Engineering Report
Engineering Report
:
Effective Date:
APP-REG-FORM- Revision No.: 2
14/02/2022
C1
Form C2.3 ER
Engineering Report
Use this form to report in about 100 words per criterion under Outcomes 1 to 11 below on a recent engineering task, part of a project
or complete project to which you have made a significant contribution. The report may cover conceptualization, design and analysis,
specification, tendering and adjudication, manufacturing, project and construction management, commissioning, maintenance,
measurement and testing or planning at a well-defined level. Please also provide a sample relevant calculations and drawings as an
addendum which is limited to two A4 pages.
Use Appendix A of the Discipline Specific Training Guide R-05-PN to assist in the interpretation of the criteria
Engineering brief and The repair of a failed flexible pavement structure by milling out the surface and
objective: (< 30 words) substate to a depth of 150mm and backfilling with BTB and 40mm medium
asphalt.
Environment: Industry; Transportation, Roads Infrastructure for the South African National Roads
Laboratory; Theory; Simulation, etc. in Agency SOC Limited (SANRAL)
<15 words)
Short Summary: The road was laden with deep ruts exceeding 20mm, potholes and wet base
(State engineering problems; solutions due to water infiltration on coarse surface. The improvement of the pavement
in < 30 words) was to eliminate deterioration of the road and promote safe movement of
vehicles.
Budget: (<10 words) R53Million
Well-defined engineering problems have the following characteristics:
a) can be solved mainly by practical engineering knowledge, underpinned by related theory;
and one or more of:
b) are largely defined but may require clarification;
c) are discrete, focused tasks within engineering systems;
d) are routine, frequently encountered, may be unfamiliar but in familiar context;
and one or more of:
e) can be solved by standardised or prescribed ways;
f) are encompassed by standards, codes and documented procedures; requires authorisation to work outside
limits;
g) information is concrete and largely complete, but requires checking and possible supplementation;
h) involve several issues but few of these imposing conflicting constraints and a limited range of interested and
affected parties;
and one or both of:
i) requires practical judgement in practice area in evaluating solutions, considering interfaces to other role-
players;
j) have consequences which are locally important but not far reaching (wider impact are dealt with by others).
Well-defined engineering activities (WDEA) have several of the following characteristics:
a) Scope of practice area is defined by techniques applied; change by adopting new techniques into current practice;
b) Practice area is located within a wider, complex context, with well-defined working relationships with other parties and
disciplines;
c) Work involves familiar, defined range of resources, including people, money, equipment, materials, technologies;
d) Require resolution of interactions manifested between specific technical factors with limited impact on wider issues;
e) Are constrained by operational context, defined work package, time, finance, infrastructure, resources, facilities,
standards and codes, applicable laws;
f) Have risks and consequences that are locally important but are generally not far reaching.
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
It is the responsibility of the user to ensure that the latest version is used. The latest version will be published on ECSA Document Management system.
When I checked the severity of the defects that I mentioned above I realised that the problem
could have extended to the underlying layers as there was wide and deep rutting in certain
sections. Using a 2m straight edge I measured the rutting depths and noticed that some were
greater than 10mm. That step was necessary in deciding what corrective actions will be taken,
bearing the cost in mind.
From the evaluation I made I saw that the road was frequently under heavy traffic of trucks and
buses, this traffic was generated from transportation of goods from the coast ;because of these
findings, my advice was that for ruts between 15mm and 20mm, a 40mm medium wearing course
be used and where ruts are deeper than 20mm, a 150mm base patch should be done this
primarily to the wet base.
Outcome 2: Design or develop a solution to well-defined engineering problems encountered in
your work:
2.1 Describe ETB and BTB
how you The following had to considered when doing these pavement repairs:
designed or
developed and Cost
analysed Time
alternative Quality
approaches to
do the work.
Impacts
In order to prevent the road from deteriorating further. On the sections that were showing surface
checked. deterioration a 40mm medium wearing course was used to repair however on sections that had
Calculations upscale we had to decide whether BTB or ETB pavement layer repairs had to be done.
