Chapter 1 and 2
Chapter 1 and 2
Address and reduce pollution fouling our air, water, and soil.........................
Positive consequences...................................................................................
Negative consequences..................................................................................
Research...................................................................................................................
Solution requirements..............................................................................................
Design Requirements...............................................................................................
Selection of Solution................................................................................................
Selection of Prototype..............................................................................................
Chapter 1
Present and Justify a Problem and Solution
Requirements
Causes
The huge generation of waste:
In 2012, Egypt produced 89.03 million tons of solid waste, including 21
million tons of municipal solid waste, 30 million tons of Agricultural waste, 6
million tons of Industrial waste, 28,300 tons of hazardous medical waste, 4
million tons of construction
demolition waste, 25 million
tons of waterway cleansing,
and 3 million tons of sludge.
Cairo is the city that produces
waste with 15,000 tons of
waste, then comes Giza with
Figure 3: Waste Composition in Egypt.
4,500 tons of waste. In 2016,
Milik, S. M. (2021). Assessment of solid waste management in
according to the Report on
Egypt during the last decade considering
Environmental Status of
Egypt, the generation of waste was around 90 million tons of waste. As shown
in Figure 3, the waste composition in percentage for each type of waste.
Inadequate budget:
The solid waste management (SWM) financial sources are insufficient as
the allocated budget and the available resources do not cover the cost of SWM
developments and activities. The main source for funding SWM in Egypt is the
central government, with the cleansing fund and other funds like donors' funds
that help SWM, and usually, the funds are sent to non-governmental
organizations (NGOs) or NGOs in cooperation with Ministries. So, there is no
direct fund for SWM through the central government budget, but it follows the
central government supervision in other fields. As a result, the SWM has no
earnings to improve its facilities by, for example, buying modernized collections
or treatment equipment.
The lack of awareness of people:
One of the main causes of solid waste mismanagement (SWM) is the lack
of awareness of people about SWM, especially in rural areas like Qena, Sohag,
and Minya, because of the low education level and awareness about recycling
problems and the challenges that Egypt suffers from.
Most people in rural areas do not know the importance of recycling and the
harm of not paying attention to it. In addition, many children in Egypt do this
behavior automatically because they see older people doing it. This habit is
often widespread in rural areas due to a lack of interest in education.
The generation of waste in rural areas per capita is 0.5 to 0.6 KG/day, and in
urban areas, it is around 1.0. Rural areas produce 70 – 80% organic waste with
about 2/3 of food leavings and 1/3 of animal manure; rural areas also produce
approximately 6% plastic waste, 6% diapers, that is because they like to have
many children, 4% paper and cardboard, 2& glass, and 1% metals.
Impacts
the Delta region, increases the emissions of PM 2.5 by about 35%, which leads to
many miserable diseases like ischemic heart disease (IHD) and cardiovascular
lung. Hence, the number of diseases has reached 12 thousand per year because
of this particulate matter PM2.5.
Resource depletion:
The lack of recycling leads to the depletion and reduction of the original
resources because when new products are made, pure materials must be used.
The recycling process plays an important role in saving raw materials, for
instance, recycling 1 ton of paper can save more than 17 trees from cutting
danger, and it can save the energy that could be used in tree cutting and
transporting it to the factories.
Address and reduce pollution fouling our air, water, and
soil
Pollution is the addition of any Harmful substance to the environment. Those
harmful substances are called Pollutants. Egypt was ranked the 9th among the
most polluted countries in the year 2022,
as shown in Figure (6). This shows how
Big the pollution problem is in Egypt. In
addition, Cairo was ranked 126th among
the most polluted cities in the year 2022.
Pollutants are harmful Substances that
affect the environment Badly. Industrial
production and Commercial service are
found to be the main solid pollutants with
41.4%. And the oil industry accounts for Figure 6: percentage of each type of pollution in Egypt
14.1% of pollutants (EEA, 2017) as
Shown in Figure (6). The health burden
associated with air pollution was
estimated at EGP47 billion in 2016-17 in
Greater Cairo alone, or 1.35% of GDP,
according to the World Bank (Larsen,
2019). The cost of the toll on health due
to air pollution resulting from the burning
of fossil fuels was estimated at more than
EGP100 billion in 2018, or 2.8% of GDP Figure 7: the immense Fertilizers consumption per year in Egypt
(Greenpeace, 2020). Not all pollution is
air pollution as Egypt also suffers from soil Pollution. Agriculture soil in Egypt
suffers from a big problem Which is represented in chemical Pesticides
consumption (EC, 2018) as shown in Figure (7).
Causes
Waste Mismanagement:
Egypt has a lack of recycling wastes which it is in the 7th position of the
list of countries with the most mismanaged plastic wastes, Egypt has been
facing with wastes management for about two decades the private sector wastes
management industry is facing due to structural problems in the industry, and
the markets have a lack of products of recycling. According to annual report of
waste management statistics in Egypt
was reported in 2013, Egypt has
generated a total of 89.03 million tons of
solid wastes and the most serious part of
it were municipal solid wastes calculated
at 21 million tons, in addition to. 6
million tons of industrial waste, 28,300
tons of Hazardous medical waste, 30
million tons of Agricultural waste, etc.
