Barge Tutorial: Hecsalv8/Posse5
Barge Tutorial: Hecsalv8/Posse5
Barge Tutorial
2.4
9.0
3.0 1.5 7.5 10.8 10.8 10.8 9.6 6.0
4.5
9.0
5.4
1.5
4.5
Barge Tutorial • 2
Contents
Introduction 5
Overview ....................................................................................................................................................................... 5
The Sample Barge ......................................................................................................................................................... 5
The Sample Exercises .................................................................................................................................................... 5
Sample Analyses 51
Overview ..................................................................................................................................................................... 51
Prerequisites ................................................................................................................................................................ 51
Objectives .................................................................................................................................................................... 51
Description of the Incident .......................................................................................................................................... 52
Defining the Incident Initial Condition (Before Stranding) ......................................................................................... 52
Current Condition (After Stranding)............................................................................................................................ 54
Detailed Damage Analysis .......................................................................................................................................... 55
Developing the Plan..................................................................................................................................................... 60
High Tide ..................................................................................................................................................................... 60
Low Tide ..................................................................................................................................................................... 63
Summary...................................................................................................................................................................... 68
Glossary of Terms 87
Barge Tutorial • 3
Hull Definition............................................................................................................................................................. 91
Skeg Properties ............................................................................................................................................................ 92
Skeg Offsets................................................................................................................................................................. 92
General Arrangement .................................................................................................................................................. 93
Lightship ...................................................................................................................................................................... 94
Lightship Weight Ordinates ......................................................................................................................................... 94
Lightship Weight Blocks ............................................................................................................................................. 94
Structural Section ........................................................................................................................................................ 95
Barge Tutorial • 4
Introduction
Overview
This tutorial is aimed at providing a general overview of the key pieces of the HECSALV/POSSE software
suite. Using step-by-step procedures, the tutorial will first take you through the basic processes of
defining a ship model from technical drawings, and then you will be shown how to perform some typical
salvage and emergency response analyses using the resulting ship model.
The tutorial is broken up into two distinct parts, Defining the Model and Sample Analyses with the
intention that if your task only involves salvage response and not ship modeling, you can skip the first part
and use the completed Sample Barge model that is included with the installation to perform the sample
analyses.
For each major task in the tutorial, a general overview of the user interface is provided as well as detailed
instructions related directly to the samples. For a more comprehensive treatment of the user interface
and functionality of the software, please refer to the HECSALV/POSSE User Manuals.
The technical specification for the barge is designed for simplicity, reducing the amount of repetitive data
entry that would be involved in a more complex vessel, while still incorporating as many of the essential
data elements as possible. This will enable a variety of analyses to be performed on a ship model that
can be quickly developed.
A full specification of the sample barge is provided in the supplementary appendix: Sample Barge
Definition. Relevant excerpts of the specification will be included throughout the tutorial.
Congratulations, you have just initiated a new ship project! As mentioned, the SPE is set up to allow for
the entry of data in just about any order. However, the main nodes of the Project Tree view in the SPE
are arranged in a typical order in which you might enter the data, and so can be used as a guideline for
how to proceed. After entering principle particulars you would most likely move on to enter data related to
general ship properties (frame table, longitudinal reference points, number of propellers, etc.). After this
basic information is entered, it is logical to proceed on to define the geometry of the hull, the internal
compartmentation, and so o18n. The figure above shows how the Project Explorer mirrors this natural
data entry progression. Each of the main nodes of the project tree has been expanded to show further
details of how the data elements are organized. Having entered the most basic information related to the
XBarge (i.e. name and principle dimensions), you can now proceed to enter additional general
information.
Particulars
Enter additional general particulars
• Select the Particulars node of the tree view.
• In the main work area, the input fields will be displayed as shown in the figure below. Enter
additional information for the following fields:
References
It is helpful at this stage to examine the general frames of reference used in the technical description of
the barge (Appendix). By paging through the technical description the following observations can be
made:
• Frames are numbered from “0” at the AP to “100” at the FP, with a 0.6m frame spacing
throughout,
• Longitudinal distances are measured in m from the AP with positive values indicating meters
forward (x direction),
• Vertical distances are measured from the baseline (molded topside of keel plate),
Transverse distances are measured from the centerline with positive values indicating meters to
starboard. Typical reference planes are automatically provided as default values as follows:
For the purposes of this exercise, only the default reference systems are required. However, it is worth
noting that it is possible to define special reference points if required. For example, if you are given a
shipyard drawing that shows the vertical center of gravity of deck tanks in terms of meters above the
deck, then it might make the data entry easier if you defined a third vertical reference point called “Deck”
along with the BL and Keel.
• Select the Change Axis Settings button to open the display options editor. This can also be
opened from the main menu by selecting Tools | Display Options and clicking on the Axis
Settings tab. The Axis Setting tab is used to set the x, y and z axis default settings. Make sure
the Reference Plane set as shown below. Locations representing AP (aft perpendicular), BL
(Baseline), and CL (centerline) should already be defined and available.
• The Standard Ship Settings button can also be used to reset these settings. A high level of
control is provided to control the display of location information for ships and offshore shapes.
It is up to you how much (or how little) version information you would like to keep track of. A good
guideline is to have one version number for each major release of the ship project (starting with the initial
definition). Version notes are not so important during the initial definition, but starting with a first major
modification to the ship project (i.e. “version 2”), a short version note should be added for each major
element of data that is modified, added, or deleted.
• Click on the Generate button to generate the entire table from the entered information. Then
Select OK to save the table. Review the frame table to make sure it matches the data provided.
Items highlighted in yellow in the tables are locked and cannot be modified. If you cannot see the
yellow on your computer control the color by opening the Tools | Options menu and reviewing the
settings on the Tables tab.
It is best to use simple numerical names for the frames if possible. Frame labels can be shown in
2d and 3d graphic displays, and keeping the names very short improves readability.
Draft Marks
Now that the frames of reference have been defined, they can be used to start describing the actual
physical aspects of the barge beyond just the principle particulars. The first node under Ship Properties is
labeled Propellers. Of course, you will not need to enter any data here for the barge, but this is the place
where you would enter the location and diameter of a propeller, and how to display the results of the
immersion calculation (i.e. whether to display the immersed propeller as 50% or 100% immersion).