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
It is the responsibility of the user to ensure that the latest version is used. The latest version will be published on ECSA Document Management system.
Also considering the time implications to wait for an approval of mix designs and order required
bituminous product to mix the product on site. This option poses more problems requiring more
precision/expertise from the contractor thus I thought of chances of the quality being
compromised were more. BTB would be supplied by a batch plant which would make the mix a
better lab-controlled product that would give more accurate results. It is made from high quality
materials to achieve strength and durability. It is also a better product to use in places that have
high traffic volumes compared to ETB.
Considering all the above: BTB was a much better product to use than ETB. (Calculations on
annexure)
2.2 State what Looking at the state the road was in and the rate of deterioration; Some surface patches would
the final have to be upscaled to 150mm BTB patches due to infiltrated water into the substrate.
solution to Subsequently the wet base was affected by the high traffic volumes on a daily bases, and the
perform the increase in traffic volumes as the holiday season was approaching.
work was,
client or your
supervisor in Considering all this we concluded that the solution was feasible as it would cost more to do the
agreement. BTB patches to existing road level. The solution was accepted by the Client as proposed.
Outcome 3: Comprehend and apply the knowledge in established engineering practices and
knowledge specific within your practice area as applied in your task:
3.1 State what Construction Methods 1 and Construction Materials:
NDip level I ensured that Hot-mix asphalt from the batch plant arrived on site with temperatures as per
engineering
design parameters in our case 160⁰C and well mixed with no segregation. The temperature of
standard
procedures the asphalt was checked in the truck, paver and on the mat using a calibrated Tel-Tru
and systems thermometer. It is important that once the truck arrives, the pre-mix remains hot during after
you used to placing. Directly after being placed, it must be compacted using static rollers (pneumatic- tyre
execute the roller and steel wheeled rollers).
work, and how
NDip level The temperature during compaction is an important parameter that determines the volumetric
theory was
properties of the compacted asphalt pavement. Using an improper compaction temperature can
applied to
understand cause problems on the dense-graded asphalt mixture performance. If the compaction
and/or verify temperature is less than the desirable temperature, it can potentially reduce the density and
these increase the air voids, thus reduce the pavement strength.
procedures.
The temperature must be constantly and closely monitored and captured. A calibrated nuclear
gauge must be utilised for process control however I ensured that cores were drilled from the
compacted asphalt within 24hours when the temperature of the road is 20⁰C or less, for quality
assurance.
3.2 Give your Traffic accommodation in relation to asphalt patches and theory.
own NDip level
theoretical Because any work activity which results in a decrease of the road space available to the travelling
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
It is the responsibility of the user to ensure that the latest version is used. The latest version will be published on ECSA Document Management system.
Traffic accommodation during construction was to be carried out as two-way traffic and in some
sections a Stop/Go was put in place. Before any construction could start I observed that this was
a very busy route due to all the trucks and because the towns are close to each other, people
travel to and from work in the morning and in the afternoon.
Implementing a stop/go in the morning and afternoon in areas that require it would be a problem
because it was going to frustrate the road user due to the delays. I then suggested that where
traffic accommodation would cause us to have one-way traffic the work must commence when
traffic volumes have decreased.
This made it possible to accommodate the traffic in both directions and eliminated safety issues
and frustrations that could arise from the public that is common to the route.
In sections where traffic could still flow in both directions because it was a 4-lane road we simply
closed the lane that we were working on using temporary road signs, flagmen and delineators.
Delineators were placed 5m c/c apart. Placing of all temporary road construction signs was done
according to the project specifications which are in line the South African Road Traffic Signs
Manual (SARTSM) Volume 2 Chapter 13. We ensured that all surface repairs are complete while
there is visibility and before the traffic volumes increased.
Asphalt Compaction
The right compact of a new asphalt layer is important as it reduces the amount of air voids in the
asphalt layer and to move the aggregate in the layer closer together. The three important
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
It is the responsibility of the user to ensure that the latest version is used. The latest version will be published on ECSA Document Management system.