As shown in Figure 8.
Increasing waste can cause soil and water and air pollution. Therefore, global
warming will increase burning waste in landfills and increase the emissions of
greenhouse gases which cause global warming. When the amount of waste
increases, the people, through the waste in water, so, the sources of clean water
will pollute and maybe cause desertification, drought, and several problems.
Soil and water contamination:
Total CO2 emissions in Egypt are estimated at about 180 Megaton per year.
The division of CO2 emissions in sectors is shown in Figure 9. The estimate
shows that roughly 60% of CO2 emissions in Egypt are caused by the industry.
Impacts
Health Problems:
Public health is directly threatened by pollution. With regard to illness or
disability, it reduces
Egyptians' life expectancy
by an average of two years.
19,200 people died
prematurely and over 3
billion days were lived with
illness in Egypt in 2017 Figure 10: Disease caused by inhaling PM2.5
because of ambient PM2.5
air pollution in Greater Cairo, and inadequate water, sanitation, and hygiene in
all of Egypt. Air pollution caused 90,559 premature deaths in Egypt in 2019 and
over 12% of all deaths in 2017. The World Health Organization database
indicates that in Egypt in 2016, heart disease (57.9%), stroke (17.7%),
pulmonary and lower respiratory disorders, and cancer (24.4%) were the
illnesses linked to air pollution that caused early mortality. In Egypt,
noncommunicable illnesses account for 82% of deaths and 67% of premature
deaths, making them the leading cause of death.
The health problems outcomes had increased due to the presence of ambient
PM2.5 with huge amounts in Egypt air, The exposure to high amounts pf PM 2.5 is
a primary reason for many diseases like ischemic heart disease (IHD),
cerebrovascular disease (stroke) (CBV), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
(COPD), lung cancer, and diabetes Type II among adults (25+ years of age), and
acute lower respiratory infections (ALRI) among children and adults (all ages)
As shown in Figure 10.
The annual deaths
because of PM2.5
exposure in Greater
Cairo accounted for
12,000 to 13,000 in
2017. About 59% of
the estimated deaths Figure 11: shows the annual deaths because of PM2.5 exposure
like the Eastern and Western deserts in Egypt is extremely high during the day,
as it reaches 45 degrees Celsius, and very cooler at night, reaching between 8 to
18 degrees Celsius in Sinai, which reaches 30 degrees Celsius. The precipitation
of Sinai is equivalent to 125mm, as shown in Figure 12. One of the reasons
that causes arid areas is lacking water, so if Egypt knows how to benefit from
the flood discharge problem, it will improve these desert lands. The solution to
flood discharge is impounding water and distributing it. Hence, most of Egypt’s
area is an arid one. The consequences of arid areas are immense and hazardous,
like desertification, land degradation, and drought. Land degradation is an
important global issue for the 21st century because of its adverse impact on
agronomic productivity, the environment, and its effect on food security and
quality of life.
Causes
Water erosion:
Many regions in Egypt suffer from
flood problems, like the Sinai, which
submit to fluvial processes as shown in
Figure (13), which is a major source of
deforestation Erosional processes in
Anthropogenic activities:
Too many anthropogenic activities lead to increasing desertification and
deforestation in escorting to the forming and increasing arid areas such as
overgrazing. For instance, Sinai has 18 sites
distinguished by agricultural areas as there is a
botanical survey according to (Moustafa,
2001). They found that throughout the 18
localities, as shown in Figure (15), 316 plant
species were identified as growing in different
habitats. Grazing intensity is measured on a
scale from 1-6. The severe grazing has resulted
Figure 15: The distinguished 18 sites in Sinai
in the disappearance of pastoral plants, a paucity of
trees and shrubs, as well as the disappearance of many rare and endemic species
and increased arid areas in these species as the lowest percentage of endangered
species are in 6-grazing intensity as shown in Figure (16).
Impacts
Agricultural depletion:
Land degradation is the proximate
implementation of arid areas in Egypt.
When a specific region is subjected to
deforestation, cutting down trees,
desertification, or grazing, it turns out to be
an arid area. By passing the time, it comes
Figure 16: the relation between grazing intensity and
to pass a desert. In the desert areas and the .engendered species
desert valley fringes, the active dunes and
sand encroachment phenomenon is widespread, causing around 16% of Egypt’s
total areas to be covered with Aeolian windblown sands and dunes, which lead
to the movement of dunes and sand sediments on productive agricultural lands.
The total agricultural area affected by such a phenomenon is estimated at
around 1.8 million feddan of the total agricultural land in Egypt. The economic
losses are estimated at around 25% of average productivity. According to (Arab
Republic of Egypt Ministry of Agriculture and Land Reclamation Desert
Research Center, n.d.)
Water availability:
In the future is threatened by deforestation, which is caused by arid areas, the
water share per capita has been going
down Figure (17) in an inverse relation
with the population growth; it went
down from around 3000m³ in 1947
with a population of around 15,000,000
people to 500m³ in 2010 with a
Figure 17: the relation between population and water share per capita
population of around 82,000,000 people, and this will result in high water bills
and reduction in agriculture production and a general decrease in quality of life.