Multiple sets of draft marks can be defined, such as adding drafts at instrumented locations, but only one is required
for this tutorial.
Strength Locations
The Sample Barge Definition does contain information pertaining to the strength locations. Entering these
longitudinal locations has a dual purpose. First, it defines the locations along the length of the hull where
the strength results (shear forces and bending moments) are to be calculated and displayed. Secondly,
this table allows you to enter section properties which will further enable the calculations of deck and keel
stresses and deflection. For the purpose of this sample barge, you are simply going to enter the strength
locations to enable the shear force and bending moment calculations.
According to the Sample Barge Definition the strength locations are as follows:
In addition to the above table, SPE also provides a graphic view of the data entered. If you were to have
entered values for Shear Area, Section Modulus, etc., you would be able to view the entered data
graphically. This additional information regarding section modulus properties will not be used for this
sample barge. In general, the SPE provides this graphing capability wherever it can act as a visual aid to
checking the entered data.
The following drawing extracted from the Sample Barge Definition provides all you will need to define the
basic hull shape using offsets. From the profile view at the top of the figure, the offset station locations
can be defined, and from the body plan view, you will be able to develop each station’s offsets.
1.5m
3m
6m
2.55
0.3m
12m 6m
42m
60m
6m 6m 6m 6m 6m 6m 6m 6m 3m 3m 3m 3m
18m
1.2m
0.6m 10.2m
6, 9 6, 0 6, 9
5.7, 9
4.5, 7.8
4.5, 0
3.6, 9
3.174, 8.826 3.15, 9
3, 8.4 3, 0
2.25, 8.1
2.1, 9
2.25, 0
1.674, 8.826
1.5, 8.4 1.5, 0
0.6, 9 0.6, 9
0.174, 8.826 0.174, 8.826
0, 8.4 0, 0 0, 8.4
Hull Editor
• A new window is displayed to enter the offsets to define the hull shape and compute hull volume
properties. The top of the window is an area for graphically displaying the sections as they are
defined. The bottom contains tables to define the station locations and offsets as shown below.
The right table is provided to define the offsets for the active section (table appears as soon as a
station location is defined).
• Start by entering the station locations (as indicated in the hull definition drawing) in the first
column of the left hand table. Remember to enter the stations from aft to forward. Start with the
station labeled “0” at the AP and work forward.
For a symmetrical station, offsets are to be entered in a counter-clockwise direction looking forward,
starting and ending on the centerline.
The program will mathematically fit a curve between the offset points you define, in order to describe the
shape of the station at any point between the entered offsets and the shape of the surface between
stations. Special properties can be set on the offset points to more accurately define the shapes. In
particular, a point can be defined as an “ArcMidPt”, a “Chine”, or a “Deck Edge”:
• ArcMidPt – a point designated as the midpoint of an arc will result in an arc being drawn through
that point and the two adjacent points.
• Chine – a chine is used to identify a hard corner, or “knuckle,” in the shape of the section, and to
connect geometry features from station to station (for example, the deck edge or the flat of
bottom). Chines are used to improve the interpolation of new stations between the defined
stations which is necessary during compartment generation and for analysis cross section
graphics.
• Deck Edge – The deck edge is a special chine that assists the SPE in automatically connecting a
separately defined deck (with deck camber, for example) to a hull. Refer to the user manual for
details.
Note that chines and arcs are very important not just to defining the sectional shape of a given station, but
also for interpolating sectional shapes in between the defined stations. Refer to the user manual for a full
discussion on chines.
The index of the chines you define are important. Since chines stretch over a longitudinal
distance of the hull, using the same chine number in adjacent stations will provide the longitudinal
continuity and improve the interpolation of interior geometry.
The tabs on the right hand side of the graphic view of the stations allow you to view the information you
have entered in a number of different ways, as follows:
• Active – displays the active station in body plan view. As you step through the offsets, the
active offset is highlighted on the screen. Other selected stations are also shown in less
detail.
• Loc – shows, in profile view, the station locations that you have entered (this is helpful in
reviewing your station spacing if you are using Simpson’s rule for integration).
• All – shows all of the stations in an isometric view that can be rotated and viewed at any
angle. It also shows the continuity in the chines that you have defined, by connecting
each identically named chine with a red line.
• Body – shows all of the stations in body plan view. Note the aft stations are displayed on
the left hand side, whereas the forward stations are displayed on the right hand side in
the body view.
The figure below shows the All view of what you have entered so far, If yours is different, then you may
need to review the data you entered for the offsets.
Note that Chine points are connected longitudinally between stations with a red line to provide a visual
check that you have defined them properly.
• You are now in a position to complete the hull definition. Following station 3 the next seven
stations are identical. Use the same technique of copying the previous station to create the
offsets for the remaining stations.
• Note that for stations 9, 9 ½ and 10 (No. 11/12/13 in the table) the bilge radius no longer exists.
Make sure that you have entered the first chine point at the correct distance from the centerline.
For Stations “9”, “9 ½”, and “10”, the first chine should be 8.4m, 8.1m, and 7.8m from the
centerline, respectively.
Note that due to the prismatic shape of this Skeg, trapezoidal integration will be used.
• To refine the model lets add some interior stations. Interior stations are not necessary for
analyses with small trim/heel, but for extreme damage situations where the waterplane may pass
completely between the two modeled stations additional detail can be important. To quickly
refine turn on the Refine option in the Integration menu. The resulting model should look similar to
the one shown below.
Creating Skeg P
• Upon completing the step above, you will see the Hull displayed along with the two appended
skegs. The skegs are shown in a regular black outline. Note that any subtracted compartments
will be shown in red.
2.4
9.0
3.0 1.5 7.5 10.8 10.8 10.8 9.6 6.0
4.5
9.0
5.4
1.5
4.5
Compartments
Compartments can be constructed the same way we built the hull and skegs. However the SPE provides
a variety of ways to automatically generate offset geometry based on parent volumes, boundaries and
other methods that greatly simplifies the creation of compartments.
Typically volumes used for compartments are generated simply by specifying boundaries. The following
are examples of boundaries:
• A vertical, horizontal, or transverse Plane defined by its location relative to the appropriate
reference point. For example, if the top of a tank is defined by a perfectly horizontal deck, 3.0 m
above the baseline, then the top boundary would completely be defined by the value 3.0 m (from
BL).
