Construction: Representation in Various Media
Construction: Representation in Various Media
Construction This is the way a media text is put together. In a film or television
programme, this includes the editing and choice of camera angles; in a
magazine or newspaper, it includes the layout and writing as well as the
choice of images.
Mediation This is the process everything goes through before it reaches an audience.
This can be how a film script is written and re-written before it makes it to
production, how newspaper or magazine photographs are cropped and
captioned, or how real life events—like a protest or a speech by a
politician—are portrayed in a news report.
Selection This refers to what has been selected for inclusion in a media text. This can
be particularly important in newspaper articles, where selecting certain facts
over others can change the angle of a story; what is omitted is sometimes as
important as what is included.
Anchorage These are the words that go along with images to give those pictures a
certain meaning in a specific context. This includes captions and headlines in
newspapers and taglines in adverts or on film posters.
Stereotypes These are a simplified representations of a person, groups of people or a
place, through basic or obvious characteristics—which are often
exaggerated. Stereotypes can be used to describe characters quickly, relying
on existing audience recognition. They are dangerous as they can lead
audiences to generalize about people or places.
Ideology These are ideas and beliefs, held by media producers, which are often
represented in their media texts.
Camera shots and angles A low angle camera shot can make someone seem more powerful
and in control than they really are.
A high angle shot of the same person may make them seem less
important or influential.
Editing Media producers can manipulate the emotions of the audience by
representing certain characters or situations through editing. For a
documentary style reality show, like Don't Tell the Bride, many hours
of film footage may have been recorded, but this footage is edited
down to fill a one hour broadcast. How it is edited will determine
how the characters are represented and how the audience respond
to them.
Reality shows like 'Don't Tell the Bride' edit down many hours of footage to create a
one hour programme.
Visual Codes Iconography (the visual images or symbols that appear in a scene) can
influence representation. For example, iconography can have a big
impact on a representation of femininity – a character carrying a
briefcase and wearing a smart suit creates a very different
representation of femininity than a character carrying a changing bag
and pushing a buggy.
REPRESENTATION OF GENDER
The representation of gender is a powerful code in media texts.
Women Representations of women in the media have developed and changed with
time to reflect the cultural and sociological changes in society. However,
female stereotypes continue to appear in some media texts.
Men Representations of men have changed over the past two decades with the
emergence of the 'new man' or 'metrosexual', a man in touch with his
feminine side and interested in romance, fashion, health and fitness.
However, the main focus is still on the traditional idea of masculinity which is
strong, heroic, with the ability to outsmart life's problems and survive against
all odds.
The Big Bang Theory stars a group of scientists who are hyper-intelligent,
geeky and weedy. The show represents how Leonard, one of the weedy
scientists, manages to win the heart of Penny – despite him not being the
stereotypical tough, handsome guy who always gets the girl.
David Beckham combines tradi3onal and modern male values.
Today many men are faced with unrealistic and aspirational representations
of masculinity in the media.
The front cover of men's lifestyle magazines can offer an unrealistic representation of
masculinity
The front covers of men's lifestyle magazines often depict a 'perfect man'
with great hair and a six pack of abs. As a result, many men are now under a
similar pressure to women, trying to con form to an ideal image.
REPRESENTATION OF AGE
Representations of age can influence how audiences respond to a character or real-life person in a
media text.
Young people When media texts represent people, they can be categorized according to
age, however it is easy to fall into stereotypical caricatures of lazy teenagers
or grumpy old people. Today it can be difficult to pigeon-hole people into
age groups, as the boundaries are becoming more blurred – for example,
video games are just as likely to be played by middle-aged adults as
teenagers.
Young people are often represented negatively in media texts, which can
cause controversy and stimulate debate. During the London riots, British
young people were portrayed by the print media as dangerous and hostile.
This representation was based on the actions of a small number of people
and created an unfair stereotype.
The main media texts which offer positive representation of young people
are usually situations which allow them to represent themselves, within a
specific context. For instance, auditions on talent shows such as Britain's Got
Talent and The X Factor or celebrations of their good deeds on charity
programmes like Children in Need.