According to Figure (x), Water share in Egypt per capita/m3 (1897-2010)
Dehydration of land:
Dehydration occurs when the area doesn't have a source of water, but lack
of a source of water isn't the only reason for dehydration. There are other
reasons, such as hot weather. There are a lot of
areas in Egypt that suffer from dehydration,
like Sinai, Eastern Desert, and Western Desert.
It takes 95% of Egypt's area, which estimated
at 680,650 km2 In these areas, people don't
concentrate, so it causes urban Congestion,
people concentrate on the Nile River, which is
considered 6,650 km, and this area is equal to
5% of Egypt's area, as shown in Figure (18).
Causes
Overreliance on the Nile River:
Relying on something that is not sufficiently secure can cause many
problems, as it is not guaranteed that the Nile River will always remain
renewed, increasing and full of water, especially after the problems that occur to
it, such as climate change.)the Nile delta becomes the second most susceptible
place on earth to climate change impacts in terms of sea level rise," says Karim
Elgendy, an associate fellow at the Chatham Institute think tank.) This heavy
dependence makes the country vulnerable to any changes in the river's flow
especially with upstream developments like the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance
Dam (GERD)., Filling the GERD during drought periods could significantly
reduce Egypt's Nile water allocation.
The oscillation of statues of (GERD)
would have a big risk and almost
guaranteed the Disturbance of water. As
shown in figure 21, This shows that the
water supply from the Nile River has
Figure 21: relation between the average annual water loss with filling
become non-guaranteed. Egypt fears the of GERD
catastrophic consequences of
unilaterally filling the dam in a short span of time before reaching a legally
binding agreement that would safeguard the water rights of everyone. The
country is already suffering from severe water scarcity and an annual water
deficit of 7 billion cubic meters.
Climate change
Warmer temperatures enhance evaporation from water bodies, soil, and
vegetation, reducing surface water levels and soil moisture. This process
diminishes water supplies for drinking, agriculture, and industry. Climate
change-induced sea level rise forces saltwater to penetrate freshwater aquifers,
especially around the coast. The inflow of seawater harms agricultural lands and
contaminates supplies of water for human consumption, Warming change-
driven spikes in temperature significantly enhance the need for water in many
different sectors, making
Egypt's already serious water
shortage problems severe. As
temperatures rise, less
precipitation occurs. As shown
in figure 22, from soil and
water surfaces, requiring more
irrigation to maintain crop
yields in agriculture, which
consumes around 80% of
Egypt's freshwater Figure 22: shows the decreasing of precipitation related with increasing temperature
resources. For example,
Egypt's food security depends on essential crops like rice and wheat, needing
more water during extended heat waves, placing an extra strain on the Nile's
limited water supply. Also, high temperatures in the industrial sector heighten
the requirement for water-intensive cooling techniques in manufacturing
facilities and power plants. To avoid excessive heat, thermal power plants, for
instance, would require more water, which would further reduce the resources
already available. Personal water use grows as well during hotter times due to
individuals consuming more water to stay hydrated and use more water for
cooling activities like running air conditioning systems, which frequently use
water-based cooling technology.
Inefficient water use
Egypt's difficulties concerning lack of water are mainly made harder by
wasteful water use. The significant water loss in the drinking water distribution
systems is one of the main issues. Such inconsistencies result in the loss of
nearly 29.7% of the total quantity of drinking water produced, or 9.3 billion
cubic meters per year. This is according to 2016 research by the Drinking Water
and Sanitation Statistics organization. The decline not only lowers the amount
of water that is available, but it also risks efforts to efficiently manage the
nation's limited water supplies.
The Nile River, Egypt's primary water source, faces significant challenges
due to backfilling of its extensive network of waterways and increasing
encroachments along its banks. These issues threaten the river's health and the
country's water security. Backfilling describes a way of depositing materials
into the paths of a river, resulting in decreased navigability and water flow.
Environmental sedimentation or caused by human actions like building and
poor garbage disposal could lead to this process. The accumulation of sediment
and rubbish reduces the river's ability to keep up with industry, agriculture, and
everyday human needs by narrowing streams and hindering water flow.
Backfilling has the potential to change a river's trajectory over time, damage
aquatic ecosystems, and raise the possibility of flooding during times of heavy.
Impacts
Closer ratio of consumed and produced water
The number of Egyptians has been growing significantly over the last few
decades, which has resulted in a sharp decline in the amount of water available
per person. The population increased from 27 million to over 100 million
between 1960 and 2020, leading to a
reduction in the per capita water supply to
a quarter of its pre-inflation level. The demand for water has increased due to
this demographic rise in a number of areas, such as industry, agriculture, and
individual consumption. The whole country is under more water stress as a
result of the growing water needs for irrigation and household use to meet rising
food demands. Egypt now receives less than 500 cubic meters of clean water
each citizen year, placing the country in the water poverty stage as the ratio
between water consumption and water production is imbalanced and tends to be
a fraction of less a bit than 1, As shown in figure 23.
food security
Causes
Arid areas
Arid areas are one of the main causes for agricultural inactivity,
furthermore, research shows that only 4% of Egypt’s land is occupied by the
population, while the remaining land is deserted. Arid areas hurt the nearby soil,
reducing its ability. They are also responsible for great differences in weather
between night and day cycles, which affects all of the populated regions, the
industrial regions, and the agricultural fields.