• A user defined Bulkhead. This is an object, also defined by offsets, that represents a surface with
some shape to it. Bulkheads can be used when the boundary of a tank isn’t a perfectly flat plane.
In general, compartments (and the volumes used to attach to them) can be defined by specifying six
boundaries (fore/aft, top/bottom, and port/starboard). Any previously defined offset model (such as our
hull) can be used as a boundary to define a new volume. Selecting the Hull (for example) as a Base
means that you start out with the exact geometry of the hull, and then you specify internal boundaries that
cut away the parts of the hull that you don’t need.
To take the example further, if you were to use the XBarge hull as a base, and then specify an aft
boundary of 30 m-AP (essentially an aft boundary at the midship), the resulting new compartment would
look like just the forward half of the hull. If you were to then specify a starboard boundary of 0.0 m from
centerline, the SPE would take that forward half of the hull, and further cut away everything to starboard
of the centerline, resulting in a compartment that looks like the forward and port quarter of the hull. Any
internal boundary not specified tells the SPE to use the base as the boundary.
This concept will be further illustrated in the next step.
• In the Define Boundaries window that appears, you will see in the first line, Base Volume, that the
Hull is specified as the base compartment. If the base is not defined then enter “Hull” for the
base.
Defining CO 1P boundaries
• Referring to the general arrangement drawing in the appendix, CO 1P extends from Frame 74 to
Frame 90. Since these longitudinal boundaries represent perfect transverse planes (i.e. there is
no shape to the boundary) you can simply enter the longitudinal location of these boundaries.
Using the frame location shorthand, type “f74” in the field, Long Bounds | Aft. Similarly, type “f90”
in Long Bounds | Fwd.
• Since CO 1P extends vertically from the bottom of the Hull (keel) to the top of the Hull (topside
deck) you don’t need to specifically define these bounds. The SPE will know to use the Hull
(base) as the lower and upper boundaries.
Spaces for CO 1P
Defining Bulkheads/Decks
Creating the tank CO 1P from boundaries was relatively simple. However, not all tanks are bounded by
perfectly flat planes. If you look at Cargo Oil tank # 4P (CO 4P) in the plan view of the general
arrangement drawing in the appendix, you will see that the starboard boundary (i.e. the bulkhead
between CO 4P and CO 4C) cannot be specified as easily as CO 1P.
• You have just created a fence post 12 m-AP and 3 m to port of centerline, and that extends from
below the base line to just above the deck.
• For the second station at 17.4 m-AP, copy offsets from the previous station (click on Station 2 to
make it active and then press the F4 key on your keyboard) and then modify the offsets to reflect
that the “fence post” at this station is further to port of centerline (4.5m to port) as follows: Offset
1: (-1.0, -4.5), Offset 2: (7.0, -4.5)
• For the third and last station, (44.4 m-AP) you can simply copy the offsets from the previous
station (click on Station 3 to make it active and then press the F4 key).
• From the File menu, select Apply Changes and Close.
• You should now see the shape of the Wing P bulkhead superimposed on a faint outline of the hull
as above. On the tool bar menu just above the graphic view are a number of buttons that allow
you to view the displayed shape from a number of different angles. For example, clicking on the
icon will show the bulkhead in Plan View to help you verify that you have defined a shape that
looks like what you were trying to achieve from the general arrangement drawing.
This tutorial creates the bulkhead manually using offset entry to illustrate the differences
compared to volume offset entry. Options are provided in the bulkhead editor through the
Generate button to simplify the creation of simple decks and bulkheads.
Before moving on to use these bulkheads to define compartments, there is one more Bulkhead/Deck
object to create. Referring again to the general arrangement drawing, you will see that there is a stepped
deck separating the Machinery Space from the two aft void compartments. In this case you will define a
You will define the stations of the Aft Deck in a similar manner to the wing bulkheads. Of course the
vertical fence post analogy does not work here, but the concept is similar in that you will use straight lines
oriented in the athwartship direction to define the shape of the deck. Note that in order to define the
vertical step in the deck you will need to define two stations at exactly the same location. The figure below
shows, in profile, the deck that you will be creating.
You can see that there are four athwartship fence posts (marked in green) required to define the deck
surface (shown in red). You need to create a station for each of the four posts, noting that Station 1 and
Station 2 will be in exactly the same longitudinal location (and similarly Station 3 and Station 4 will both be
at the same longitudinal location).
• Clicking on Station 1 (3.0 m-AP) enter in the pair of offsets that will define the first athwartship
fence post as follows, noting that the fence post stretches from the starboard side of the hull right
across to the port side: Offset 1: (7.0, 9.0), Offset 2: (7.0, -9.0).
Cutting surfaces
• The post defined by the offsets above is actually hovering above the deck, but when connected
with the next post which will be appropriately placed at the step height it forms a cutting surface
that will produce the desired results. Define the rest of the stations as follows:
• When you have completed the above, select File | Apply Changes and Close from the menu and
your new deck should look like this:
• On the Tools menu select Generate All or press the F4 button. If you are regenerating an item
that already exists you will receive a warning message. Select Overwrite Existing Item | OK to all
for these items. Note that before pressing this button, all the names of the compartments may or
may not be in red font. This is to indicate that these items have not yet been generated (if red).
Once the generation process is complete, the names of all should be displayed in black font.
• Close the generation window and click on the Geometry/Compartments by Group node in the
tree. If you expand all of the groups under the Compartments by Group node, you will see all
new compartments that have been created from the generation table. You can click on any one of
them to see the geometry that has been generated.
Entering Loads
In the previous two sections, you defined first the hull form and then the internal compartmentation of the
hull. At this point you have completely defined a 3-dimensional model of the barge. It is now the time to
complete another significant element of the description of the barge, which is the characteristics of the
various “loads” that can be placed on the barge during its operation.
The most significant of these loads, of course, is the weight of the barge itself, or the lightship weight.
Refer to the tables in the Appendix for the lightship information. The lightship weight distribution is
described in two alternative tables: first, as ordinates of a curve describing the weight per unit length
(MT/m), and secondly as a set of weight blocks with fore and aft bounds and a longitudinal center.
