federal Deposit Insurance would become Athene Holding
Global Atlantic has
In a statement, CFPB Direc- terest debt they cannot repay. benefit millions of American Corp., in May issued joint Ltd. Financed by an investment nearly $90 billion in
tor Kathleen Kraninger said “Amid a global pandemic consumers. “The CFPB’s action guidance for banks that seek from a publicly traded vehicle
the bureau’s action would “en- and an economic contraction will ensure that essential credit to offer “responsible small- Apollo controlled, Athene
assets and is valued
sure that consumers have ac- with little precedent, the CFPB continues to flow to communi- dollar loans.” bought up fixed-annuity assets at $4.4 billion.
cess to credit from a competi- has chosen to devote scarce ties and consumers across the The proposal to restrict the on the cheap in the aftermath
tive marketplace, have the best resources not to protecting country, which is especially im- payday loan industry, years in of the financial crisis and
information to make informed consumers, but to dismantling portant in these unprecedented the works, was introduced in signed them over to the buy-
financial decisions, and retain guardrails that would have times,” D. Lynn DeVault, the late 2017, days before Richard out firm to manage. amount of interest over the life
key protections without hin- given people more protection group’s chairman, said. Cordray, the Obama-appointed Apollo now manages $140 of a contract. Insurers make
dering that access.” She said from predatory lenders,” said Consumer groups have director, left the bureau. The billion of assets on behalf of money by earning more on the
the bureau “will continue to Linda Jun, senior policy called on lawmakers to impose bureau soon put the proposal Athene and Athora Holding money handed over by buyers
monitor the small-dollar lend- counsel at Americans for Fi- a limit of 36% on interest rates on hold and revised it before fi- Ltd., a European insurance than they are required to pay
ing industry and enforce the nancial Reform. for consumer loans. More than nally rescinding it on Tuesday. company it founded in 2014. out, making them attractive to
That accounted for 44% of private-credit managers.
Apollo’s total assets at the end KKR will pay the amount of
Fed Official Sees Likely Need for Loan Program of March and contributed the
bulk of the $190 million in fee-
related revenue the firm re-
Global Atlantic’s book value as
of the deal’s closing through a
combination of cash from the
BY PAUL KIERNAN dent of the Federal Reserve be eligible to access the loans. completed the registration pro- ceived from permanent-capital firm’s balance sheet, proceeds
Bank of Boston, said in an in- Of the five largest U.S. cess, while another 174 are still vehicles in the first quarter. from potential minority co-in-
WASHINGTON—The Federal terview Wednesday. “So banks by assets, only Bank of signing up. Apollo’s credit business has vestors and the issuance of
Reserve’s $600 billion lending there’s an insurance element America Corp. has indicated He acknowledged that it is ballooned as a result of the debt or equity. Global Atlan-
program for medium-size against the pandemic, as well that it plans to make Main “going to take some time for strategy, becoming the envy of tic’s book value as of March 31
businesses hasn’t attracted as meeting an immediate need Street loans available to new banks and borrowers to be- its peers, and is now the indus- was about $4.4 billion, the
much interest yet, but that is of some borrowers.” customers. Three others— come familiar with the pro- try’s largest, with $210 billion companies said.
likely to change if the U.S. The Main Street Lending Wells Fargo & Co., Citigroup gram” but that he fully expects in assets as of March 31. Global Atlantic sharehold-
economy takes a turn for the Program aims to lend to com- Inc. and U.S. Bancorp.—said demand to pick up. Blackstone got the right to ers, which include Goldman
worse amid rising coronavirus panies contending with the they plan only to serve existing Under the program, banks manage the assets of FGL and its private-wealth clients,
cases, said the official who economic fallout from the pan- customers. JPMorgan Chase & will lend between $250,000 Holdings Inc., formerly known will have the opportunity to
runs the program. demic, but it has struggled to Co. didn’t say whether it and $300 million to businesses as Fidelity & Guaranty Life, roll their investments into the
“The likelihood that we con- get off the ground since it was planned to lend to new cus- that were creditworthy before when a special-purpose acqui- deal. KKR said it initially ex-
tinue to have serious problems announced in April. Its rollout tomers through the program. the economic crisis began. A sition company in which the pects to have about 60% eco-
with the infections means that was held up by negotiations Almost 11,000 federally in- Fed facility will then buy a private-equity firm invested nomic ownership of the com-
businesses are likely to be dis- over terms, while bankers have sured banks and credit unions 95% stake in those loans, leav- bought the insurer in late 2017. pany. Global Atlantic will
rupted for a longer period of expressed skepticism that many could be eligible. Mr. Rosen- ing originating banks with 5% In February, FGL said it was remain a separate business un-
time,” Eric Rosengren, presi- borrowers that need help will gren said that 260 lenders have of the credit risk. extending and enhancing its der Mr. Levine’s leadership.
