White Paper Color Management For Digital Label Presses
White Paper Color Management For Digital Label Presses
COLOR MANAGEMENT
FOR DIGITAL LABEL
PRESSES
2
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
Contents
Introduction 3
Brand challenges 5
Profiling 7
Conclusion 13
Glossary 14
3
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
Introduction
Digital presses require front ends that can provide accurate color management
that is adapted to the specific characteristics of each model. This white paper
explains the challenges and opportunities presented by the inks or toners and color
reproduction of the different common digital print processes used in these sectors.
It also explains how Global Graphics’ Harlequin® products offer sophisticated color
management tools to press developers and end users.
A Glossary with notes on the concepts is provided at the end.
Recent years have seen a rapid growth in the adoption of digital printing processes for commercial
production of labels, and a surge in development of digital presses for various sectors of packaging.
There has been a proliferation of different digital processes and ink or toner types. This is leading
to a need for new technologies for accurate management of color in a variety of new workflows.
“Conventional” non-digital processes such as flexography, offset lithography, gravure and screen
processes are long established. The workflows from original file through color separation, screening,
plate/cylinder/screen and press are often designed to match widely used international standards for
media, ink and print colors.
Digital printing processes are still being developed and refined from year to year, with considerable
ongoing potential for further improvement in speed, quality, tonal range, gamut size and media
type supported. At present this diversity means that there is far less uniformity of results and the
international standardization processes have not yet completely caught up with the potential of
digital print for label & packaging.
For this reason it is particularly vital for the front end software that controls color and screening to
obtain not only the optimum quality from a particular printing press, but where necessary to modify
the results so the color will match existing processes and standards.
Global Graphics has more than thirty years’ experience in developing industry-leading front end
software for conventional pre-press film and plate making systems. For half of that time it has also
been developing these for digital production printing systems. This includes a lot of knowledge and
experience in generating halftone screens and managing color.
This expertise with color management knowledge is particularly important as Global Graphics is
offering its systems to OEMs in the digital press markets for label & packaging.
4
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
• toner for high-end labels for which offset would traditionally be used
• UV inkjet for industrial labels that would have historically been printed using flexography
• aqueous inkjet for corrugated board that would use offset for medium to long runs, etc.
This alignment is not necessarily permanent, however, and may well change as press technology
develops further. As an example, most folding carton and flexible packaging presses in production
use at this time use liquid toner, mainly because Indigo was the first vendor to bring production
quality presses to the mass market. It seems very unlikely that inkjet will not make some progress
here as well.
Single-pass inkjet
At present the predominant liquid toner label presses on the market are HP Indigo models. These
are the most commonly used high productivity digital label printers worldwide.
More traditional electrophotography (i.e. dry toner) is used by Xeikon at the high productivity end
of the commercial labels market, and it is fairly common in low volume presses, such as those based
on engines from Oki Data. Xeikon claims to be number 2 in terms of worldwide digital label press
installations, and has recently added liquid toner presses.
Single-pass inkjet, almost always used with UV-cured inks, is used by the majority of label inkjet press
models available today, even though sales numbers in higher volume sectors of individual brands so
far are lower than the HP Indigo or Xeikon presses, largely because this is a newer technology. The
same single-pass approach is also being used in various UV and aqueous inkjet presses for folding
carton and corrugated board; use in flexibles is likely to come soon.
Single-pass means that the print heads are fixed, and the substrate moves past them. The substrate
can be either sheet-fed or as a web on a roll. Single-pass is used primarily because it can be much
faster than the multiple-pass technology often used in the wide format market. Web-fed presses
can usually achieve higher printing speeds than sheet-fed, commonly up to around 85m/min for UV
Inkjet or 300m/min for aqueous. But web-fed presses may not fit as well into the supply chain or
integrate so well with converting processes for certain packaging segments such as folding carton
in small to medium companies, especially for very short run custom products.
5
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
Additional ink types are used for inkjet printing in other print sectors, such as oil-based or latex. To
date the variety of ink types used in label & packaging is fairly limited, but it’s perfectly possible that
this will change in the future.
Just as for conventional print, the profitability of runs of very small numbers of labels or packages
depends hugely on significantly reducing wastage of time and materials in preparing the press for
the next job. An hour’s wash-up and make-ready on a flexo press, taking a couple of hundred feet
of media, might be acceptable when the job will then run on press for several days. As jobs, or
versions, etc, lead to shorter and shorter press runs it’s becoming common for the shortest jobs to
be on press for a few minutes, meaning that many more jobs must be turned round in every shift.
Minimizing the time to switch from one job to the next and automation of the entire supply chain
are vital.