• Note that a row is provided to enter a “Constant” weight. This can be used in cases where a
significant and permanent weight has been added to the lightship (such as a fixed crane or
permanent ballast). Entering a weight in this row effectively makes it a part of the lightship weight
that cannot be changed during the analysis. For the purposes of this sample barge, you can leave
this row blank.
• If these two values did not match, you would see a notice in red at the bottom. At this point you
could take one of two actions: 1-Click on the Adjust button to add one or more weight blocks over
the length of the ship to force the distribution to match the total; 2-Check your entered distribution
for a mistake. In the case of this sample barge, a mistake could be the only reason that there is a
discrepancy between the global weight and that calculated from the distribution.
Tank Capacities
Another major category of Loads is that of the operational tanks and their capacities. The definition of a
tank in the Loads section is not to be confused with the definition of the corresponding compartment in
the Geometry section. Describing a tank in the Loads section will enable you to use it as a tank in the
various analyses, varying its fill level and contents in order to describe an operational loading condition.
For example, the CO 1P compartment is a tank that may be empty, full, or anywhere in between, and so
for this reason it needs to be established as a tank load that may be manipulated in the description of any
loading condition. By contrast, the Void F compartment is not a tank, and so need not be included as a
Load.
• This window represents a tool for generating tank information. Refer to the user manual for a
complete description. For now, you are going to use this to generate not only the tank load and its
related capacity information, but also individual tank tables (i.e. fluid level dependent properties)
for all of the compartments in which you are interested.
• Make sure the Selected Compartments radio button is selected and click on Select.
• In the tree view of compartments that appears, click on the Cargo Oil and Ballast groups to
ensure that all tanks within those two groups are selected and then click OK. Verify that all eleven
tanks (nine cargo and two ballast) are listed in the summary.
• Click on the Options tab at the top of the window. Ensure that the Always radio button is selected,
and click on the Generate Loads button at the bottom of the window.
• If you click on the Tanks by Group node of the project tree view, you will see that there is now a
Cargo Oil and Ballast group. In the main window, a table showing summary information for each
group (total volume, density, etc.) is displayed. Select a color for each group.
• By clicking on the Cargo Oil group node, you will see a capacity table for all of the cargo oil tanks,
describing each individual tank’s capacity, center of gravity and free surface values. A similar
table is available for the Ballast tanks.
• One final item to check is the tank table generation. For each of the tanks listed in the capacity
table, a table of fill level-dependent properties is generated. By clicking on the Tables | Tank
Tables | CO 1P node in the project tree view, you will see the data that is generated for Cargo Oil
No. 1 Port. Note that you can choose which values to display graphically in the upper right portion
of the screen.
• You can see that a draft range has been provided according to a set of default options. Since
defaults can be edited, you might see different values to those displayed in the figure above.
• While the above drafts are perfectly adequate, you might want to use more typical values that you
might see in a Trim and Stability book. There are two ways to do this: one is to edit the defaults,
• Once you hit OK, you will be prompted to use these new default settings. Click YES.
• Note that you have selected not to include trim corrections so the values on the right hand side
will not be used. As a result, if you choose in HECSALV/POSSE to calculate results using Tables,
the hull properties will be based only on these “even keel” values. However, if you choose to
perform a direct calculation, HECSALV/POSSE will ignore these tables and calculate the
properties at the exact trim and heel depending on the load condition.
• Now that you have your drafts set, click the OK button at the bottom of the Hydrostatics
Generation Options window.
• Your newly created hydrostatic table pops up or can be viewed by clicking on the Tables |
Hydrostatic Tables | Hull node of the project tree view. Note that the table is named “Hull” to
indicate that it was calculated from the hull offsets that you defined earlier.
• Select the Displ/Draft tab. Before changing the displacements make sure the Generate By
Displacement radio button is selected. Click on the Change button and edit the displacements so
that they are the same as shown above.
• Click on the Generate button.
• Your newly created cross curves can be viewed by clicking on the Tables | Cross Curves | Hull
node of the project tree view.
If you make any changes to the hull offsets, you can quickly regenerate all three tables by simply
selecting Tables | Generate All Default Hull Tables from the main menu. Note that the draft, heel angle,
and displacement ranges will be according to the default settings.
Evaluation Criteria
The last major data category provided by the SPE is Evaluation Criteria. On most vessels there will be a
complete set of stability and strength criteria imposed on the operation of the vessel. Required GM curves
and Allowable Shear Forces and Bending Moments are among the most common criteria. For the
purpose of this barge, you will simply enter a load line.
At this stage, you have entered all the data required in order to perform a wide variety of analyses. The
resulting file Xbarge.SHP is now available for use in the main HECSALV/POSSE program as well as
supplementary analysis modules.
Model Review
Before performing analyses using your new ship project of the barge the final step is to review and
validate the model. Model review helps you find typical modeling problems and tells you what types of
analyses can be done with the data entered. A full set of tools for this purpose are provided on the
Validate menu.
Critical errors are shown in red and warnings are shown in blue. Critical errors should be corrected in the
ship project before any analyses are conducted. Warnings are an indication of possible problems and
should be reviewed. Items are checked if they have been modeled in the SPE and no critical errors have
been detected. Press the Update button to recheck the project for errors if any changes are made while
the Model review window is open.
Model Review
Model review can, and should, be done at all stages of the modeling process. See the user manual for
more details.
There are many alternative responses to any casualty. For each sample exercise described in
this chapter, the salvage response plans that are developed may not represent the only solutions.
Throughout the analysis, explanations are provided for why certain approaches are taken.
Prerequisites
The sample barge model will be used in all exercises. If you have not completed the first part of this
tutorial, Defining the Model, a completed version of the sample barge model is available.
It is assumed that you are familiar with the basic functions of managing ship model files (*.sh2) and plan
files (*.pl2). You should also be familiar at least with the following terms relating to the general
HECSALV/POSSE user interface:
• Menu
• Tool Bar
• Tree View
• Active Condition, Base Condition, Delta Condition
• Status Bar
• Calculation Type (Intact, Free-Floating, Stranded)
• Auto Update
For further information and for detailed use of HECSALV/POSSE, please refer to the user manuals.