MARKETS
ECB Helps
Close Gap
Gold ETFs Add Record $40 Billion
BY AMRITH RAMKUMAR Gold prices* Monthly net flows Performance of gold-mining
Lagarde backed
away from her initial
position on being a
Chinese Stocks Extend Rally to a Seventh Day
BY JOE WALLACE parts of the country, and ten- Index performance Wednesday “There’s definitely never
backstop. AND GUNJAN BANERJI sions have risen between been more unknown unknowns
China and the U.S. Shanghai Composite 1.74% out there,” said Nancy Davis,
U.S. stocks rose while main- “I would characterize the portfolio manager of the Qua-
land Chinese shares extended stock market as relatively im- Nasdaq Composite 1.44 dratic Interest Rate Volatility
“If you know that the ECB is their winning streak for a sev- mune to the [health] crisis,” and Inflation Hedge Exchange-
there to protect the spread enth day. said Gregory Perdon, co-chief Russell 2000 0.81 Traded Fund. “We’ll have to
market, why would you want Major indexes wavered for investment officer at Arbuth- see whether the economy can
to bet against it?” said Peter much of the day before turn- not Latham & Co., a U.K. pri- S&P 500 0.78 stay open and people can get
Schaffrik, a global macro strat- ing higher late in the session. vate bank. It is difficult for back to work.”
egist at RBC Capital Markets. The jump stock prices to go down when Dow industrials 0.68 The unemployment rate fell
The central bank “has made WEDNESDAY’S helped claw stimulus measures by the Fed- in June but still hovered at
huge contributions to stability MARKETS back losses eral Reserve and European Hang Seng 0.59 11.1%.
in financial markets. The mar- from the prior Central Bank have pinned Chinese shares resumed
ket is reassured.” session, when the S&P 500 fell down bond yields, he added. –0.67 Stoxx Europe 600 their recent spurt, pushing the
This is despite historic con- and snapped its five-session That has been on display Shanghai Composite Index up
tractions in European coun- winning streak. this week. –0.78 Nikkei Stock Average 1.7%. Early Thursday, the
tries’ economies resulting from Stocks have traded in a nar- The Nasdaq Composite benchmark was up 0.2%.
the lockdowns and a surge in row range for the past month, added 148.61 points, or 1.4%, Source: FactSet The index has advanced 8%
debt issuance as governments after zipping higher for much to a record 10492.50. this week as individual inves-
seek to fund their fiscal stimu- of the second quarter. The S&P 500 advanced tors are looking for safety. 20% for the year and about 4% tors bet that a recovering
lus programs. Investors have been weigh- 24.62 points, or 0.8%, to Gold prices are hovering at below their record of $1,891.90 economy will boost profits.
Italy was the first country ing stimulus efforts by central 3169.94, led by shares of tech- the highest level since 2011. from August 2011. At midday Thursday in To-
in the region to implement a banks and governments nology companies. The Dow On Wednesday, the most ac- Meanwhile, shares of ho- kyo, the Nikkei 225 Stock Av-
lockdown in early March and against signs that the rebound Jones Industrial Average tively traded gold futures rose tels, airlines, restaurants and erage was up 0.2%, Hong
subsequently its economy is in U.S. economic growth has gained 177.10 points, or 0.7%, 0.6% to $1,820.60 a troy ounce other companies that have Kong’s Hang Seng Index was
expected to be the worst-hit in lost speed. to 26067.28. on the Comex division of the been affected by coronavirus- flat and South Korea’s Kospi
the trade bloc in 2020. The Eu- Meanwhile, there has been Despite the recent stock New York Mercantile Ex- related lockdowns have fallen was up 0.5%. U.S. stock futures
ropean Commission is fore- a jump in coronavirus cases in gains, there are signs inves- change. Prices are up nearly over the past month. were down slightly.
casting that it will shrink
11.2%. Greece is predicted to
contract by 9%, compared with
an expected decline of 8.7%
across the euro area.
Bets on
Ms. Lagarde said on March
12 that the ECB was “not here
to close spreads.” After a
Business
sharp selloff in southern Euro-
pean government debt, she
quickly pivoted to echo the
Reopenings
rhetoric of her predecessor.
Mario Draghi, pledging to do
“everything necessary” to help
Lose Steam
the eurozone through the cri- BY AKANE OTANI
sis. Six days later, the ECB an-
nounced a €750 billion Bets on a relatively smooth
($846.84 billion) bond-buying reopening of businesses
program, which was expanded across America are fizzling
to €1.35 trillion June 4. out in the stock market.