Impacts
Limited market opportunities
Poverty can have a profound impact on market demand by limiting
consumers' purchasing power, which can lead to a restricted domestic market
demand. Additionally, farmers may be discouraged from adopting modern
techniques and investing in agricultural productivity enhancements. In essence,
poverty constrains market opportunities by limiting the purchasing power of
consumers, which can lead to low demand for products from industrial
enterprises, ultimately hindering the development of the industrial sector.
Due to the high amount of HMs, they trigger hazardous diseases in Egyptians,
such as liver and kidney damage,
skin disorders, cognitive
Figure 32: the HMs at Rosetta Nile Branch in different sites
impairment, and even cancer. In Gohar, M. E., Ali, M. H., & El-Sayed, S. M. (2019). Heavy metals contents in Nasser Lake and the
Nile River, Egypt: An overview. The Egyptian Journal of Aquatic Research, 45(4), 301–312.
Egypt, the incidence attained about https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejar.2019.12.002
Positive consequences
Improving water equality
The water condition at Rosetta Nile Branch is considered poor, not potable
for drinking, and unhealthy. It causes many diseases such as Women's cancer as
the incidence attained about 37.5% of total cancer cases among Egyptian
females due to Heavy metals. If water improves and removes all pollutants like
HMs, TDS, and Microorganisms that cause hazardous diseases, the water will
be potable. Hence, the people in El-Rahawy, Tala, and Kafr El-Zayat will find
rich-condition water for drinking, and the pollutants won’t affect the
inhabitants’ lives.
Depletion of the number of patients
The lower Egypt, Delta, is considered a good condition place for agriculture.
Especially at the Rosetta Nile Branch. However, the production of agricultural
products has depleted due to using wastewater that contains pollutants
decreasing its fertility and eroding its products. If the water has been treated in
the Rosetta Nile Branch, El-Rahawy, Tala, and Kafr El-Zayat, the agricultural
products will be enhanced.
Negative consequences
Economic Costs:
Figure 34: the salts that are left behind in the surface
and as we go down in depth the salinity decreased, and that’s because at first,
all layers are equally likely to have the same percentage of salinity, but once
the evaporation process starts occurring the only pure water flowing above
such as volatile and but before the water goes above to sky its dissolved salts
become less lifted on the surface of solid satisfying this equation 1: H₂O
(liquid) → H₂O (vapor) + dissolved salts (residue)
but the salts are not constant or even stable, so some of these gradually
infiltrate deeply into the soil and as the surface was the salt resourced. so, for
that reason, it is the saltiest layer, and then goes down it decreases in salinity.
This process, known as salinization, which creates salts could be seen on the
above crusts on the soil surface, which makes the soil less fertile and, in
severe cases, unsuitable for agriculture and then lack agricultural products.
Ion exchanges
The reversible shift of ions between the solid phase of soil and the soil
solution is known as ion exchange. Positively charged ions (cations) like
calcium (Ca²⁺), magnesium (Mg²⁺), potassium (K⁺), and sodium (Na ⁺) get
attracted to and kept by negative charge locations found in soil particles,
mainly clay minerals and organic matter. For soil fertility and structure, these
cations' content and balance are essential.
Through cation exchange reactions, sodium can substitute other required
cations in soils exposed to high concentrations of sodium ions, which often
happens by salinity irrigation water or seawater intrusion like
2Na⁺ + Ca²⁺ (soil) → 2Na⁺ (soil) + Ca²⁺
One calcium ion adsorbed on the soil particle is replaced in this reaction by
two sodium ions in the soil solution. Since calcium is essential for
maintaining soil particle grouping, this displacement results in a decline of
the soil's structure. Too much sodium distributes soil particles, decreasing
permeability and porosity, which limits root growth and water infiltration.
Seawater intrusion
Heavy metals
Heavy metals are naturally occurring metals, and the reason is called Heavy
mainly latent on its size which is usually 5 times greater than water in weight
and density. They are not fully advantageous, but they have a dangerous
negative impact on the environment, Heavy metal contamination in aquatic
systems is a major problem because of its toxicity, bioaccumulation, and
persistence. the following resources of Heavy metals tell us the different types:
Wastewater containing metals like lead, cadmium, mercury, and arsenic is
released into water bodies by industries like extraction, melting, electroplating,
and manufacturing. Surface waters are exposed to high levels of heavy metals
as a result of these activities.
Figure 37-A: The Figure 37-B: the Figure 37-C: The Figure 37-D: The
carbon has been settled Methylene-blue contaminated water final version of
out as a layer right solution is putted in interacting with purified water after
down. burette activated carbon and bypassing activated
bypassing it. carbon
activated carbon reacts with what makes the water Blue and gets it to stick in its
pores leaving the water mostly purified, As shown in figure 37-D.
Figure 38: shows the four lines responsible for the filtration
capacity reaching 500,000 m3 water/day, but a few years after its implantation
and construction, it updated to have a capacity of 2 Million m3 water/day
according to (New Cairo Operation and Maintenance of the Raw Water
Intake, Boosters, Transmission Lines and Water Purification Plant – ICAT,
n.d.). The implementation cost for the New Cairo water station project is 40
Million dollars. It can supply the water for the whole of New Cairo City and the
Administrative New Capital City, having a population of 5 million inhabitants.