Brand challenges
Accurate reproduction of brand colors is particularly important in the label & packaging markets.
However, it is frequently not possible to achieve an exact match for a particular brand color using
the four-color process sets of inks (i.e. cyan, magenta, yellow and black, or CMYK), especially with
“conventional” non-digital offset or flexographic ink sets.
On a conventional press with standard inks the solution is to use extra ink colors that are specially
mixed to be exact matches for the brand colors and to use these either as spot colors or in a non-
standard process set.
For various technical and practical reasons, it is rarely possible to use special colors on digital
presses. One reason is the cost of making a special ink, which is much higher than for conventional
offset or flexographic inks. Another problem that particularly applies to inkjets is the difficulty and
expense of cleaning out the ink feed lines and print heads if you need to change between different
special colors frequently.
Because inkjet inks are not subject to the same historical limitations (or standards) as offset and
flexo presses, it is common for them to show greater purity in the CMYK process colors.This means
that even a UV-cured CMYK inkjet press will often be able to cover a wider color gamut than is
possible with CMYK offset or flexo inks. Aqueous inkjets have their own challenges which tend to
limit the achievable tone range and gamut, but this can be mitigated by selecting the appropriate
substrates or pre-coating.
6
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
In practical terms an extended gamut means that a greater number of brand colors can be matched
satisfactorily. “HiFi color” was coined in the 1990s as a generic term for the concept of achieving
an extended gamut in print. More recently the term “extended gamut” or “expanded gamut”,
abbreviated to XG or XCG (extended color gamut) has become more popular.
One of the primary value propositions for a digital press is its ability to handle shorter run lengths
and avoid wastage of time or materials; being able to address many brand colors without washing
up the press and changing inks is a vital part of responding to that opportunity. This is where an
extended gamut ink set comes into its own, in allowing accurate emulation of a larger proportion
of brand colors.
Another recent addition to toner based label printer capabilities is a clear toner option. Designers
will need to be made aware of this feature to be able to incorporate it into their designs but so far
sample labels have been impressive. A cold can of beer with water droplets on it can be made to
look as if the final label is actually wet. Another example is highlighting certain images with a clear
coat.
Metallic inks are available with some large format inkjets and for some UV-cured inkjet presses, but
at the time of writing they are not yet widely used. Note that so-called “digital foiling” tends to be
used to describe a model where cold foil is applied in finishing, guided by the use of specific colors
in the printed piece, rather than actually applying the foil on press.
7
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
The Harlequin ColorPro™ color management system delivers accurate and optimal use of the
printer’s gamut.The color is calculated within the RIP and the output raster from the RIP is delivered
in the most appropriate format for the press.
Global Graphics provides expertise, documentation and other assistance in the final encoding of
the raster delivered so that it can be stored, post-processed and/or forwarded to the printer
controller for delivery to the marking engine (laser/drum for EP presses or heads for inkjet presses)
as efficiently as possible.
Profiling
Output profiles must be built on sound color science principles to produce color accurate proofs
or final print color gamuts.
Accurate and reproducible color printing is only possible if a color profile is created to describe
the actual output achieved by that press for a given combination of ink, substrate, screening and
resolution, and if the color produced by the press is stable. Global Graphics supplies a wizard-
based color utility called Harlequin SetGold™ that is designed to prepare a press for profiling by
establishing an optimal “Golden State.”
By setting gray balance and ink limiting separately from the process of creating an ICC color profile
Harlequin SetGold ensures that the final color reproduction is more stable as environmental
variables such as humidity and temperature change slightly in the press room.
A gray balanced profile is the first step in building an output profile for a new printing device. This
procedure, guided by an informative GUI, can determine the correct inking & gray balance and
correct the tone scale values for a new device. This important step improves profile accuracy and
avoids over-inking and is often overlooked.
8
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
This “Golden State” is then captured and calibration tables can be created for several color
measurement device types and/or measurement systems, such as density, %dot, Status-T, Status-A
etc, so that any non-reference printer can be adjusted to this “Golden State” using single-channel
calibration curves, without requiring a full re-profiling. This means that profiles made by the OEM
in their color labs on their test presses can be used on a press installed in the field and still be
reasonably color accurate straight out of the packing crate.
Gray Balance
Alignment of press color output with measurements of color neutrality also ensures that the output
of neutral colors in a print is more robust with variations in media and ink/toner colors, caused by
temperature or humidity changes, for example. This means that colors intended to be neutral are
more likely to remain visually neutral. In the same way, in-production color variation can be more
easily adjusted for with a lightweight calibration process that can be completed quickly and easily
without expensive equipment.