By applying its weight to the HMA surface and compressing the material underneath the
ground contact area. Since this compression will be greater for longer periods of contact,
lower equipment speeds will produce more compaction, higher equipment weight will
also increase compression.
By creating shear stress between the compressed material underneath the ground
contact area and the adjacent uncompressed material. When combined with equipment
speed, this produces shear rate. Lowering equipment speed can decrease the shear
rate, which increases the shearing stress. Higher shearing stresses are more capable of
rearranging aggregate into denser configurations.
Depending on the job, other equipment may be necessary to use when asphalt paving. The
machines listed above are the essential pieces of equipment used to pave highways, parking lots
and other paved areas.
Outcome 4: Manage part or all of one or more well-defined engineering activities embodied in
your work:
4.1 State how My responsibilities included conducting safety checks every day. I checked all the previous day’s
you managed daily maintenance report, traffic accommodations and route patrol registers.
yourself, During the day I would be in the office checking if there is any correspondence I needed to attend
priorities,
to, recording daily diaries and admin process that need to be put in place. I go to site on a formal
processes and
resources in request from the contractor for me to do inspections on work during and once completed (e.g. if
doing the work they have erected new fences, repaired guardrails. The contractor will write an inspection request
(e.g. bar chart). and I will inspect to see if the work is done according to standard.
Finally, in the afternoon I would drive through site again to check if the traffic signs are still in
accordance with SARTSM so that we leave the road in a safe condition.
4.2 Describe I am responsible for quality control and acceptance of the work this includes monitoring
your role and construction processes. Once a month I prepare appendices for site meetings, site meeting
contribution in minutes and technical minutes. I am responsible for the daily inspection of traffic accommodation
the work team. and daily traffic reports on site accidents. Once a month I also inspect the emergency trailer,
route patrol equipment and site vehicles, to ensure all necessary equipment is in place. I also
liaise with the Public Liaison Officer for all Sub-Contractor’s monthly performance.
I do measurement of quantities and reach an agreement with the contractor and verify the
contractor’s monthly claim. I manage and complete activities to the Client’s expectations and
satisfaction.
I give feedback to the Route Manager on daily activities e.g. (building of gabions and layer
construction). Any work that I think demands his expertise I bring to his attention.
I mentor students on how to calculate quantities, conduct site inspections and monitor works of
layer repairs.
Outcome 5: Communicate clearly with others in the course of your engineering activities (well-
defined engineering work):
5.1 State how I sent a weekly report to the Client, Engineer, Contract’s Manager and Site Agent keeping all
you presented stakeholders updated about different activities and progress on site.
your point of I compiled as-built data for all structural work, signage, fences, bridges and layer repairs to be
view and
used in the road conditions report. I ensured that full and accurate standardized records are kept
compiled
reports after of all site activities/meetings.
completion of The contractor had to fill in request forms every time before inspection of any section. This
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
It is the responsibility of the user to ensure that the latest version is used. The latest version will be published on ECSA Document Management system.
5.2 State how I always communicated verbally then follow it up by sending an e-mail with a set of quantities,
you compiled small scale drawings and pictures for clarification of the work. At times I also used e-mails to
and issued correct the contractor if there was work that was not done correctly on site. Issuing formal written
instructions to instruction such as penalties for traffic offences or monthly items not complete I request the Route
entities working
on the same
Manager to issue them on a standard instruction form.
task.
Outcome 6: Recognise the reasonably foreseeable social, cultural and environmental effects of
your well-defined engineering activity (task):
6.1 Describe Environmental impact.
the social, As this was a surface repair project once the milled out material was removed. The surface was
cultural and cleaned using a skid steer broom on a bobcat and this caused dust. After it was clean from loose
environmental
aggregates the next step was to tack the surface. During the tack-coating I instructed the
impact of this
engineering contractor to be cautious not to spray the tack in windy conditions. The result could’ve led in
activity. undue spillage to the road, affect passing traffic, plants and contaminate the land.