The plant uses four traditional lines for water and sediment treatment. Each
integrated process is part of the water treatment line and will always include
four lines or more, as shown in Figure 38.
Each pipe has a diameter equal to 2.2 meters, and its length reaches 30 km. As a
result, it can meet drainage needs; precise combing and sterilization tools will
be carried out in the final process. Sediment treatment will be done through the
organic conversion process. Consequently, it provides an environmentally
friendly and affordable water purification plant for New Cairo and its provinces
to cover the current and future population growth.
Mechanism
The New Cairo Water Station Project relies mainly on the biological and
mechanical filtration process as it is
classified into stages, which are
Pretreatment, primary (mechanical),
secondary (biological), and The third
Sludge treatment. Firstly, the
pretreatment works on a screening
system, a regretting and degreasing unit,
and a flowmeter, as shown in Figure
39. After the pretreatment, the water is
Figure 39: shows the pretreatment process.
examined to know which pollutants it
has. Then, The primary (mechanical) treatment with decanters is designed to
remove gross, suspended, and floating solids from raw sewage. The so-called
sedimentation process is based on density differences. Secondary (biological)
treatment is designed to remove the dissolved organic matter that escapes
primary treatment. This is achieved by microbes consuming organic matter as
food and converting it to carbon dioxide, water, and energy for their growth and
reproduction. The third treatment uses a microscreening process initially and
later chloride treatment for disinfection. Sludge treatment consists of a gravity
thickener and a flotation thickener tank, together with a high-load anaerobic
digester and a low-load digester. Finally, The biogas line has a gasholder and a
torch. There is an auxiliary emergency fuel-generator system to cover electricity
demand in case of operational or source problems. The most important features
of the New Cairo WWTP are the following: Water line including fine solids
screening (four automatic screens, 1.50 m wide and with a pass of 6 mm),
primary clarifiers (four units, 50 m in diameter and 3.60 m high), biological
reactor (six units each with a volume of 14,580 m³), secondary settling tank (six
units, 55 m in diameter and 5 m high), micro screen (10 textile mesh filters
1,374.37m³/h) and disinfection by chlorine (two chambers with a volume of
1,395 m³). • Sludge line with primary sludge screening (2 + 1 rotary screens,
each with a capacity of 110 m³ per hour), thickening of primary sludge (three
gravity units, 16 m in diameter and 4.80 m high), thickening of excess sludge
(three flotation thickeners, 15 m in diameter and 3 m high), anaerobic digestion
(four units, each with a volume of 12,076 m³).
Points of Strengths
The high quality of water:
The New Cario Water Station helps in getting rid of many pollutants
deposited into the river, leads to human public health improvement as the
agriculture drains and domestic sewage, especially in Delta and Cairo, produce
too many pollutants like heavy metals HMs with high concentrations reaching
the above baseline of these pollutants according to WHO, which causes too
many diseases to the inhibitors in Cairo and Delta, but after implantation of the
project, this percentage of HMs is decreased slightly as the project success in
filtering the water and producing about 2,000,000 m 3 potable water/ day. As a
consequence, the number of deaths is also reduced.
Agricultural:
Points of weaknesses
Economic conditions
Although the new Cairo water station had significant strength in the filtration
of water from containments like sediment and Heavy metals HMs, the cost of its
construction is too much effort as it wouldn’t be built due to its immense cost.
Firstly, 40 Million dollars was paid to the institutions of the public and private
sectors in Egypt responsible for the construction. However, during the
development of the project and improving it, it cost 100 million dollars
additionally. Hence, This financial framework limited the pressure on public
finances during the construction years, according to (“THE NEW CAIRO WASTEWATER
TREATMENT PLANT (EGYPT)” n.d.).
Since the project was implemented in New Cairo as there are some
inhabitants in the location were forced to leave their houses to build the project,
which led to a revolution that ended with some undesirable political conditions
like President Hosni Mubarak’s ousting after almost 30 years in power. On June
30th, 2012, Mohamed Morsi, the leader of the Freedom and Justice Party, was
elected president of Egypt, a position he held until July 3rd, 2013, when he was
succeeded by General Abdel Fattah el-Sisi according to (“THE NEW CAIRO
WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT (EGYPT),” n.d.).
Points of strengths
Effective Reuse of Water
By purifying agricultural drainage water and reusing it for irrigation, the
plant makes significant contributions to water conservation. This reduces the
scarcity of water, which is particularly important in arid areas like the New
Delta.
Reduction of Salinity
By using reverse osmosis, the desalination process guarantees that the salt
content of the water decreases to acceptable levels, avoiding soil salinization,
which is common in many irrigated areas.
Points of weaknesses
High Operational Costs
These procedures require regular upkeep, specific substances for
membrane cleaning, and an enormous energy input. In addition, pumps with
high pressure are needed for the procedure to push water through semi-
permeable membranes, which can require energy. The cost of maintaining these
systems is increased by the requirement for skilled workers and specialized
tools. In addition, if operating costs increase over time as a result of changes in
energy prices or the requirement for expensive replacement devices, the plant
could face difficulties. In the absence of government subsidies, grants, or
additional funding sources for covering these costs, this may make it more
difficult for the plant to continue operating profitably.