The OEM, press vendor or integrator can use Harlequin SetGold, Global Graphic’s wizard-based
color utility, to place a press in an appropriate golden state, or to develop standardized golden state
profiles that are shipped pre-installed in DFEs for all presses.The end user can then use off-the-shelf
profiling software, safe in the knowledge that they cannot over-ink the press even while printing test
forms for profile creation.
Of course, one challenge is that the optimal ink limit can vary significantly with the substrate in use.
A very low ink limit is probably required for a very lightweight, uncoated stock; but applying that
same low limit to a heavier, coated stock will reduce the achievable color gamut and tonal contrast,
in other words, degrade the color quality. A variety of ink limits may therefore be required for
different media.
9
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
This is important because one requirement for at least some label & packaging printing is to match
conventionally printed pieces. There are many reasons for that need, including:
• because some copies of the same product are produced conventionally and some digitally, and
the different print runs must match
• because the product is printed in a hybrid fashion, where some or most of the print is done
using a conventional press but additional imagery is added using a digital print head, either in-
line with conventional press stations or in a separate converting process
• because labels and packaging must match other uses of the same imagery, which may be
produced using conventional printing technologies, such as collateral and magazine advertising,
point-of sale, or even packaging or labels used for other products from the same brand
ICC profiles
Harlequin ColorPro includes the ability to use multiple ICC color profiles to specify the color
behavior of the digital press on which the jobs are being printed, and that of a conventional press
(or standard press characterization) that must be emulated.
To demonstrate this capability, Harlequin has been certified by Fogra against ISO 12647-7 (the
contract proofing standard) in matching no fewer than 7 standardized press characterizations.
This certification was performed on an Epson Stylus Pro 7890, which is clearly a more stable device
than a high-volume production press, but it is notable that Harlequin is the only Fogra contract proofing
certification achieved on an Epson printer to date with off-the-shelf Epson media and inks.
It’s unlikely that a production press would be stable enough to achieve contract proofing standard,
but the Harlequin certification demonstrates that Harlequin ColorPro can help an output device
deliver consistently accurate color; the only limitation is the stability of the device. Many production
presses can probably achieve 12647-8 (validation proof) certification.
10
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
When using a conventional press brand colors are usually achieved by using specially formulated spot
inks, but the use of custom colorants on digital devices is very rare because of their cost, the long
development time, and the difficulty of changing colors and cleaning ink/toner feed systems after use
without contamination of the next color, not to mention the wastage of time and material involved.
Pantone®
It’s been estimated that only around 40% of Pantone colors can be achieved using a standardized
CMYK space in conventional print (e.g. G7). The proportion that can be printed using CMYK
colorants on most digital presses is likely to be slightly larger than this. But that still leaves a significant
proportion of brand colors outside of the achievable gamut, whether they’re specified using Pantone
or not.
An extended gamut space using a larger number of colorants, such as CMYKOGV (i.e. CMYK + orange
+ green + violet), greatly increases the press gamut, and it’s been estimated that around 80% of Pantone
colors can be printed accurately in this way. That reduces the proportion of brand colors that can’t be
printed exactly from 50-60% down to 20%. It also reduces the reproduction error for that remainder,
because they are less far outside the achievable gamut of the press. Whether brand owners are willing
to accept the remaining discrepancy will vary between companies. Remember that most magazine
advertisements, often including brand colors, will be printed in CMYK on offset or gravure and will be
signed off by the brand owner, even though they will almost certainly vary more from the target color
than a carton or label printed using an extended gamut colorant set. But remember also that different
people within a brand sign off on the two!
11
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
Additional tables can be created for colors from other libraries and for custom colors, and entries
can be over-ridden if a brand owner wishes to adjust the reproduction of a color away from the
formal Pantone definition for any reason.
A brand color look-up table can be specified in a device independent color space (XYZ-D50),
so that the requisite color data is transformed through the appropriate output profile for the
press/media/colorant combination in use. This means that the same specification will produce an
appropriate emulation on every substrate because selecting the correct output color profile for that
substrate will ensure that the color is accurately transformed.
Alternatively, a brand color look-up table may be defined in the output color space of the digital
press, whether that’s CMYK or extended gamut. This allows for manual tweaking of the brand color
emulation to take advantage of every last corner of the gamut of a particular press, which can
sometimes be useful for brand colors that are right on the edge of that gamut.
Finally, look-up tables may also be defined to map from one separation name to another, e.g. to unify
the output where files from several sources are used together.
