Delivering Value Creation
Delivering Value Creation
the promise of
value creation
2022 Market Insights Survey
KPMG International
home.kpmg
Foreword
Private equity activity and deal valuations are at Even when the threshold was lowered to hitting full
Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
historically high levels. In 2021, it is estimated that almost potential 75 percent or more of the time, still only about in value creation
8,000 private equity deals were completed globally worth one-third of firms were able to meet that benchmark. The
$800bn. Deal values were particularly strong in North reasons provided included delaying the value creation
America ($352bn) and Europe ($172bn)1. The returns for process, relying too heavily on traditional value creation To justify paying the increased The value of
private equity investors have also been impressive and levers, and failing to fully realize the advantages of multiples, private equity firms value creation
have drawn even more investment into the sector. digital transformations.
are under more pressure to
With higher deal volumes and higher valuations, When the data was examined, it also became clear that significantly enhance operational Evolution of value
however, comes higher expectations. To justify paying value creation is more important than ever. The value
the increased multiples, private equity (PE) firms are creation process is now happening earlier, crossing more value to achieve the desired creation levers
under more pressure to significantly enhance operational disciplines, and integrating more data. returns.
value to achieve the desired returns. This has led to
a sharper focus on value creation planning, requiring Now is the perfect time to challenge deal and operating Tech and digital
rise to prominence
a more comprehensive approach to enterprise-wide partners on preconceived notions of where value This has led to a sharper focus on
creation sits in the deal lifecycle. As one partner at a PE
transformation by leveraging an ever-increasing set of
firm said, “Generally, when we come second in a deal
value creation planning, requiring
value levers and a more disciplined and transparent
approach to execution. process, it’s because the fund who comes first has a a more comprehensive approach The growing
influence of ESG
more mature and well thought through value creation to enterprise-wide transformation
To better understand this evolving shift, KPMG plan, increasing their conviction in the asset and flexibility
researched the changing nature of the levers that are on valuation.” The findings show that over 70 percent of by leveraging an ever-increasing
Advanced analytics
driving value creation and the impact this is having on PE firms with US$1+ billion assets under management set of value levers and a more drive engagement
deal processes. In collaboration with Coalition Greenwich, (AUM) recognize that value creation planning is a key and insight
120 PE firms and portfolio companies headquartered differentiator in the bidding process.
disciplined and transparent
in the UK and US were interviewed during September approach to execution.
and October 2021. We asked a series of quantitative Traditional levers like buy and build and people and talent A new era of active
and qualitative questions to explore thoughts around remain central to many value creation strategies with Naveen Sharma, UK Head of Private Equity management
newer levers such as technological and digital KPMG in the UK
value creation. It was found that only around 1 in 10
PE firms feel they have reached the full potential2 on transformation; data and analytics; and environmental,
their investments 90 percent or more of the time. social, and governance gaining ground. Lessons for
the future
1
Prequin - 2022 Global Private Equity Report. Methodology and
2
‘Full potential’ - Reaching or exceeding the maximum target enterprise performance and valuation set for the business at the time of initial investment or purchase. acknowledgements
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation
Foreword hen reflecting on the majority of investments made by your firm, on average, how often do you
W
Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
There was a clear trend for more active engagement, in value creation
believe they achieve their full potential?
with three-quarters of firms saying they are ‘active’
or ‘very active’ in their investments. PE firms are also Just over one in 10 PE firms reach full potential 90 percent or more of the time.
recognizing the value that sector or asset-specific value The value of
creation professionals can bring, with many being value creation
brought in before or during due diligence the majority of
the time.