Ethnicity defined by culture, national customs, language or beliefs. Race can mean
physical characteristics that may be related to skin colour or other
physiological features. The media’s representation of ethnicity can prove very
powerful as it could be the only experience of other cultures that some
audiences will encounter.
If all representation of ethnicity in the media were balanced this would not be a problem. However
many representations can rely on negative stereotypes which may adversely affect the way others
then perceive a particular ethnic culture.
National identity based on the features of a specific country - its culture, traditions, language
and politics. Regional identity is also based on geographical area but can be
quite broad (someone could be from the North or the South of England) or
more specific (they could be Glaswegian or Cornish).
Representations of national and regional identity often focus on certain stereotypical characteristics
and customs associated with the nation or region. For example, that the French are romantic,
Italians are the best cooks, or the Irish are friendly.
M3. LECTURE 2, PART 1: FORMING INFORMED OPINIONS OR THESIS STATEMENTS
In turn, viewing a documentary about minority groups can be a pivotal step in forming informed
opinions and thesis statements. It equips you with the knowledge and context necessary to analyze
and reflect on the issues presented in the documentary. It encourages you to critically examine the
under-representation of these groups in media and how this lack of representation perpetuates
stereotypes and inequality. In this part of the module, you are to use your knowledge of concepts on
representation and under-representation in preparation for gaining refined knowledge about how
informed opinions or thesis statements may best be made.
A thesis statement is a concise and clear statement that articulates the main argument or point of
view in an essay, research paper, or any written work. It serves the following purposes:
A. Guide—it is like a road sign that serves as a guide that tells what the focus of the whole text is.
B. Main Point—it tells readers about the overall message of the whole text.
However, do note that while the main idea provides the topic or summary of each paragraph, the
thesis statement is responsible for providing the main point of the whole text, not just a single
paragraph.
In order to get a clearer picture of what a thesis statement is, consider the following essential
components of a thesis statement. These components must be satisfied, achieved, or found in a
statement before it can be considered a thesis:
Topic: It clearly identifies the topic, which is "the persistent issue of food insecurity in urban
communities."
2. Reduction of dependency on food aid programs: This argument raises questions about the
effectiveness of existing food aid programs and whether they are contributing to long-term
solutions or perpetuating dependency. It's arguable as opinions may differ on how best to
transition away from reliance on aid programs.
INTRODUCTION
Introduction—these are the first few paragraphs in any academic paper. It serves two purposes:
(1) identify what the topic and the thesis statement/s are; and
(2) prove the importance of the topic and validity of the author’s thesis statement related to the
topic
For an introduction to effectively serve its purposes, there are various techniques in paragraph
development that writers can use separately or in combination:
1. FACTUAL INFORMATION—this technique comes in the form of including details that have
already been proven and tested to be true or deemed to be logical.
Example:
Until recently, estradiol, the primary hormone secreted by the ovary, has been thought to
predominantly influence reproductive functions.
Thesis Statement: It is now known that this pleiotropic hormone has profound effects on plasticity
in the developing and adult brain (McEwen et al., 1995). Recent clinical studies demonstrate that
estradiol replacement in postmenopausal women ameliorates cognitive dysfunction (Sherwin. 1994;
Robinson et al., 1994; Henderson et al., 1996) and decreases the incidence and rate of
neurodegeneration associated with diseases such as Alzheimer's disease (Henderson et al., 1996;
Paganini-Hill and Henderson, 1994: Brenner et al., 1994).
2. How can the so-called factual pieces of information be checked for their validity or truthfulness?
a. Citations which include those by McEwen et al. (1995), Sherwin (1994), Robinson et al.,
(1994), etc. can be counterchecked.
3. How do the so-called factual pieces of information contribute to the effectiveness of the given
introduction?
a. The paragraph introduces the hormone estradiol as a potential preventive source of
medication/ medicine against Alzheimer’s and other similar diseases—ailments that affect
many and are seen to still be unpreventable or incurable until the present times.
2. ANECDOTE—this technique comes in the form of including retellings of relevant personal
experiences or experiences by other people.