Energy Intensive
Significant amounts of energy are used by the plant's operations, especially
reverse osmosis. Water must be forced through RO membranes using high-
pressure systems, which require a constant and dependable energy source. A
large environmental impact and greenhouse gas emissions could hurt the
environment if the energy originates from fossil fuels. Because the system is
power-intensive, if the energy used to operate the plant does not come from
renewable sources like solar or wind, the environmental benefits of the plant
can be offset. The treatment plant's overall sustainability may be at risk in
regions like the New Delta, where electricity may be limited or costly unless
improvements in energy efficiency or cleaner energy sources are integrated into
the design. Excessive energy use results in more operating costs and The
treatment plant's overall environmental advantages are limited by its
environmental impact.
Dependency on non-renewable energy sources eventually makes the system
unsustainable.
Complex Maintenance
The implementation of modern equipment in the treatment plant, including
membrane filtration, the process of reverse osmosis, and electrodialysis,
requires extremely skilled operation and maintenance. Due to their sensitivity,
these systems require constant upkeep, cleaning, and repair. For instance, RO
membranes can be expensive to repair and require routine cleaning to avoid
fouling. Over time, devices used in complex systems for filtering need complex
maintenance due to damage from use. To run and maintain these technologies,
the station also needs skilled workers. It may be challenging to find and keep
skilled workers in remote locations, which could cause shortages and delays in
important maintenance. The factory may experience inefficiencies, higher
operating costs, or even system breakdowns if the necessary knowledge is not
easily available. Greater costs as a result of bringing in and instructing more
expert personnel. Potential operating problems that impact irrigation and water
treatment plans if skilled workers are unavailable. Problems with sustainability
during time if maintenance is not properly managed.
Mechanism
Beach filtration is a natural pre-treatment process that improves seawater
quality for desalination by utilizing the natural permeability of coastal
sediments to exclude suspended solids, organic pollutants, and microorganisms
with minimal chemical pre-treatment, thus maximizing the efficiency of the RO
system. The process begins with the installation of vertical beach wells along
the shoreline at specific points engineered to take advantage of natural
percolation. Seawater percolates through sand and gravel beds before entering
the wells. As the water moves through these sediments, it undergoes multiple
filtration processes:
Mechanical Filtration: Suspended solids and sediments are physically
filtered out by permeable layers, reducing turbidity and lowering the Silt
Density Index (SDI) from about 4.4 in open seawater intake systems to less than
1. This prevents membrane clogging and reduces maintenance expenses.
Chemical Filtration: As the water contacts minerals in the sediment,
dissolved organic matter, impurities, and heavy metals are absorbed, stabilizing
the water composition before entering the desalination plant.
Biological Filtration: Microbial activity within the sediment layers
breaks down organic contaminants and kills bacterial pathogens, naturally
disinfecting the water and reducing biofouling potential within RO membranes,
thereby extending their lifespan. These filtration processes significantly enhance
feedwater quality, reducing the need for chemicals, lowering operational
expenses, and ensuring more effective and stable RO desalination operations.
However, beach filtration has site-specific limitations related to sediment
characteristics, permeability, and variations in aquifer connectivity, which can
impact overall system performance. Another major issue is the progressive rise
in coastal aquifer salinity due to continuous pumping.
Over 20 years, the total dissolved solids (TDS) concentration can rise
from 34,000–35,000 mg/L to 45,000 mg/L, reducing desalination efficiency and
necessitating additional treatment. To mitigate these risks, sustainable
management practices must be implemented, including continuous water quality
assessment, well maintenance, sediment flushing, and optimization of extraction
rates. Additionally, the upfront infrastructure cost for installing beach wells,
including drilling and maintenance, can be high, requiring careful planning and
investment. Despite these challenges, the long-term benefits of beach filtration
—such as reduced chemical dependency, enhanced environmental protection,
and greater desalination efficiency—justify the initial investment. Compared to
conventional open seawater intake systems, which are more prone to fouling,
require extensive chemical treatment, and have a larger environmental footprint,
beach filtration is a more sustainable and cost-effective alternative for coastal
desalination facilities. By selecting optimal sites, planning infrastructure
efficiently, and conducting regular maintenance, beach filtration can maximize
desalination efficiency, reduce operational costs, and promote long-term
freshwater production with minimal environmental impact.
Points of Strengths
Improved Water Quality and Reduced Fouling
Seawater filtration significantly enhances feedwater quality by removing
suspended solids, organic fouling agents, and microbial contaminants. The Silt
Density Index (SDI) is reduced from around 4.4 in conventional open seawater
intake systems to below 1. Lower SDI results in fewer particulates passing
through RO membranes, reducing the risk of fouling, scaling, and biofilm
formation. This minimizes membrane cleaning frequency, extends membrane
lifespan, and reduces maintenance costs while improving desalination
efficiency.
Lower Operational and Maintenance Costs
Beach filtration naturally pre-treats seawater before it enters desalination
plants, reducing the need for sophisticated mechanical and chemical pre-
treatment. Since the process provides cleaner feedwater with a lower SDI,
membrane fouling is minimized, resulting in fewer cleanings, lower
maintenance costs, and prolonged membrane life. Beach wells and infiltration
galleries are less sensitive to algal blooms and seasonal water quality
fluctuations, improving system stability and freshwater production efficiency.