13% 12% 20%
40%
Evolution of value
The days of thinking about value creation only after creation levers
the transaction closes are long gone. Value creation 12% 17%
should be a key part of the strategy to build conviction
40%
and strengthen your position in a competitive process. 75%
Tech and digital
In today’s crowded market, the winners are engaging rise to prominence
in value creation planning and strategies much earlier, Over $100 Bn $11 - $100 Bn
digging deeper, and partnering closer with managers 27%
and advisors to help ensure that plans come to fruition
to help each investment reach its highest potential. 8% 12% 14% The growing
26% influence of ESG
We hope you enjoy this report, and we look forward to 44% 21%
discussing these topics and more with you during 2022. 38% 42% Advanced analytics
drive engagement
39% and insight
Naveen Sharma
Partner and UK Head of Private Equity
Total $1 - $10 Bn Under $1 Bn
KPMG in the UK A new era of active
$ AUM management
Rajesh Sennik
Partner, Value Creation practice lead
90%-100% 75%-90% 50%-75% Less than 50% Lessons for
KPMG in the UK the future
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation
Contents
01 02
Structural shift
05
The value of
07
Evolution of value
9
Tech and digital
Top six insights
from the survey in value creation value creation creation levers rise to prominence
13
The growing
16 18
A new era of active
22
Lessons for the future
24
Methodology and
Advanced analytics drive
influence of ESG engagement and insight management acknowledgements
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved.
Top six insights from the survey
The research revealed the following six key insights:
Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
in value creation
1. Few PE firms are achieving the ‘full potential’
of their investments
3
2. Value creation planning is starting earlier,
going deeper, and having a greater impact on
3. Advanced analytics and sophisticated
value creation planning are driving more
decision-making competitive deal processes for attractive
— Only around 10 percent of PE firms feel assets The value of
they have reached full potential 90 percent or — Fifty percent of PE firms with more than value creation
more of the time on their investments US$10 billion of assets under management — Eighty percent of firms with AUM $10-100bn
(AUM) now activate their value creation plans believe that proper planning enables them to
— Reasons included delaying the value creation earlier in the deal process than three years ago increase their competitiveness in auctions
process, relying too heavily on traditional Evolution of value
creation levers
value creation levers, and failing to fully — More than 80 percent of these firms — Almost half of portfolio company execs
realize the opportunity and speed of business engage actively in value creation planning at or feel that the price paid for their business
model shift as the economy becomes ever before making the investment decisions, with was underpinned by specific value creation
more digital three-fifths of the largest firms developing assumptions Tech and digital
their plans even earlier, right at the very start rise to prominence
of deal evaluation
4. 5. 6.
Somewhat surprisingly, ‘buy & build’ and ESG is growing in importance for deal PE firms are bringing in external advisors The growing
influence of ESG
‘people & talent’ remain the top value consideration, but is not yet an established earlier to help achieve full value on their
creation levers, but ‘tech investment/ digital lever for value creation investments
transformation’ are rising rapidly as preferred
strategies — ESG factors are increasingly considered — External advisors are engaged before or Advanced analytics
pre-deal, whereas previously, they were a during initial due diligence more than 60 drive engagement
and insight
— Buy and build and people and talent post-deal consideration percent of the time
retrospectively and prospectively are the
two top value creation levers used by PE — Over 90 percent of firms with AUM over — When choosing outside consultants to help
funds across all fund sizes US$10 billion have declined an investment lead value creation planning, US firms favor A new era of active
due to ESG criteria deep sector expertise, while UK firms put management
— Technology and digital transformation are greater emphasis on track record
rapidly gaining ground and are expected — However, ESG is not yet considered one of
to be the third most important lever going the top five levers for value creation
Lessons for
forward, with significant focus on customer- the future
facing digital transformation, data analytics,
and cyber security
Methodology and
acknowledgements
3
“Full potential” - Reaching or exceeding the maximum target enterprise performance and valuation (e.g., stretch case) set for the business at the time of initial investment or purchase.
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 1
Structural shift in value creation Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
Value creation planning is experiencing a dramatic shift. Rather Has the timing of when you have activated value creation planning on your investments in value creation
than creating and implementing a value creation plan after a
changed during the past three years?
deal closes, 50 percent of PE firms of AUM of US$10 billion or
greater are now initiating value creation planning earlier in the PE investors see timing of value creation shifting to earlier in deal cycle.