Example:
We sat on the edge of the bed together, the day's end ritual drawing to a close. I gently stroked her
bent arthritic spine with the loving intent to ease the pain from the hours spent in immobility,
moving only from the chair to the bathroom, to the dining table and back again to the chair. Her
physical care for this day was complete. She relaxed under the soft touch of my hand and suddenly
said: “You are such a good mother." I was jolted out of my reverie to reply: “Excuse me, Mom." Our
eyes met, we laughed spontaneously and heartily, embraced and in that instantaneous moment
transcended the mundane tasks of caring and entered into a special moment of togetherness--a
mutual caring, compassion and recognition.
Thesis Statement: This moment was not one of role reversal but one of experiencing the meaning
of caregiving and receiving. Several days later, I shared this experience in a qualitative research class
discussion in phenomenology. The class participants were visibly moved, and shared recognition of…
3. Why might the experience of the person who shared his/ her encounter be relevant to the topics
covered by the introduction?
a. He/ she is probably a nurse/ caregiver who has had firsthand experience in caring for
patients.
3. DEFINITION—this technique comes in the form of giving meaning to, providing examples of,
or describing of relevant concept/s.
Example:
Cancer is the uncontrolled growth and spread of abnormal cells inside the body with the potential to
cause death.
[1] In America, it is the main cause of death in children aged 14 years or less.[2] In Indonesia, the
2013 Basic Health Research data state that 0.5% of total cancer patients are children aged 14 years
or less.[3] Children suffering from cancer at the end of their lives need comfort, but it is rarely
fulfilled.[4] The uncomfortable conditions experienced by children are related to pain, dyspnea,
digestive problems, and neurological changes. [3] Nurses' management of pain or other symptoms is
part of the multidisciplinary model of providing comfort. [6] Nurses' understanding of what comfort
means to children at the end of their lives affects the intervention of comfort provided to increase
the children's quality of life. [Z]
Thesis Statement: Therefore, exploring the nurses' understanding on the essence and meaning of
children's comfort at the end of their life is a study necessarily conducted.
2. How do the concepts defined in the paragraph relate to its topic, and how do they make the
introduction effective?
a. The definitions provide ideas about the disease cancer that causes discomfort among young
patients; they identify the different types of discomfort that the said disease causes among
the identified patients; and they make the introduction effective as they provide a clear
picture of an issue of concern which is the comfort that can be afforded to the patients while
experiencing a pain-causing disease.
4. BRIEF HISTORY—this technique comes in the form of including details about past events.
Example:
Thesis Statement: As with other practice professions, nursing requires a knowledge foundation
that is based on theory and derived from systematic research.
The first nursing theorist, Florence Nightingale, created detailed reports of both medical and nursing
matters as chief nurse for the British in the Crimean War in the mid-1850s. Nightingale noted that
“... apprehension, uncertainty, waiting, expectation, fear of surprise, do a patient more harm than
any exertion” (p. 6) (2). As a result, Nightingale's conceptualization of nursing included the need to
have an understanding of the laws of nature, the prevention of disease, and the use of personal
power. She viewed persons as both physical and spiritual beings, emphasizing the importance of the
environment and the need to care for the patient, not the disease. With her emphasis on the
environment, changes in nutrition, hydration, and sanitation, mortality rates dropped drastically
during the Crimean War (3). In subsequent years, Nightingale developed "laws of nursing" that
formed the basis for nursing science and guided nursing education in the United States from 1850 to
the 1950s (4).
2. Why are the identified past events relevant or helpful in making the introduction effective?
a. They prove the thesis statement or the claim that the nursing profession, just like any other
jobs, benefits from both sufficient theoretical knowledge and the process of systematic
researching which includes keeping records, experimentation, and healthcare decisions
based on results.
5. QUOTATION—this technique comes in the form of using statements coming from other
sources.
Example:
Thesis Statement: As with other practice professions, nursing requires a knowledge foundation
that is based on theory and derived from systematic research.