Over time, reduced energy consumption, chemical usage, and maintenance
requirements make beach filtration a more cost-effective and sustainable
desalination method, especially in high-water-demand regions.
Reduced Chemical Usage and Environmental Impact
Beach filtration eliminates the need for many chemical pre-treatments,
such as coagulants, disinfectants, and anticalins, which are typically used in
conventional seawater intake systems. Lower chemical usage results in lower
operating costs and minimizes the risk of chemical pollution in marine
environments.
The process reduces toxic brine discharge, lessening its impact on marine
life and helping preserve coastal biodiversity by avoiding excessive chlorine,
biocides, and other harmful substances. By creating a cleaner and more
environmentally friendly water treatment process, beach filtration improves the
sustainability of desalination systems.
Points of Weakness
Geological Limitations and Performance Variability
The efficiency of beach filtration depends on the coastal area’s geological
characteristics, including sediment permeability, grain size, and stability. If
sediments are too fine or clay-rich, infiltration rates can be low, limiting natural
filtration efficiency. If sediments are too coarse, dissolved organic matter and
fine particulates may pass through without adequate removal, reducing filtration
effectiveness. Poor well positioning or over-extraction may cause saltwater
intrusion, leading to aquifer contamination and long-term system sustainability
issues.
Risk of Salinity Buildup and Aquifer Contamination
Continuous seawater infiltration can gradually increase the total dissolved
solids (TDS) concentration in coastal aquifers, potentially reducing pre-treated
water quality. In prolonged use, TDS concentrations can rise from 34,000–
35,000 mg/L to above 45,000 mg/L, requiring additional treatment to remain
effective for desalination. Industrial and urban pollution near coastlines can
introduce hydrocarbons, heavy metals, and other contaminants into aquifers,
necessitating further monitoring and pre-treatment.
High Initial Infrastructure and Maintenance Costs
Constructing beach wells requires extensive site surveys, geological
assessments, and engineering expertise. Drilling, building filtration plants, and
installing monitoring devices can be costly compared to traditional open
seawater intake systems. Maintenance is necessary to prevent sediment
clogging, biofouling, and reduced infiltration efficiency, requiring regular
sediment flushing and cleaning. Coastal erosion and seasonal variations in
sediment movement may also affect system performance, necessitating
additional engineering controls. Despite these challenges, beach filtration
remains a viable and sustainable solution for improving desalination efficiency
while minimizing environmental impact.
Mechanism
Membrane filtration to pure water is one of the most effective methods of
removing impurities from water. It is achieved by passing water through a semi-
permeable membrane, which removes impurities and allows pure water to pass
through. It is used widely in Egypt for wastewater treatment and providing
clean drinking water. The principle of selective permeability regulates the
membrane filtration process. Small pores in the membrane will allow water
molecules to pass through and block other larger particles, bacteria, and viruses.
It is based on the membrane type used where different filtration processes can
be carried out. These include microfiltration, ultrafiltration, nanofiltration, and
reverse osmosis. Microfiltration and ultrafiltration entail the application of
larger pore membranes, typically between 0.1 and 0.01 microns. Microfiltration
and ultrafiltration can remove suspended solids, bacteria, and some viruses.
Ultrafiltration can also remove small impurities, such as proteins and colloids.
The process is mainly applied at the initial stages before more complicated
stages of purification are used. Reverse osmosis and nanofiltration employ still
smaller pore-sized membranes, typically less than 0.001 microns in size.
Nanofiltration removes small organic compounds, dissolved salts, and hardness
constituents and is thus best suited for softening of water and desalination of
water. The most advanced method of membrane filtration, reverse osmosis,
removes all dissolved salts, heavy metals, and poisonous contaminants,
producing highly purified water. Pressure filtration pushes water through the
membrane and forces out impurities. The forced-out impurities are expelled by
forcing them out, thus preventing clogging and increasing membrane efficiency.
Fouling of the membrane by particle deposition in the long term can degrade
performance. Cleaning by regular cleaning, for instance, washing in sodium
hypochlorite solutions, preserves membrane life and efficiency. Energy
consumption is yet another parameter of membrane filtration. Microfiltration
and ultrafiltration involve quite low pressures, but nanofiltration and reverse
osmosis require high pressures, and hence energy is more expensive.
Development in membrane technology is aimed at reducing energy
consumption and increasing the membrane's life so that the process is
economical. Membrane bioreactors (MBRs) combine membrane filtration and
biological treatment to enhance wastewater treatment.
Microorganisms in MBR break down organic pollutants before membrane
filtration, which removes the remaining impurities. The integrated process
yields high-quality effluent that can be utilized for irrigation and industry.
Membrane filtration in Egypt has proved to be a successful way of managing
water scarcity and pollution. It is a sustainable technology for wastewater
treatment and drinking water quality improvement. The technology is, however,
prone to operational challenges such as membrane fouling and excessive cost,
but research has not stopped identifying ways to improve efficiency and cost-
effectiveness.