Objectives
This sample exercise involves a basic grounding scenario and guides you step-by-step through the
description of the incident and the development of two alternative salvage plans. By the end of this
exercise, you will have learned the fundamental concepts of creating a Salvage Plan through the
judicious arrangement of a sequence of Conditions. Concepts that are covered include:
• Conditions
• Salvage Plan
• Calculation Type
• Oil Outflow
Start up HECSALV/POSSE and load the ship model for the XBarge.
• Click on Start | All Programs | HECSALV8 to open the HECSALV program group and then click
on HECSALV 8.1 to open the analysis software. You will be prompted to select a ship project to
get started. Browse for your XBarge model.
• Once loaded a single condition will be created as the starting point for your analysis. This
condition is usually a lightship condition.
For the purpose of this exercise, it is best to leave AutoUpdate mode “ON”, this is important. The
bottom right corner (within the status bar) shows the status. Select Tools | AutoUpdate from the
menu bar to change it. With AutoUpdate set to “ON” all results will be recalculated automatically
every time a condition is changed in any way. In subsequent exercises, involving a large number
of delta conditions, it may be advantageous to turn AutoUpdate “OFF” while minor updates are
being made. Otherwise, it may take some time to recalculate a large number of delta conditions
every time a single change is made.
To enter a value for an entire column at one time, click on the column heading. You will see the
entire column is automatically selected, and the cursor is placed in the top field. Type in the value
and hit enter.
• In the column labeled % Full, enter in the tank fill levels according to the owner’s information
listed in the yellow sections on the previous page.
• Since there were no other tanks or weight items to report, this should completely describe the
initial condition.
Within the HECSALV/POSSE User Interface, there are many ways to arrange the individual
windows. A very basic and useful view to start out with any analysis involves the Results | Profile
and Plan View and the Condition | Tankage and Cargo Entry view. With these two views, you
have what basically looks like an onboard loading computer (see below), and you have all you
need to quickly and easily establish the vessel’s loading condition and check the resulting stability
and strength calculations.
Using all of the information available, it is important to describe the actual condition of the
damaged vessel as accurately as possible. Mistakes made at this stage will be carried all the way
through the subsequent analysis.
One way to mitigate the risk of getting it wrong in the beginning is to develop several possible scenarios,
and examine them in parallel. As more information is made available, you can then simply eliminate the
scenarios that were based on erroneous assumptions.
For this simple example, the information from the owner is fairly comprehensive. However, there was still
some uncertainty as to whether the starboard skeg was damaged or not. One way to deal with this
uncertainty is to examine two different scenarios, one in which the skeg is breached and another in which
it remains intact.
To assist in pinpointing the boundaries of the compartment, the table in the bottom left hand side
of the Pressure Balance Location screen provides a “points-eye-view” of the boundaries of the
tank based on the point’s current location. In this way, it was simple to see that in order to move
the default point transversely out to the starboard boundary of CO 4C, it was necessary to type in
a value of 3m to stbd.
• Take a quick look at the Pressure Balance Location for CO 4S. To do so, click on the next arrow
button in the lower left corner. Check if the Location of the Damage is identical to that you have
defined for CO 4C (12.0F; 0.0; 3.0S). If not, make edits where necessary.
• The No. of Pinnacles radio button should already be set to “One Pinnacle.
• A Ground Type of “Rock” should already be selected as well.
• Click OK. You have specified a one-pinnacle grounding on a rock. Since the drafts were
specified, HECSALV/POSSE will automatically calculate the location of the ground reaction
based on the initial condition and the specified damaged tanks. Both the definition of the
damaged compartments (step 4) and the definition of the ground type are now being taken into
account in the calculation of results. Several additional values will now appear in the status bar,
including Ground Reaction.
In addition to checking your results as above, you should also check the validity of the information
received in the incident report and the assumptions that you made based on that information.
One way to do this is by opening Results | Profile and Plan View. In the stranded calculation
If you consider that the barge ran aground while it was moving directly astern or at a slight angle to
starboard, then the location of the ground reaction as calculated by HECSALV/POSSE appears to be in a
logical place in relation to the tanks that were breached and the resulting attitude of the barge.
If you arrive at this stage of the analysis, and the location of the ground reaction does not appear to be in
a location that would be consistent with the flooded tanks then that should prompt you to review the
information provided by the owner, and the subsequent data entered into HECSALV/POSSE.
There is a relationship of conditions within the plan hierarchy. If you consider the Intact condition
to be the parent condition, you would want AGRD1 and AGRD2 to be siblings. This reflects the
fact that these are alternate views of the same situation and the intention is to pursue two
independent, parallel paths of analysis. If AGRD2 was created as a delta condition to AGRD1
(effectively making it a grandchild of INTACT condition), then any changes made to AGRD1
would also affect AGRD2, making it impossible to pursue independent solutions.
• Of course, the results comparing to the AGRD1 condition are quite similar. In the following
section, the focus will be on developing a plan based on the AGRD1 condition. Nevertheless, it is
important to have this alternate view of the damage situation. The early part of salvage planning
involves defining the boundaries of the solution, and until more information is made available, this
is one way to ensure that the scope of the problem is covered.
High Tide
If they started the pump now, they would only be able to transfer roughly 120 MT of cargo (174 m3) by
the time high tide came around in 3 hours time. It is worth seeing what the ground reaction would be at
high tide after transferring the oil, but it is unlikely that with the current resources, the barge will float free
at the next high tide.
Adjust the tide height to reflect the high water mark described by the owners.
• Select Ground | Change Tide/Tide Cycle.
• Fill the table: Time Description “HT”, Day “0”, Time “1700”. Enter Tide Change “0.7”.
• Make sure the radio button for Change Water Depths by Tide Change is selected and click OK.
Edit Time/Tide
With HT as the active condition, create a delta condition and rename it “XFR” to
represent a condition in which a transfer of oil has taken place.
It is advisable to keep condition names as short as practical (ex. “XFR” rather than “Transfer”) so that you
can maximize the results and entry area of the User Interface, and still keep a large amount of the tree
view visible. This is especially important as the layers of delta conditions grow.
For any delta condition, if you make a change to a tank in the Tankage and Cargo Entry screen,
the weight field for that tank will appear in bold type. This is to indicate that it is a value that
deviates from the parent (or base) condition. If you make a change that you wish to undo, it is
important that you follow the steps above in order to re-link the delta condition’s value with that of
the base condition. If this is not carried out, then future changes to the base condition will not be
reflected in the delta condition.