The first nursing theorist, Florence Nightingale, created detailed reports of both medical and nursing
matters as chief nurse for the British in the Crimean War in the mid-1850s. Nightingale noted that
“... apprehension, uncertainty, waiting, expectation, fear of surprise, do a patient more harm than
any exertion” (p. 6) (2). As a result, Nightingale's conceptualization of nursing included the need to
have an understand laws of nature, the prevention of disease, and the use of personal power. She
viewed persons as both physical and spiritual beings, emphasizing the importance of the
environment and the need to care for the patient, not the disease. With her emphasis on the
environment, changes in nutrition, hydration, and sanitation resulted, and mortality rates dropped
drastically during the Crimean War (3). In subsequent years, Nightingale developed "laws of nursing"
that formed the basis for nursing science and guided nursing education in the United States from
1850 to the 1950s (4).
2. How does the identified part help in making the introduction an effective one?
a. It comes from an icon in the profession being talked about—Florence Nightingale.
b. It supports the thesis statement that the nursing profession benefits best from deriving
decisions from research results—like what the source found out, i.e., apprehension, among
many others, affects patients negatively.
Example:
Thesis Statement: A mother's genetics determines how clever her children are, according to
researchers, and the father makes no difference. Women are more likely to transmit intelligence
genes to their children because they are carried on the X chromosome and women have two of
these, while men only have one.
Example:
Thesis Statement: All hospitals should use electronic health records (EHRs). As new legislation and
advances in technology have led many hospitals and clinics away from paper records, the debate
between the two still lingers. Some doctors cling to paper records out of habit or personal
preference, and there are often concerns about the security of information and protecting patient
privacy. But, as Americans become more transient and medical professionals more interconnected,
the fact that electronic records can be shared easily between hospitals is becoming more and more
important. EHRS also have a physical lasting power that is unmatched by paper records. There are
legitimate concerns about the security of electronic records, but the benefits outweigh the risks.
Thus, even though EHRs pose some security risks, every hospital should use them because they are
permanent and they can be shared easily between hospitals.
2. How do the recent events or given trends support or make the introduction effective?
a. They make it seem that the thesis statement or argument, “All hospitals should use
electronic health records (EHRs),” is true since many believe it or imply it to be their belief
by means of how they prefer electronic versions of their records over their printed
counterparts.
Example:
Cancer is the uncontrolled growth and spread of abnormal cells inside the body with the potential to
cause death.[1] In America, it is the main cause of death in children aged 14 years or less.[2] In
Indonesia, the 2013 Basic Health Research data state that 0.5% of total cancer patients are children
aged 14 years or less.[3] Children suffering from cancer at the end of their lives need comfort, but it
is rarely fulfilled.[4] The uncomfortable conditions experienced by children are related to pain,
dyspnea, digestive problems, and neurological changes. [3] Nurses' management of pain or other
symptoms is part of the multidisciplinary model of providing comfort. [6] Nurses' understanding of
what comfort means to children at the end of their lives affects the intervention of comfort provided
to increase the children's quality of life. [Z] Thesis Statement: Therefore, exploring the nurses'
understanding on the essence and meaning of children's comfort at the end of their life is a study
necessarily conducted.
2.How does the number or numerical data support or make the introduction effective?
a. It makes readers have more concrete idea about how many of those who suffer from cancer
are children whose comfort, while going through such illness, must be ensured. While the
number or percentage may seem insignificant, it still presents the idea that there are young
lives at stake and must be taken care of.
BODY
The Body—at this part of an academic paper, the following functions must be served: (1) to explain,
(2) to provide examples, and (3) elaborate on reasons/ explore ideas.
2. What techniques were possibly used to support and develop the introduction?
a. Sentences 2 and 3 may either be classified as factual pieces of information or shocking
statements since they prove what makes the human body wonderful by means of saying
how it is better shaped compared to bodies of other organisms despite it being less
beautiful and how it is capable of doing many types of work.