The value of
deal lifecycle than they did three years ago. value creation
Lessons for
the future
6%
2% 2%
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 2
The intensity of the planning is also much higher in the earlier Value creation planning in the deal lifecycle
stages. Value creation planning is actively pursued at or before
due diligence by 65 percent of all firms, and by 88 percent of All sized firms recognize the importance of starting 3% Top six insights
from the survey
the largest firms with an AUM of US$100+ billion. planning for value creation early in the deal lifecycle; 6%
larger firms have the most significant focus on value 6%
The message is clear: Value creation planning needs to be creation at the earliest point.
undertaken before the deal is completed, when there is 35% Structural shift
more room for maneuver. It is vital to secure access to an in value creation
existing repository of value levers, data sources, and analytical 19%
Total
techniques early in the process, so the value creation strategy
can be fully integrated into the investment plan. If value The value of
creation planning is left until post-completion, there is a much 63% value creation
higher risk that either the opportunity itself will be missed,
or, at the very least, it will be more challenging to realize its 30%
full potential. Evolution of value
creation levers
42%
38%
Tech and digital
rise to prominence
30% 30% 29%
25%
The growing
20% 19% 19% 20% influence of ESG
13% 13%
10% 10% Advanced analytics
6% 7% drive engagement
4% and insight
2%
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 3
Another key factor in the value creation planning process is Approaching cost and revenue in a balanced manner
the approach taken. Today, the largest firms overwhelmingly
take a balanced approach to costs and revenues when In terms of value creation, nearly half of all firms take a balanced view on revenues and costs. Top six insights
from the survey
developing their value creation plans. For the others, it is a
These results mirror KPMG’s internal research, which shows that those investments with a balanced approach
more even split between a balanced approach and a focus on
to value creation achieve 15 percent EBITDA growth, versus only 5 percent growth for those that consider costs
revenues, with only a minority focused on costs.
alone. With the right application, a balanced approach can help to distill potentially dozens of value creation levers
Structural shift
down to those few that can create the most value in the particular investment being analyzed. in value creation
Total 47%
44%
Tech and digital
rise to prominence
The growing
influence of ESG
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 4
The value of value creation Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
Value creation planning is becoming an increasingly important part The use of value creation planning in the bidding process over the past three years in value creation
of the bidding process itself. In the last three years, PE firms of all
sizes have seen a rise in the use of value creation planning in the Value creation planning has increased substantially across regions and AUM asset classes, in particular
bidding process. Firms with AUM greater than US$10 billion have across larger firms.
The value of
increased their use of value creation planning by 80 percent, while value creation
for firms with AUM between US$1 and US$10 billion, the increase
is almost 70 percent. Total 23% 40% 36% 1%
Evolution of value
creation levers
Over $100 Bn 25% 75%
$ AUM
rise to prominence
Partner, PE firm, US$1 - US$10 billion AUM Under $1 Bn 18% 31% 51%
Advanced analytics
drive engagement
and insight
Why are firms starting sooner and moving faster? Because it United States 27% 32% 39% 2%
helps improve their chances of winning. The research shows that A new era of active
value creation planning improves competitiveness or pricing in management
United Kingdom 18% 47% 35%
the bid process more than 50 percent of the time. With so much
‘dry powder’ in search of the next big deal, company founders
are not only looking for investment, but also for strategies and Lessons for
focused execution capability that should come from having “the Increased substantially No change the future
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 5
Value creation planning increasing competitiveness in bid process
Value creation planning has a big impact on the bid process, enabling higher bids. Top six insights
As deals have become more competitive, having a from the survey
With improved bid pricing, firms can win more deals. The pressure is then on the winning
robust value creation process that is underwritten bidder to execute their value creation plan to drive performance. To achieve that, the value
into the deal allows us to pay more for deals creation levers should be properly identified, quantified, and actioned at the appropriate
Structural shift
time.
where we have a high conviction of our ability to in value creation
drive value. Of particular note, over 80 percent of PE firms with US$11+ billion AUM recognize
that value creation planning is a key differentiator in the bidding process. When combined
The value of
Partner, PE firm, US$1 - US$10 billion AUM with quantitative analytics, this enables firms to achieve more effective positioning value creation
in auction processes, which in turn helps to secure the most desirable investment
opportunities.