While it is still not enough to float the vessel free, pumping oil from CO 4P instead of CO 1S proves to be
the more effective course of action.
At this point, contact is made with the owners to find out more details if possible about the actual damage
sustained. They have had a diver in the water and have the following to report.
Low Tide
In the process of defining the “boundaries” of the situation at hand, it is important to look at the low tide
mark, as it will typically be associated with the worst conditions during the salvage operation. Shear
forces and bending moments are likely to peak at low tide, as will the oil outflow.
• The Edit Time/Tide dialogue appears. Fill the table: Time Description “LT”, Day “1”, Time “0300”,
Tide Change “ -0.85”. Note the value for Tide is updated from 0.000 to -0.85.
• Click OK.
• Note that the total oil outflow is broken into two components, Hydrostatic Loss and Exchange
Loss. The Hydrostatic Loss is defined as the oil which outflows immediately as the pressure head
differential between the oil in the tank and the external waterline reaches equilibrium. In this
exercise, this hydrostatic loss accounts for most of the oil outflow. The Exchange Loss does not
happen immediately. Any oil that is in a volume of the tank that is lower than the damage opening
is assumed to “leak out” over time.
• The results can be graphically reviewed by selecting the Section Viewer (using either the tool bar
button, , or selecting the Results | Section Cut View menu item), and cutting a section close to
the transverse bulkhead between the machinery space and the No.4 CO tanks by clicking in the
profile/plan view.
• Note, as mentioned before, the wedge of oil that has leaked out of CO 4C is due to exchange
loss.
With LT as the active condition, create a delta condition and rename it “XFR”
for Transfer condition.
Simulate the transfer of oil that might be affected by the time the low tide
occurs.
• Similar to steps above we are going to transfer the following oil. But in this case we make use of
another transfer tool which is designed to deal with multiple transfers.
• Open the Tankage and Cargo Entry. Select the Damaged tab and right click anywhere on the CO
4C tank. Pick Other Tools | Tank Transfer Multiple Steps.
• The Weight Transfer Wizard pops up. We like to do the following transfers (your numbers may be
a bit different but it is important to know how to shift tank cargo between different compartments)
Within the Available Sources click on CO 4P and within the Available Destinations on CO 1P.
Before hitting the Add Transfer button type “160” in the field below.
• Repeat the previous procedure for the three remaining transfers. 160 MT from CO 4P to CO 1P
(CO 1P is now full), 46 MT from CO 4P to CO 1S (CO 4P is now empty), 114 MT from CO 3C to
CO 1S (CO 1S is now full), 10 MT from CO 3C to CO 2P (CO 2P is now full)
Applying transfers
• By the time low tide occurs the pump will have been running for 13 hours allowing a total of a little
over 715m3 (500 MT) of oil to be shifted around. Without resorting to transferring oil into ballast or
void spaces, the transfer plan above involves only 330 MT, which would easily be accomplished
in that time.
As time passes, the oil transfer continues and completes, and low tide arrives at 0300 in the morning on
the following day.
Telecon – Owner XBarge
22 June at 0300 CST
They have completed the transfer plan as instructed and have taken another draft reading as follows:
Fwd Marks: 4.5m
Aft Marks: 1.65m
Heel is 1.5 deg to port
The next high tide will occur at 1100 CST, and will be at a level that is 1.8m above the current low tide mark. As a back up, they
have requested the equipment needed to pressurize a damaged compartment - if necessary. This pressurizing equipment is
capable of generating a maximum pressure of 0.15 bar.
While the observed drafts are fairly close to the calculated values, they are slightly off which indicates that
the ground reaction, as calculated initially in the AGRD1 condition, most likely does not quite reflect the
current condition.
Adjust the tide height to reflect the low water mark described by the owners.
• With LT from drafts as the active condition, right click on it and select Add a Delta Condition &
Change Tide.
• Enter the Edit Time/Tide Entry. Fill the table: Time Description “2nd HT”, Day “1”, Time “1100”,
Tide Change “1.8”. Make sure Change Water Depths by Tide is selected.
• Note the Tide field is auto updated to 0.95 m. Click OK.
• Rename the condition to “2nd HT”.
While the ground reaction is greatly reduced, the barge will still be stranded at the second high tide.
However, with eight hours to spare, the owners will be able to bring the pressurizing equipment into effect
in order to force the flooded water out of the machinery space.
With 2nd HT as the active condition, create a delta condition and rename it
“Press”.
With Press as the active condition, simulate the pressurization of the damaged
machinery space.
• Open the Damage Entry window and activate the Detailed Damage Entry tab.
• For Machy Space, enter a value of “0.15” bar into the column labeled Pressure, and hit Enter,
then hit OK.
At this point, you have solved the problem of floating the barge free.
Summary
In this example, the solution was quite simple and could have been achieved in a number of different
ways. However a complete analysis was performed and captured by a series of conditions. By using delta
conditions to capture various stages of the analysis, it is now possible to retrace the steps taken, review
intermediate results, and recreate the line of reasoning.
11mm PLATE 6m
12.5mm
4.5m PL BILGE
12.5mm
PLATE BOTTOM
9m
Project Properties
• For example, you could start by simply laying down a keel plate. In this case, you would select a
Horizontal Plate from the Type drop down list. You would then give it a thickness (tw/tp), a
breadth of the plate (hw/bp) and a location of the plate’s origin (X Loc and Y Loc). Note that not
all of the columns are necessary to define a horizontal plate (for example, tf refers to the
thickness of the flange element in a Tee or Angle section which of course is not applicable to a
horizontal plate.)
• However, before you start defining the various elements in this manner, you will take advantage
of a tool that allows you to automatically generate the outer shell plating based on the hull
definition.
• Make sure that Create New Section is selected, and click on the Generate button.
• You will now see that in addition to the original Section Editor table (which now has four plate
elements in it) you also see a Section View window, and an individual element viewing window
which displays information related to the “active” or selected element.
• Note in the Section View window that only the starboard side of the plating has been defined
(also note that both the vertical and horizontal neutral axes have been drawn based on the
structure defined so far). There is a facility for mirroring elements to the port side once all of the
starboard side has been more fully defined. This will be explained towards the end of this section.
If your main window does not appear to be the same as the above, try selecting Window | Layout
– 1 from the main menu.