Socio-economic
Although the project is a temporary project the Traffic Accommodation was affect to certain
degree. The project also benefited society as it created employment and will leave the citizens
with skills that they can use in long term.
Cultural
There are sack-manne rasta people in the area who walk barefoot in between towns. During the
construction we had to respect and assist them not to walk too close to the asphalt as it would
burn their feet. I instructed the two students and the traffic safety officer to be on the lookout for
the sack-manne rasta and if there are any nearby they should be escorted them away from the
work.
6.2 State how I understand the importance of Safety, Health, Environment and Quality (SHEQ) management.
you After assessing the risk posed by cleaning of the exposed material I pre-cautioned and
communicated recommended that all employees should wear disposable masks, this is in addition to their
mitigating personal protective gear. I also cautioned that earpieces must be given to employees involved
measures to with the paver which produces high noise levels
affected parties
and acquired
stakeholder Firstly consulted with the safety consultant and he made me aware that there is NIHL Regulations
engagement. (Noise Induced Hearing Loss Regulations) which stipulate that where employees may be
exposed to noise levels above the noise-rating limit (regardless of whether hearing protection is
worn) an employer must conduct a Noise Assessment / Survey. This must be done by an AIA
(NIHL Regulation 6). So, I advised the contractor to find quotation from suitable companies that
qualify to conduct this survey.
Outcome 7: Meet all legal and regulatory requirements and protect the health and safety of
persons in the course of your well-defined engineering activity (task):
7.1 List the I ensured that the traffic accommodation took into account the provisions of the latest edition of
major laws and the South African Road Traffic Safety Manual (SARTSM). The latest version of accommodation of
regulations traffic being volume 2, chapter 13 of the June 1999 edition and Standard specifications of routine
applicable to
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
It is the responsibility of the user to ensure that the latest version is used. The latest version will be published on ECSA Document Management system.
7.2 State how During the time when the Contractor was not performing by completing Job Instructions on site I
you obtained received advice from the Contracts Engineer to issue a Site Instruction giving the Contractor 14
advice in doing days to fix the work. The work was still not complete within the 14 days and the Contracts
risk Engineer using Fédération Internationale Des Ingénieurs-Conseils (FIDIC) issued a 15.1 Notice
management
to correct. After 28 days from the time the notice to correct was issued the Contracts Engineer
for the work
and elaborate further issued a 15.2 Termination by Employer. The decision to terminate the contract was based
on the risk on information I provided to the Contract Engineer and the Client.
management
system I also received advice from the health and safety consultant for safe work practice on the
applied. regulations that govern the type of project I am working on which is road construction. I then
personally observed and conducted more research. The risk management system that is applied
is divided into 2 sections which are the baseline risk assessment and client’s health and safety
specifications as per construction regulation 5(1)(b) 2014. The baseline risk assessment is used
to identify any risk associated with any hazard at a construction site in order to identify the steps
needed to be taken to remove, reduce or control such hazards. Clients health and safety
specifications outlines the scope of the work and how to carry out each construction activity in a
manner that is compliant to the OHS rules
Outcome 10: Be responsible for making decisions on part or all of well-defined engineering
activities included in your work:
10.1 Show how
you used NDip During the visual assessment for pavement layer repairs. I quantified the amount of work to be
theoretical done. The brief calculations done below include the hauling of milled out material. The conversion
calculations to factor of asphalt from m3 to ton differs from region to region and asphalt plant. The conversion
justify factor which is to convert the amount cubic meters to tons was given to me by the batch plant and
decisions taken it was 2.52.
in doing
engineering
work. Attach Below is a summary of how I got the quantities to be paved.
actual
calculations
Calculations for Wearing Course:
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
It is the responsibility of the user to ensure that the latest version is used. The latest version will be published on ECSA Document Management system.
Summary of calculations:
CONTROLLED DISCLOSURE
It is the responsibility of the user to ensure that the latest version is used. The latest version will be published on ECSA Document Management system.