To what extent does value creation planning enable higher bids and help rank better in a Evolution of value
creation levers
competitive auction process for PE firms with US$11+ billion AUM?
Advanced analytics
drive engagement
Total and insight
80% Often/Always
Lessons for
Rarely/Never the future
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 6
Evolution of value creation levers
Value creation has always been about driving greater deal multiples or EBITDA, ideally both. While value creation ideas have become an increasingly important part of the bidding
Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
in value creation
process, the top levers of value creation have changed little. Both retrospectively4 and prospectively5, the research shows the two primary levers for creating value are (1) buy and
build and (2) people and talent investment. Notably, technology investment and digital transformation are rapidly gaining ground. The survey found that these two levers are expected
to double in importance over the next three years.
The value of
value creation
Most common value creation levers to date Most common value creation levers in the future
Buy and build and talent investment are the top two to date value creation levers over Tech investment and digital transformation doubles in importance over next Evolution of value
the past three years. three years. creation levers
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 7
For the time being, buy and build is the top value creation lever by a
significant margin and is expected to remain so. Talent management Successful value creation strategies are Top six insights
is also likely to remain a priority focus in the long term, as even in now combining technology and digital from the survey
the most high-tech industries, human capital often plays a critical
role in differentiating a business. Furthermore, in an environment
transformation with data insight. These
where the first 12 months under new ownership are often key to strategies build a scalable platform for Structural shift
an asset delivering on its overall three-year plan, having the right organic growth, and merger and in value creation
team in place from day one (or day one hundred), puts the portfolio
company in a stronger position to achieve its new objectives. acquisition integration; they drive better
experiences for customers; and they can The value of
Will reliance on these traditional levers continue to be value creation
sufficient going forward? The availability of additional sources help reduce duplication, inefficiency, and
of data allows firms to identify many more potential levers. By cost. This potent blend of tech, digital, and
combining industry insight and experienced advisors, firms can
identify the levers with the most potential for each particular
data is having a large and compounding Evolution of value
creation levers
opportunity, enabling them to achieve both EBITDA improvement impact on EBITDA.
and higher multiples. PE firms should therefore stay abreast of the
changing strategies which continue to develop, in particular around Phil Murden, Partner, KPMG in the UK
Tech and digital
technology investment, digital transformation, and ESG factors. rise to prominence
The growing
influence of ESG
Which levers are most important to you?
Advanced analytics
drive engagement
and insight
Methodology and
acknowledgements
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 8
Tech and digital rise to prominence
As noted previously, there is a growing focus on tech-driven levers to build conviction in the value creation plan, drive business transformation, and create additional value. Although
Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
in value creation
technology investment/digital transformation was only ranked as the sixth most common value creation lever over the past three years, survey respondents expect it to become
a solid top-three lever in the future, a change that was also reflected in many of the comments from respondents.
The value of
Important considerations for technology investments by portfolio companies value creation
Digital transformation and data analytics are the top choices for technology investments.
ESG and digital transformation are critical Invest substantially more Invest moderately more Maintain current investment Invest slightly less
value creation levers that have been growing in
Invest substantially less We do not invest in this area and have no plans to Methodology and
importance through time. acknowledgements
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 9
Firms are investing in these areas to refresh their business models and enhance the existing value propositions
of their investments. Looking forward, this increasingly intense focus on digital transformation is strongly
aligned with the use of data analytics. With 77 percent of firms planning to invest more in customer-facing Top six insights
from the survey
digital transformation and 75 percent in data analytics (not to mention 71 percent on cyber security), it is clear
that technology and data are likely to play an increasing role in the investment process in future. Those firms
Technology is the golden thread that choose another path risk getting left behind.