Before you continue on to define individual structural elements, a brief discussion of how the elements
are located and oriented is given here. As always, refer to the user manual for more details.The following
is an excerpt from the manual that introduces the concept of a Local Reference Point.
A key feature of this program, and one which greatly enhances its utility, is the use of a local reference
point (LRP) for each element. Commonly, the complete section properties of a section are built up by
summing the areas and moments of area for each contributing part. This requires knowing the center of
area for each part. For many parts, such as a 6 x 4 x 1/2 inch Tee attached to the shell plating oriented at
30 degrees from vertical, this is awkward to calculate. What is often known more precisely however is the
location of the attachment point of the Tee to the shell, e.g. the centerline at the base of the web.
In the Section Modulus Editor, each element type has a set of local reference points (LRPs), from 0 up to
8 in some cases, representing the potential attachment points for that section. In data entry one can
specify whichever point is most convenient for the user to determine. By default, the center of area LRP =
0, is assumed, and in general, LRP = 1 is chosen to be the most likely attachment point for the specific
element type.
The figure below represents an example of the local reference point for a Tee section.
This element (which was given the name “Hull-1”) is a horizontal plate and the local reference point is
designated as “2” (see the column heading Ref. Point). The LRP’s for a plate are defined in the figure
below.
90o
Molded BL (0,0)
Bottom Plate
Before you start adding individual longitudinal stiffeners to the section, note that while the outer plating
was very efficiently generated using the hull shape that you had already defined, there was no way to
similarly generate the internal plating. In this case, there is a longitudinal bulkhead at 4.5m from
centerline. You will start by adding this simple plate to the section.
Note the defined coordinate system. Section Modulus Editor is a two-dimensional table based
tool, which uses a standard cartesian coordinate system, based in the intersection of center- and
baseline, with positive direction to the top and right.
Type: “V”
Name: “Long Bkhd”
Description: “Bkhd Plate”
• When you have finished the definition, you should have the following. Note that as you add
structure to the section, the element and section properties are recalculated and displayed.
Hull Plating
Now you are ready to add some of the longitudinal stiffeners to the outer shell. You will start with the Tee
section attached to the keel plate.
While all structural elements in your section could be defined in the Section Editor window, the
program provides you with a custom editing window for each element type (plates, angles, bulbs,
etc). As you will see in this step, it is easier to use these custom element windows because the
columns are set up specifically for each element type. This is especially true with more
complicated element types.
• Select Edit | Tees from the main menu. The Tees Editor will appear and you will see that the
columns available for input are specific to defining a Tee section.
Name “BT-1”
Description “Bottom Tee”
Web-T 18.75 mm
Web-H 600 mm
Flange-T 25.0 mm
Flange-B 225.0 mm
Angle 0 deg
X Loc, Y Loc 0.0 cm, 0.0 cm
Ref. Point 1
Material (Leave as “Mild Steel” for
now)
• When you are finished you can close the Tees Editor window. The first line in the Tees Editor
window should be as shown below. Notice that your newly created BT-1 element has been added
to the list of elements in the main Section Editor table, along with the dimensions that you defined
and corresponding calculated properties. The Section Editor table shows all elements regardless
of type, and again, you could have simply entered this data directly, rather than opening the
specific Tees Editor window.
Tees Editor
• You can also see the new Tee element in the Section View (along with all other elements defined
so far) and the individual element or Part View as shown below. Note, the tee element will not be
this size on the actual screen because it is so small relative to everything else. You will need to
zoom in to see the following picture displayed below.
• Note also the reference point (“1”) and angle (“0”) that were used. The default local reference
point for a Tee section (i.e. the most likely point of attachment to the plating) is set at 1, which as
discussed before represents the local centerline and base of the tee section. For the Tee section
just created, this is the ideal reference point, as you can simply place the Tee at the global origin
of the section (i.e. at 0,0, the baseline and centerline of the section), and the Tee section will line
up perfectly with the centerline and will be attached to the inside face of the bottom plating.
• Referring again to the schematic definition of a Tee section, you can see that an angle of 0o will
result in the Tee being aligned standing straight “up”.
You will now continue with adding the next Tee section which is attached to the bottom plate at 1.5m from
centerline.
Name “BT-2”
Description “Bottom Tee”
Web-T 18.75 mm
Web-H 300 mm
Flange-T 25.0 mm
Flange-B 225.0 mm
Angle 0 deg
X Loc, Y Loc 150cm, 0.0 cm
• You should now see your second Tee section attached to the bottom plating.
In the Section View, you can “zoom in” on any particular element or groups of elements. Using
the “Zoom Window” tool button , click and drag to describe a small rectangle around the two
Tee sections.
• Click the “Zoom All” tool button, to return to the overall view of the section.
As with most ships, the sample barge has numerous structural elements that have identical dimensions.
The Section Modulus Editor has a number of tools to efficiently generate copies of elements where only
the location has to be redefined. You will take advantage of one of these tools in the definition of the third
Tee section along the bottom plating at 3.0 m from centerline, which has identical dimensions to the
element BT-2 that you have already defined.
You will now turn your attention to the Angle stiffeners attached to the longitudinal bulkhead plating. Note
that these are nine identical stiffeners spaced evenly along the height of the bulkhead plating at 0.6m
apart.
• You should see the new angle attached appropriately. Note in particular the X Loc of 450.55cm.
The additional 0.55cm was necessary to account for the thickness (or half-thickness) of the
longitudinal bulkhead plating. An X Loc of 450cm would have set the attachment point in the
middle of the plating rather than on the face of the plating as required. See the figures on the left
hand side.
• In the Section Editor window, right-click on the newly created LBA element and select Add Part |
Create Multiple.
• You will be presented with a Multiple Part Generator window in which you can specify the number
of identical parts you want to create, the spacing, and the length (in a straight line) over which
these parts are to be spread. Fill in the window: With spacing selected “0.6”, From “(4.506, 0.6)”,
To “(4.506, 6.0)”.
• Click Generate
• Based on the original “prototype” angle you have now generated all nine angles at appropriately
spaced intervals along the longitudinal bulkhead.