Since the body of an academic paper must explore an idea, elaborate on a chosen topic, and support
the thesis statement, there are also various paragraph development techniques a writer can use to
do so other than the one used previously. The common ones are as follows:
1. NARRATIVE—this kind of paragraph shows how events take place and in what sequence.
Example: It was three in the morning. Sarah’s husband stood up from their bed and rushed to their
room’s toilet. There, he started vomiting. Later that morning, he was rushed to the hospital and was
found to have suffered from food poisoning. Hours before that unfortunate event, the couple had
gone eating at a fine-dining restaurant, with Sarah’s husband unknowingly ordering and eating
spoiled scallops. It took them such a mishap to realize how serious and bothersome food poisoning
can be, with Sarah even saying, “I was so shocked by what was going on that didn’t know what to do
to help him.”
2. Can the events be sequenced in a chronological order or according to how they actually
happened? Which event comes first, second, and third?
c. Sarah’s husband and she eating at a restaurant and ordering spoiled food
a. Sarah’s husband vomiting at 3am in the morning
b. hospitalization of Sarah’s husband and the diagnosis of food poisoning
3. If any, are there details that support the claims of the narrative paragraph to be true?
a. Direct quotation of Sarah where she states the events to be shocking and her not knowing
what to do
Example: Gardner and Lambert (1972) have defined attitude in terms of the endurance exhibited by
the learner in using extensive effort or energy to achieve a particular goal. Stem (1983) has included
attitudes towards learning the target language itself and learning languages in a general way.
Example: It’s perfectly normal for kids to exhibit a certain behavioral style in class. Behavior, after
all, is a primary form of communication for school-age children. Decipher its meaning and you’ll be
better equipped to help your child succeed academically.
Here are a few of the more common classroom styles: The class clown tends to be outgoing.
Gregarious child is in need of attention. At home he’s also charming and funny, but at times drives
you crazy with his endless capacity for high jinx.
The shrinking violet is shy, introverted and insecure about speaking up in school. In a comfortable
setting at home or with close friends, however, she may be full of talk.
The daydreamer who tunes out or doodles in class may have a concentration problem, or the work
could be either too advanced or too easy.
The eager beaver tends to be a high achiever who’s naturally motivated. But he can be hard on
himself if he doesn’t meet his own standards.
Example 1: The researcher requested permission from the author of the “A Survey of Foreign
Language Learning Motivation” (Wang, 2010) among Polytechnic Students in China to use the
questionnaire in gathering the data needed in the study.
The questionnaire was modified through the assistance of the statistician and his adviser.
Example 2: A number of curious experiences occur at the onset of sleep. A person just about to go to
sleep may experience an electric shock, a flash of light, or a crash of thunder – but the most common
sensation is that of floating, or falling, which is why “falling asleep” is a scientifically valid
description.
A nearly universal occurrence at the beginning of sleep (although not everyone recalls it) is a sudden,
uncoordinated jerk of the head, the limbs, or even the entire body. Most people tend to think of
going to sleep as a slow, slippage into oblivion, but the onset of sleep is not gradual at all. It happens
in an instant. One moment the individual is awake, the next moment not.
2. What are the steps, in ascending order, involved in the process illustrated in Example 1?
a. requesting permission from Wang (2010) for the use of his/ her questionnaire from the
study titled “A Survey of Foreign Language Learning Motivation”
b. modification of the questionnaire with the help of a statistician and the research adviser
3. What are the other details in Example 2 that do not just state steps but explain the process or
concept involved?
a. going to sleep not being slow or gradual but instantaneous
Given:
Table 5. Distribution of Respondents by their Use of Chinese Outside their Class
Chinese Language Usage Outside Class Frequency Percentage
1. Hardly 38 11.2
2. Sometimes with foreign friends 143 42.2
3. Sometimes with other teachers or peers 38 11.2
4. Sometimes with my family members 120 35.4
Total 339 100
Example:
The Respondents in Terms of their Use of Chinese Outside their Class
Table 5 shows the distribution of the respondents by their use of Chinese outside their class.
The 11.2% of the respondents hardly use Chinese outside their class. The 42.2% of the respondents
sometimes use Chinese language with foreign friends while 11.2% of the respondents sometimes
use Chinese language with other teachers or peers. The 35.4%of the respondents sometimes use
Chinese language with their family members.