that runs through the lifecycle of Structural shift
To this end, PE firms are taking a longer-term view towards the technology investments they make in their in value creation
an investment. portfolio companies and their anticipated ROI. In fact, 70 percent of firms have a long- or medium-term view of
their technology investments in their portfolio companies, with that figure rising towards 90 percent for higher
Luke Anderson, Partner, KPMG in the UK
AUM firms. The value of
value creation
Methodology and
acknowledgements
Source: 2022 Market Insights Survey
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 10
When considering risk mitigation and value preservation, PE firms overwhelmingly anticipate spending more heavily on
cyber security, with nearly 75 percent looking to increase their cyber security investment. With reports showing ever
increasing cyber attacks, particularly on businesses between deal announcement and deal close, firms should consider Top six insights
A major and public cyber- or this issue as part of their deal modelling. from the survey
data-related incident could Similarly, it is no surprise to see investment in operational resilience is also a priority for almost half of those
be the fastest route to value surveyed, particularly given the supply chain disruption and uncertainty of recent years. Structural shift
destruction for any business. It in value creation
is critical that both a business Approach to risk mitigation and value preservation
and its investors understand For risk mitigation and value preservation, investments in cyber security and operational resiliency top the rankings. The value of
value creation
its exposure to threats and
proportionately mitigates them.
Equally important is establishing Cyber security 26% 48% 19% 3% | 1% | 2% Evolution of value
creation levers
resilience and having effective
incident response and recovery Operational resilience 45% 44% 4% | 4% | 4%
Lessons for
the future
5 - Invest substantially more 4 - Invest moderately more 3 - Maintain current investment
2 - Invest slightly less 1 - Invest substantially less 0 - We do not invest in this area and have no plans to
Methodology and
acknowledgements
Source: 2022 Market Insights Survey
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 11
Value creation in action
KPMG firms have recently supported PE-backed clients to deliver value from instilling levers to support their strategic business goals.
Case study: Empowering procurement Case study: Creating value post-completion in a tech-enabled
B2B business Structural shift
in value creation
After being acquired by a blue-chip PE firm in London, the client – a tech-enabled B2B
provider of data, analytics, and research services to global financial institutions worldwide
– engaged the TMT value creation practice to develop an ambitious action plan to drive
double-digits revenue growth. The KPMG in the UK team spent 14 weeks working side The value of
value creation
by side with the management team and the operating partner of the fund to refresh the
customer strategy, build a leading digital product roadmap, and identify bolt-on merger
and acquisition and joint venture opportunities to help enhance customer churn, increase
pricing power, enter new market segments and expand its portfolio of digital tools Evolution of value
and capabilities. creation levers
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 12
The growing influence of ESG
With climate change and environmental and social disruption Evaluation of ESG factors in the deal lifecycle
Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
in value creation
never far from the headlines over the past few years, there
is growing awareness that firms cannot continue to act in Over two-thirds evaluate ESG factors as a part of a due
the ways they have in the past. There is almost universal diligence and investment decision, with larger firms taking
12%
recognition that all market participants, including PE firms, ESG into account earlier in the deal process and more The value of
need to embrace the spirit and the values embodied by fundamentally as part of the post-deal value creation plan. value creation
Structural shift
13% in value creation
24%
54% 46%
39%
87% 100% 76% The value of
61% value creation
Although ESG may not be cited directly as a top three lever in value creation planning, it has become an important part of the
investment decision-making process. Most firms are looking at ESG factors early in the deal process, and, if that review raises Tech and digital
sufficient concerns, investors are more than willing to walk away. In fact, over 90 percent of the largest firms in the survey rise to prominence
have declined an investment due to concerns over its ESG performance. Overall in the UK, almost 75 percent of PE firms have
stepped away from a deal, due to ESG factors, while almost half of PE firms in the US have taken the same action.
The growing
influence of ESG
When looking at the geographic split of where firms have declined three quarters of UK firms have done so, and just over half
of US firms have done so.
Advanced analytics
drive engagement
and insight
27%
73%
Lessons for
the future
United Kingdom United States
Methodology and
acknowledgements
Source: 2022 Market Insights Survey
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 14
Embedding ESG in the value creation plan As these figures show, PE firms of all sizes take ESG reviews seriously, with the bigger firms having the
most mature processes in place.