Generated Angles
• You will now take advantage of another powerful tool to create the angles that are attached to the
side shell, but are essentially the same dimensions as the longitudinal bulkhead angles you just
You can select multiple elements either by clicking on the first row with the left mouse button and
dragging down to select a range, or you can hold down the Ctrl key on your keyboard and
individually click on each element that you want with the left mouse button, or you can hold down
the Shift key on your keyboard to select a series of items.
• With those nine angles selected, use the right mouse button to click on one of the selected rows
and select Duplicate Part(s):
• You will see that all nine angles are reproduced and given a name with a “(c)” appended to it.
• Change the Description column for all nine of the newly duplicated angles from “Long Bhd Angle”
to “Side Shell Angle”. You can do all nine at once simply by selecting the range in the Description
column (by clicking and dragging the mouse) and typing “Side Shell Angle” once.
• Similarly (although you have to do them one at a time) change the Name column to reflect that
these angles are attached to the Side Shell. For example, change LBA – 1 (c) to “SSA – 1”.
• With all nine side shell angles still selected, right-click in the Section Editor and select Attach –
Right.
• You will see that the set of nine duplicate angles are now attached to the face of the plating to the
right of the longitudinal bulkhead (in this case, the side shell plating is to the right of the
longitudinal bulkhead). The Attach – Right feature has logically placed the stiffeners at right
angles to the side shell plating and has additionally oriented the angle so the flange extends
downward.
• This is exactly the way it should be, except for the bottom-most stiffener, SSA - 1 (see red arrow).
Since this element was attached at the junction between two plates (i.e. the side shell and the
radius plating), the program was unable to determine how to orient the stiffener. You can fix this
in the next step.
Note that the sign of the angle is important in order to know which way the flange is facing. An
angle of 270 deg would orient the Web of the stiffener in the same direction as an angle of –90
deg, but the flange would be facing upward instead of downward.
• For your reference the remaining elements that were added to complete the section are specified
below.
You are now in a position to check all of the work you have done so far. By selecting View | Section
Properties from the main menu, you will see a comprehensive report detailing the section properties as
calculated from the section that you have defined. Check your answers against the following table.
Section Properties
Note that columns are included for “Corroded” and “Damaged” sections. Later in the tutorial, you will
define some damage for the structure which will lead to a recalculation of the section properties. In the
meantime, since you have not defined any damaged or corroded regions, the section properties should
be identical in all three columns.
If your results are significantly different from above there are a few things you can check:
• Make sure you are neither missing any elements nor, have any extras defined in your section. In
looking at the Section Editor table, you should have exactly 42 elements (including shell plating).
• Make sure that you have changed the material properties of ALL elements from “mild steel” to
“AH-32 steel”.
Note that this “mirroring” action can be undone. Every mirrored part has the same name as the
original with an “(m)” appended to it. If, for example, you needed to make significant adjustments
to the section, you could simply take the following steps: Select Tools | Delete Mirrored Part(s)
from the main menu, make your changes to just the starboard side, and Mirror your half-section
again when the changes are complete.
Summary
You have now completed the definition of the sample barge midship section. While this is a very simple
section, the main features of the program have been covered, and the tools and techniques could be
applied to any structural section.
Some of the more advanced features that were not covered, but nevertheless you should be aware of
are:
• The use of standard stiffener libraries
• Generating a “simplified section” using known section properties and “effective” plate breadths.
Refer to the user manual for more details.
Aft Perpendicular
AP
Curves of Immersed cross sectional area plotted against the vessel’s draft
Bonjean Curves
Term applied to vertical partition walls subdividing the interior of a vessel into compartments
Bulkhead
Block Coefficient
Cb
All inclusive mass or weight of vessel measured in tones and equal to the mass of water displaced
Displacement
Table of which transverse frames are located, indicated on the baseline, numbered from zero at
Frame Table the aft perpendicular and terminating at or beyond the forward perpendicular.
The window or control on a window that has the program focus. This is often indicated by a
highlight or dotted outline on a button. Context menus apply specifically to the item that has the
Focus focus.
Forward Perpendicular
FP
The surface of a liquid in a tank is considered free if the tank is not completely full or empty. If the
vessel has trim or heel a tank with a free surface will experience a shift in its contents center of
Free Surface gravity. This effect is important in assessing stability.
Calculate loading condition from geometric data. Hull properties calculated from the hull offsets.
Intact Direct Tank centers and free surface calculated from offsets if available.
Calculate ship loading condition characteristics from hydrostatic and other tables. Tank centers
Intact and free surface calculated from entered tank loads or tank tables if available.
The vessel condition without any form of deadweight aboard (including fuel and ballast)
Lightship
Length Overall.
LOA
Term covering main engines, auxiliary engine room machinery in addition to other installed plant
Machinery
Amidships
MS
Dimensional co-ordinates of a hull form,(referenced to the moulded baseline) usually presented in
Offsets tabular format
Pertaining to the left- hand side of a vessel in the Profile view of the vessel
Port (Side)
Centerline fin form continuation of the lower afterbody integrated into the hull primarily for
Skeg directional stability and for support in dry drock.
Pertaining to the right hand side of a vessel in the Profile view of the vessel
Starboard (Side)
The longitudinal attitude of a vessel, the difference between forward and aft drafts
Trim
Strength Stations
FRAME LOCATION
No. (m-AP)
F05 3.00 F
F20 12.00 F
F38 22.80 F
F56 33.60 F
F74 44.40 F
F90 54.00 F
1.5m
3m
6m
2.55
0.3m
12m 6m
42m
60m
6m 6m 6m 6m 6m 6m 6m 6m 3m 3m 3m 3m
18m
1.2m
0.6m 10.2m
6, 9 6, 0 6, 9
5.7, 9
4.5, 7.8
4.5, 0
3.6, 9
3.174, 8.826 3.15, 9
3, 8.4 3, 0
2.25, 8.1
2.1, 9
2.25, 0
1.674, 8.826
1.5, 8.4 1.5, 0
0.6, 9 0.6, 9
0.174, 8.826 0.174, 8.826
0, 8.4 0, 0 0, 8.4
Skeg Offsets
Skeg offsets
2.4
9.0
3.0 1.5 7.5 10.8 10.8 10.8 9.6 6.0
4.5
9.0
5.4
1.5
4.5
11mm PLATE 6m
12.5mm
4.5m PL BILGE
12.5mm
PLATE BOTTOM
9m
Barge Tutorial • 95