This program is expected to Shares of hotels, airlines,
DAVID PAUL MORRIS/BLOOMBERG NEWS
HEARD STREET ON
THE
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS & COMMENTARY
Investors Should
Beware of Bargains
At Shopping Malls
After years of worrying about e- income will settle in the future. Less
commerce, mall owners face another than one-third of rent due for April
unwelcome reckoning from the pan- was collected by U.S. mall landlords,
demic. Their stocks appear cheap, according to Fitch Ratings.
but investors are better off window Permanent rent cuts will be
shopping until the long-term hit to needed to avoid a rise in vacan-
rental income is understood. cies. Even well-funded interna-
Retail real-estate investment tional brands like Swedish fashion The company has launched new iPhones in the last half of September every year since 2012. CEO Tim Cook last year.
ings at companies in the S&P 500 –10 rush the doors of the office of the still. More recently, a surprising epi-
will show a drop of 43.9% from a Miami-Dade supervisor of elections. thet is sometimes attached to the
year earlier. That is far worse than –20 Or consider that cultural arche- brand. One Etsy listing describes a
the 11.7% decline they forecast at type of the 1980s: the yuppie. In Brooks Brothers argyle sweater as
the outset of the quarter, when it –30 that decade, stories about this de- “hipster,” and an eBay listing used
was clear the crisis was buckling mographic were almost always ac- the same term to describe one of
the economy. –40 companied by some of their favor- its tan leather garment bags. Brooks
There is a tendency for analysts ite brands, Brooks Brothers among Brothers’ legacy may live on in the
to set a low bar for earnings even –50 them. A 1990 Wall Street Journal closets of the yuppies’ children.
in normal times. In the second
Jan. Feb. March April May June July
quarter that tendency may have
gone into hyperdrive. This is be- Source: IBES data from Refinitiv
cause the bulk of the downward
revisions happened early in the
quarter, before it was clear the
onavirus caution flags have gone
back up, spending in June looks to
Levi Strauss Looks Faded in a Pandemic
economy had started bouncing have improved from May’s level.
back. That bounceback hasn’t Analysts’ difficulty figuring out Many have joked that seated compared with a 34% decline for accounted for 5% of total sales a
spurred many upward revisions. what is happening on the ground Zoom calls have eliminated the need Levi Strauss, which dropped 8.4% on year earlier, brought in 15% last
At the outset of the quarter, earn- has probably amplified their cau- for new pants. Levi Strauss & Co. Wednesday. quarter. The acceleration in online
ings for industrial companies in the tion. Over 40% of companies in the shareholders aren’t laughing. While its recent results were selling means the company’s e-com-
S&P 500 were expected to decline S&P 500 have withdrawn guidance, The brand’s revenue dropped 62% markedly weaker, Levi Strauss’s re- merce business will be profitable for
by 32.8%, and by the end of May, leaving analysts flying blind. Mean- in the quarter ended May 24 com- treat seems excessive for a company the full year, ahead of expectations.
that drop was marked down to 88%. while, many techniques analysts use pared with a year earlier, and the that has posted solid performance And while denim isn’t an up-and-
Now estimates are calling for an to decipher what is happening with company swung to a net loss. coming growth category like athletic
89.1% decline. The pickup in indus- their companies, such as factory A couple of factors compounded wear, Euromonitor still predicts the
trial activity that was reflected in tours and store checks, have been the poor performance: One was that market will grow 2% to 3% a year in
the Institute for Supply Manage- put on hold. its business is pants-focused. The
Almost 40% of reopened the U.S. The jeans maker’s domestic
ment’s better-than-expected June Even if companies beat current company said on a Tuesday earnings stores saw sales brand awareness is topped only by
manufacturing report last week estimates handily, there is no cer- call that its tops business, which ac- Nike, according to a survey con-
seems not to have registered. tainty their results will be met with counted for 21% of sales last fiscal
numbers exceed year- ducted by UBS Research last year.
Similarly, earnings for consumer glee. The torrid recovery in stocks year, fared better in the last quarter. ago levels last month. Like many of its peers, the com-
cyclical companies were expected suggests any good news on earn- Aside from the aforementioned issue pany is using the bad months to fo-
to slip by 33% at the start of the ings may have been baked in even of presentability on camera, custom- cus its attention where it matters,
quarter, by 109.7% at the end of as more recent news on Covid calls ers might be less comfortable buy- including high-tech initiatives in de-
May (in other words, to show out- into question the rapid improve- ing pants online without the ability over the past few years. sign and product development.
right losses), and are now pegged ment analysts expect following the to try them on. The second factor It seems to be faring far better Levi Strauss has weathered a lot
to fall by 114%. Yet the Commerce second quarter. Current forecasts was the timing of its quarter, which where bricks-and-mortar sales have of storms in its 167-year history. The
Department’s May retail sales re- show S&P 500 earnings slipping encompassed the peak pandemic resumed. As stores reopened, Levi depth of its latest swoon, a blip in
port, released in mid-June, showed 24.7% in the third quarter, 13.2% in months of March, April and May. Strauss stopped burning cash and the long run, might present a buying
a much bigger bounce from April the fourth quarter and then gaining Nike, another apparel brand with saw positive cash flow in June. Al- opportunity. If any apparel maker
than economists expected. Even 12.2% in the first quarter. a similar reporting period, saw reve- most 40% of reopened stores saw can look even more stylish after be-
though credit-card data suggest That could be a stretch. nue drop by a much milder 38%. Its sales numbers exceed year-ago lev- ing stretched and torn, it is this one.
sales have softened recently as cor- —Justin Lahart share price is down 4% year to date els last month. E-commerce, which —Jinjoo Lee