The expectation is that acknowledging and embedding ESG Top six insights
in a value creation plan will have a positive impact, during the from the survey
lifecycle of an investment and far beyond. Firms are using ESG Review
ESG criteria not just to assess risks and identify opportunities, Respondents were asked how sophisticated their processes were for assessing ESG factors in
but to manage their portfolio and ultimately aim to deliver investment decision making. Structural shift
improved and more sustainable returns at exit. in value creation
While it is expected for ESG to be an area of increased Over $100 billion: $1 - $100 billion:
importance going forward, it is interesting to note that it is not
75% 50%
The value of
anticipated to be a top five lever of value creation on its own value creation
over the next three years.
Evolution of value
very sophisticated very sophisticated creation levers
You can see a clear shift from $1 - $10 billion: Under $10 billion:
ESG’s prominence being seen as a Tech and digital
32% 11%
rise to prominence
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 15
Advanced analytics drive Top six insights
from the survey
The value of
value creation
Data is vital to help investors understand the intrinsic nature of the Percentage of PE funds who believe quantitative analytics influence the price/
business they are investing in, and to create effective value creation
bid on opportunities
strategies. But without appropriate analysis, the amount of data could Evolution of value
creation levers
be overwhelming. The analysis showed that over 80 percent of the time, quantitative analytics had an impact on the
price paid for an asset, rising to 100 percent for the largest transactions.
The importance of analyzing and actioning relevant data, therefore,
cannot be overstated. The research found that PE firms believe Tech and digital
quantitative analysis has influenced bid prices in over 80 percent of rise to prominence
opportunities. For the largest firms, this rises to between 90 and 100
percent of opportunities. Total 83%
The growing
Furthermore, clear and consistent data enables greater accountability and influence of ESG
transparency pre-and post-deal.
Under $1 Bn 82%
Managing Director, private equity firm, US$1 – US$10 billion AUM
Methodology and
acknowledgements
Source: 2022 Market Insights Survey
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 16
Advance analytics to calculate expected returns
A common desktop analysis tool is the top choice for calculating expected return from value creation technologies, but other advanced tools and techniques are gaining traction. Top six insights
from the survey
91%
Total
20% 20%
76% 13% 13% 13% Evolution of value
10% 10% 10% creation levers
7%
2%
A market-leading desktop analysis tool In a world that is growing more technologically sophisticated by the day, it may seem surprising that a common desktop
Advanced analytics
is often the default tool for quantitative analysis tools - first released on the PC in 1987 – is still a primary quantitative tool for data analysis in value creation planning. drive engagement
analysis for bid pricing. However, more and insight
With analytics automation platforms such as Alteryx, or with firms developing their own proprietary tools, advanced analytics
advanced tools and techniques are are expected to drive more decision making, both on the front end during planning, but also in response to dynamic changes
gaining traction, particularly among in the marketplace. In particular, firms are beginning to recognize the advantages of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine A new era of active
larger firms with deeper resources. learning, both as inputs when pricing an investment opportunity, and also after the deal is closed in an effort to help transform management
With advances in AI and machine the business through enhanced decision making, improved operational efficiencies and streamlined product design.
learning, combined with big data and
Managing the ever-growing volumes of data associated with every deal and asset is also driving further adoption of AI, machine
cloud-enabled services, this can forecast learning, and other analytical. Tools are continually being developed to help ingest, decipher, and interpret greater volumes of
Lessons for
the future
significant growth for these advanced data at ever-quicker speeds, helping to drive conviction in analysis and deliver stronger results.
methodologies over the next few years.