Overall, membrane filtration is a critical water purification technology,
utilizing selective permeability to strain out impurities. Depending on different
filtration procedures, the process offers clean and safe water for various
applications.
Points of strengths
High-quality Effluent production:
Points of weaknesses
High Capital and Operational Costs
The investment for MBR is high, as it is related to the high cost of special
machines and their associated equipment. The operation cost is also relatively
low because most of it comes from energy-demanding operations to sustain
transmembrane pressure and periodic membrane cleaning procedures. This cost
may pose a great limitation for the large-scale application of MBR systems in
low-resource countries, such as some regions of Egypt. The practice still
endeavors to reduce costs by upgrading technology and economies of scale,
although it is a key consideration.
Membrane Fouling and Maintenance Challenges:
The selected solution should have the maximum efficiency possible. This
can be done by focusing on maximizing the filtration of containment acquired
from water Heavy metals (HMs), Total Dissolved Solids (TDSs), and
Microorganisms like Vibrio Cholera The selected prototype must also be easy to
be scaled up in size by a definite number. This allows for an increase in water
filtration if the solution is implemented in real life.
User experience
First, the solution design should follow the safety rules for the user. This
can feature using non-toxic materials or well-isolating the hazardous substance
that sifts the containment of water. The design of the prototype should be also
easy to use by the targeted audience, which can be done by minimal design and
providing clear instructions for using the prototype.
Design Requirements
The prototype should eliminate the containment in the water, Heavy
metals HMs, Total Dissolved Solids TDS, and microorganisms, at least (90)%,
as the threshold value of salinity becomes less than 500 Part Per Million PPM,
in the water sample (5) to (6) liters within (10) Minutes. In addition, The
materials should function at least at (80)% of their original efficiency after
being exposed to polluted water for 5 cycles to ensure that the solution can
preserve its performance over time and for a long period of use besides that the
materials should be from the nature or wasted-driven materials to deplete the
cost of the prototype. The system should also work automatically without any
human interlapping as the system should be controlled by two water gates to get
the water out or in according to its threshold level.
Selection of Solution
The solution for the management of the pollution and potential health
hazards caused by agriculture drainage and domestic sewage at Rosetta Nile
Branch is electrocoagulation, membrane filter, and disinfection. Firstly, the
water containing all pollutants, HMs, TDS, and microorganisms passed through
a chamber that contains two electrodes made from Iron Fe connected to a DC
source, so these electrodes undergo to electrolysis process. At the anode, the
iron is oxidized and forms iron ions as shown in Equation (x)
+2 −¿ ¿
Fe Oxidation Fe + 2 e
→
The ferrous ion reacts with hydroxide and forms Iron. Π hydroxide as shown
in Equation (x)
+2 −1
Fe +2 OH → Fe (OH )2
Iron Π Hydroxide acts as an efficient coagulant for ions (heavy metals) and
colloids (organic and inorganic) are primarily held in solutions by electrical
charges according to Alena Tetreault and EC Pacific Pty Ltd (2003). As it is
destabilized by the addition of ions of the charge opposite that of containments.
As a result of this reaction, immense sludges are formed at the bottom of the
chamber where the reaction occurred. To get rid of these sludges, a membrane
filter having small particles and pores, which the sludges can’t permit through
it, is used. Then the water undergoes some rays, ultraviolet rays, for disinfection
to ensure the elimination of the pathogens that are responsible for waterborne
diseases.
The main materials of the solution are 20 electrodes, 10 for anodes and 10
for cathodes, which are positioned vertically with equal gaping between them to
cover the total area, and these electrodes are connected to a power supply equal
having 50 volts and 100 amperes. After treatment of the raw water from its
containments like HMs, TDS, microorganisms, and colloids (organic and
inorganic), the water is moved to another chamber by using a water pump
circulation passing through a membrane filter to drain the water from the
formed sludges, and to ensure the water is dissolved, the sand and gravel dunes
are used. Finally, the water moves forward some ultraviolet rays for the
disinfection process.
Selection of Prototype
the plastic box represents the main pollution of agricultural drains and
domestic sewage, and then the water is transported to another plastic box
through PVC tubes to another plastic box where the first stage of filtration
occurs electrocoagulation. Here, two electrodes with (10) cm Height (5) cm and
made from Iron Fe are connected to a DC source. Hence, the water undergoes to
electrolysis process in which the iron is oxidized into a Ferrous II Fe +2 at the
anode. While at the cathode, the water is electrolyzed into Hydrogen gas H 2 and
Hydroxide Ion OH-. The Ferrous II Fe+2 reacts with Hydroxide Ion OH- and
forms Fe(OH)2. Iron(II) hydroxide is an effective coagulant for Heavy Metals
(HMs), TDS, and microorganisms. Then the water is transmitted into another
plastic box by using an electronic pump automatically. The water passes
through two filter membranes: filter paper and gravel membrane to ensure
removing the water from the sludge formed from electrocoagulation. Finally,
the water will pass through the third plastic box. In the third plastic box, the
water is filtered from pathogenic microorganisms by disinfection using
ultraviolet rays from an LED lamp. The water is transmitted to check the plastic
box to find the threshold value of pollutants. If it is above the baseline 500
PPM, the water will undergo to same filtration process again until reaching to
the baseline