The first major change has been in sexual attitudes. Thirty years ago it was considered taboo for
a woman even to say the word “sex” in public. Today women as well as men are able to discuss sex
and its problems and joys freely and openly. Additionally, women are now emphasizing their roles as
sexual partners and leaders rather than inferiors and followers, and men are accepting that change,
too.
2. How many changes are there and what are they specifically?
a. 4: sexual attitudes; marriage ideas; marriage roles; career opportunities
3. How different are the women of the past from their present counterparts in terms of the
identified major changes in their lifestyle?
a. sexual attitude—present-day women are now expressive of the word “sex” even in public
setups unlike the women before them.
b. marriage and career opportunities—present-day women are now active in discussing with
their partners the roles they play in life as well as in pursuing leadership roles unlike their
previous counterparts who saw themselves as inferiors and as mere followers.
7. CAUSE AND EFFECT—this kind of paragraph specifies reasons or sources and results, telling
how an event takes place and why.
Example:
Next to leave are those who get sick or have bad accidents. This happened to a girl down the hall in
my dormitory, but she plans to be back after Christmas.
Another reason to leave is marriage, either “shotgun” style or being unable to wait until summer or
graduation.
Also, after the first year or two, some students transfer, either for the reasons that might also make
them drop out (get closer to home, marry, money problems) or to earn a degree only offered
elsewhere.
There are two final reasons that cause dropouts: money problems and bad grades. College students
everywhere are always short on funds.
Finally, some students cannot handle the academic part of college life. For many reasons, from too
much partying to weak high school preparation, they flunk out of school. In fact, after looking back
over this list, it will be surprising if anyone sitting in this class will be left to graduate in four years.
All of the previously identified paragraph development techniques/ methods fall under what is
called expository writing, a form of writing aimed at explaining ideas and educating or informing
readers about them. As opposed to other forms of writing, expository writing is informational and
backed with facts and is technical.
CONCLUSION
The Conclusion—In an academic paper, there must be a part called conclusion which must serve the
following functions: (1) to summarize/ restate the main point/ thesis statement or (2) challenge
readers to do certain action/s related to the thesis statement.
Now armed with ideas on representation, sensitive about how these play a role in how different
groups function in society, especially those of the minority, and equipped with the skills how to
formulate informed opinions about how these groups are greatly affected and may best be helped,
you students are now expected to start your final requirement or action plan. It is elaborated as
follows:
Final Requirement:
Action plan for solving a contemporary community/ social problem, with the solution being related
to the students’ respective degree programs
Action Plan—the requirement is a very short but practical academic paper that will require students
to identify a contemporary community/ social problem (which may or may not involve minority
groups) then provide a practicable solution using knowledge or skills in their degree program, e.g., if
the chosen problem is about teenage pregnancy, those from the College of Nursing may come up
with proven deterrent and medical solutions from the field of nursing.
Format/ Parts—the paper is expected to have the following parts which will require them to use all
the skills and topics covered in the whole course and their knowledge from their respective degree
programs. This will likewise be somewhat an introduction to how scholarly papers are expected to
be written in the collegiate level, i.e., replete with references and rooted in various relevant
literature and studies that aim to address certain societal concerns.
I. Statement of Purpose—at this part, students are expected to provide two to three sentences that
would identify the objectives/ goals of their proposed plan of action.
II. Rationale/ Background of the Problem/ Description of the Problem—In here, students are
expected to provide a background about the prevalence and importance of addressing a selected
contemporary community/ social problem using relevant local and international references.
The following guide question/s may be used:
• What prevalent problem in your community needs addressing/ solving?
• Why should it be solved/ addressed?
• What are the proofs that would support the idea that it is a big problem that affects many
people?
III. Background and Analysis of the Solution/ Description of the Solution—In here, students are to
explore a possible solution for the problem introduced earlier, but the solution must be one that is
anchored on the students’ respective degree programs.
IV. Procedure and Schematics of the Proposed Solution—In here, students are to provide a brief
step-by-step guide on how the solution may be carried out paired up with a personalized graphic aid
that may visually illustrate the process, timeline, resources, budget, etc. of the plan.
V. References—In here, students are expected to list down following the APA 7th edition style all of
the references they used in formulating the plan.