These tools are only as good as the people that wield them. Therefore, it is important the same care and diligence used to
develop the tools is also applied to attract and retain the personnel with the skills to use them effectively. Methodology and
acknowledgements
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 17
A new era of active management Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
PE firms are clearly actively engaged with their What is the approach taken by fund/operating team? in value creation
portfolio companies. Long gone are the days where
value creation and portfolio management largely meant Three-quarters of firms are actively engaged with their portfolio companies.
installing a new chairman and driving management So, what does it mean to be actively engaged? PE firms are looking for strategic alignment between investors and The value of
teams hard at board meetings. shareholders. Investors are also laser focused on talent: aiming to ensure management teams receive the proper support, value creation
The survey found that more than 76 percent of and, when needed, supplementing or changing those teams to deliver on the promises of the original investment thesis.
firms overall say they take an ‘active’ or ‘very active’
Evolution of value
approach with their investments. US firms are more creation levers
hands-on, with 56 percent ‘very active’, while UK firms
take a more balanced approach overall, with responses
split almost equally across ‘very active’, ‘active’ and 2% 1%
Over next three years we Tech and digital
‘balanced’. Results from portfolio companies were
similar, with nearly 62 percent of companies saying expect to see a continued rise to prominence
their investors actively engage post-deal, and only one building of a trusted
reporting no engagement post-investment.
21% advisor community - The growing
influence of ESG
individuals and consulting
43%
organizations - that can be
deployed at pace. Advanced analytics
drive engagement
We are extending our own and insight
Operations Advisor, private equity firm,
team’s capabilities beyond US$11-US$100 billion AUM
the ‘high finance’ skillset, A new era of active
management
and, therefore, get more 33%
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 18
Value creation execution, working with advisors to identify and drive value
When outside advisors are engaged, they tend to be brought in relatively early. Overall, more than 60 percent of PE firms bring in their external advisors before or during due
diligence. This reflects the fact that value creation planning has moved earlier in the deals process, meaning trusted advisors are needed earlier, too.
In terms of the most important skills required by external advisors, US firms show a clear preference for deep sector expertise. While sector expertise is important for UK firms, Top six insights
they also show a slight preference for previous case studies when seeking support. Using such experts can help firms to build confidence in their analysis and in their value creation from the survey
planning. Industry experts and advisors can play a vital role in providing the depth of knowledge to identify the most valuable levers and when they are best engaged.
6%
5%
Over $100 Bn $11 - $100 Bn $1 - $10 Bn Under $1 Bn Evolution of value
35% creation levers
At the very As soon as a During initial As a part of the Between signing As part of normal
beginning of prospect is due diligence investment decision and completion of operations of
Total deal evaluation solidified the deal the business
Tech and digital
rise to prominence
Important factors when considering an external advisor Source: 2022 Market Insights Survey
US shows preference for sector expertise, whilst UK firms may put higher importance on case studies.
The growing
influence of ESG
Total United States United Kingdom
Deep sector expertise 61% 36% 3% 71% 29% 53% 41% 6%
Advanced analytics
Availability of skilled and trusted resource 46% 48% 6% 50% 48% 2% 43% 49% 8% drive engagement
and insight
Case studies/credentials in dealing with a
40% 40% 17% 3% 28% 48% 23% 1% 50% 34% 12% 4%
particular issue/value creation lever
Working with the PE house / portfolio previously 20% 49% 19% 10% | 1% 32% 46% 12% 8% | 2% 12% 52% 25% 11%
A new era of active
Existing knowledge of the business 25% 34% 28% 12% 1% 32% 32% 20% 15% 1% 20% 35% 35% 10% management
Gaining validation / third Party reliance 41% 44% 8% | 6% | 1% 16% 46% 30% 5% | 3% 38% 54% 2% | 6%
Price competitiveness of advice 37% 46% 6% | 10% | % 28% 48% 8% | 13% | 3% 44% 44% 4% | 8% Lessons for
the future
5 – Most important 4 – Somewhat important 3 – Neutral 2 – Not important 1 – Not important at all
Methodology and
acknowledgements
Source: 2022 Market Insights Survey
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 19
Nine lessons for the future
In summary, it is believed that there are nine fundamental principles to follow, in order to deliver on the promise of value creation.
Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
in value creation
1. 2. 3.
The value of
value creation
Start early Go beyond the functional Focus on deal speed analytics
and unique data sources
Start as early as possible looking Operational and sector or
at the origination pipeline asset-specific knowledge is a Create a repository of value Evolution of value
creation levers and strive to
Taking too narrow a creation levers
through a value creation or key differentiator and should
business model-shift lens. Put be embedded in the cycle. ensure they are backed up with view in value creation
operating partners, sector sector Empirical and “lived” experience good data sources and analytic at the beginning is Tech and digital
specialists, and value creation combined with analysis and techniques. Use these early in limiting. Make sure you rise to prominence
the process so they form part of
advisors in the deal conversation modelling should give the best look at the full potential
or even “shadow portfolio” answers. your thesis from the get-go.
of all levers. The growing
conversations. influence of ESG
Operating Partner, private equity
firm, over US$100 billion AUM
4. 5. 6. Advanced analytics
drive engagement
and insight
Understand early where Data, data, data Adopt a balanced approach
tech and digital can drive
performance What does the business know The research indicates that A new era of active
now about its customers, investments which consider a management
Is the tech value creation play people, and processes? What balanced cost and growth focus
around the operating model and more could it capture and what achieve three-fold EBITDA growth
IT or is there also a fundamental value could the business derive compared to those that consider Lessons for
the future
shift in the business model and from better information on all a cost only approach.
market opportunity through the three elements?
move to digital?
Methodology and
acknowledgements
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 20
7.
Underpinning this can be an expectation for understand the risks and upside opportunities of a deal and understand where enterprise value can
transparent principles on governance and operations. be improved. Ahead of a divestment, KPMG firms can help you build a compelling plan for change,
backed by data. KPMG professionals provide you with wide-ranging delivery – from identifying The value of
where potential lies to implementing the programmes to help release it. value creation
8. Evolution of value
creation levers
Conflate the deal and operating partner roles
Consider how you can better combine the deal Tech and digital
partner function (origination, deal execution, etc) with rise to prominence
the operating partner remit around value creation and Val Value creation
u - co
sts
ec
portfolioco management.
re
The growing
ati o n -
Value Leavers influence of ESG
re
ve n o
c ti
n
ue ot e
9. Value pr Advanced analytics
drive engagement
and insight
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 21
Methodology and acknowledgements
KPMG in the UK, in collaboration with Coalition Greenwich, interviewed 120 PE firms and portfolio companies in the US and UK during September and October of 2021 to delve into
Top six insights
from the survey
Structural shift
in value creation
issues around value creation and value creation planning through a series of quantitative and qualitative questions. Quotes throughout this report that are not attributed to KPMG
professionals stemmed from those interviews.
The value of
value creation
Participant profile
Evolution of value
AUM Region Type of investment creation levers
The growing
influence of ESG
Large minority investor 11%
$11 - $100 Bn 11%
44% 56% Advanced analytics
drive engagement
Minority investor 6% and insight
$1 - $10 Bn 33%
A new era of active
Minority investor 4% management
Methodology and
acknowledgements
Source: 2022 Market Insights Survey
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Delivering on the promise of value creation 22
Contact for further information
Glenn Mincey Naveen Sharma Rajesh Sennik
Partner, Global & U.S. Head of Private Equity Partner, UK Head of Private Equity Partner, Value creation lead
KPMG International KPMG in the UK KPMG in the UK
T: +1 212 954-8255 T: +44 (0)7711 462729 T: +44 (0)7919 175050
E: gmincey@kpmg.com E: naveen.sharma@kpmg.co.uk E: rajesh.sennik@kpmg.co.uk
Nathan Beaver
Partner
KPMG in the UK
T: +44 (0)7554 114574
E: nathan.beaver@kpmg.co.uk
Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for KPMG audited entities and their affiliates or related entities.
home.kpmg
The information contained herein is of a general nature and is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavour to provide accurate and timely information, there can be no guarantee that
such information is accurate as of the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. No one should act on such information without appropriate professional advice after a thorough examination of the particular situation.
© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved.
KPMG refers to the global organization or to one or more of the member firms of KPMG International Limited (“KPMG International”), each of which is a separate legal entity. KPMG International Limited is a private English company limited
by guarantee and does not provide services to clients. For more detail about our structure please visit home.kpmg/governance.
The KPMG name and logo are trademarks used under license by the independent member firms of the KPMG global organization.