Of course, in those cases where the press is set up to print with real spot inks, either because they’re special
inks such as white, varnish, metallics etc; or because a spot ink has been specially formulated for a significant
print buyer, the Harlequin RIP can be configured to produce appropriate rasters for those colorants.
And technical separations such as die-lines, fold lines, live area indicators etc can be printed either alone
for lead-in sheets to check register, or with the graphical page content for proofing. In a production print
run the technical separations would normally be ignored completely so that they don’t knock out of
graphical content, even if an operator in the creation workflow didn’t set them to overprint.
12
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
Color space – what colorants are used for physical output. ColorPro can manage color in all output
color spaces that the Harlequin RIP can deliver data in:
• monochrome
• mono plus spots
• CMYK
• CMYK plus spots
• extended gamut spaces such as CMYKOG, CMYKOGV
• extended gamut spaces plus spots
• PhotoInk spaces, which use light variants of process inks in addition to the fully saturated inks
such as CcMmYKk to increase smoothness of gentle tonal graduations
• PhotoInk plus spots
Spots can include varnish, metallics and white colorants. Structural and other non-color separations
used in the supplied data file for die-lines and other technical (as opposed to color) usage can be
explicitly ignored or output separately.
The interleaving of the supplied colorants can be controlled, both in the delivery order, and in
whether the separations are delivered interleaved by pixel, by line, by band or by frame.
The Harlequin RIP can consume PostScript (including EPS), PDF and XPS as well as image formats such
as TIFF, JPEG etc. The ColorPro color management engine applies equally to all input formats, meaning
that only one integration is required to achieve consistent color management across all formats.
13
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
Conclusion
Digital printing has already altered the economics of label printing, and has started to make the
same changes for several segments of packaging printing. Very short runs, just-in-time ordering,
smaller inventories, frequently changed designs and some degree of variability, such as localization,
versioning or even just batch numbering on press are all feasible with costs-per-copy that end
customers are likely to accept. It’s still important, however, to ensure that you’re looking at the total
cost of printing, rather than cost per copy, when comparing digital to conventional print. Cost per
copy does not take account of wastage of excess inventory or the cost of warehousing etc.
However, brand color matching, as well as the requirement to achieve similar overall color
appearance to other printed and digital media, remain vital to the acceptance of digital printing
within this market.
The technical nature and economics of the primary digital press processes mitigate against specially
mixed inks to achieve brand colors. Extended gamut process ink sets are used instead.
This in turn requires high quality color management to achieve accurate color matches and
predictable colors that are consistent on the same press over time, as well as the ability to match
colors across different presses and even different print processes.
Global Graphics’ color management was originally launched in the mid-1990s and has been
continuously developed ever since, becoming more powerful, gaining additional features and
becoming an indispensable component of a digital production workflow. The technology is well
proven in the field and forms a key element in solutions from multiple digital press vendors.
Harlequin ColorPro is now an indispensable component of the Global Graphics Fundamentals technology
and engineering support package for building a DFE for a digital press for labels & packaging.
14
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
Color Gamut: If a job has already been separated for printing on a conventional (e.g. flexo) press,
The set of colors that can be physically printed by a combination of press, ink that may mean that it has been separated for a non-standard Process Color set.
and substrates. A larger gamut means that more brand colors can be printed This will often result in a file with graphic elements specified in a combination
accurately (see also Extended Gamut). of brand and other spot colors which must be re-separated to the digital press
colorants while RIPing. Fortunately Harlequin ColorPro is extremely good at
It’s also important to look at the shape of the gamut for a press, especially if it is emulating spot colors in the process colors of the digital press, even when they’re
to be used to emulate conventional press work, perhaps from a flexo press. Ideally used in combination, overprinted, or used together with live PDF transparency
the digital press gamut should completely enclose that of the flexo press, meaning (e.g. for a drop shadow).
that all colors that could be printed on the flexo press can be reproduced on
the digital press.
Color Space:
This is the technical term for a defined range of colors (or reference colors)
If the job was printed on a flexo press using a non-standard process ink set (in
within the theoretical whole of a color model such as RGB or CMYK. For instance
other words, not CMYK; perhaps replacing the Black with a Dark Blue because
sRGB or Pro Photo RGB are color spaces for original camera/scanner images,
that matches a brand color in the job) then the flexo gamut will also be non-
and these are subsets of the theoretical complete RGB color range (most often
standard and it may be harder to match such gamuts on a digital press.
described as CIE LAB, which itself is a subset based on the color sensitivity of the
average human visual system). Fogra 39 is a standardized CMYK subset, primarily
intended for offset printing. Color space is subtly different from gamut, which
describes the actual range of color values obtainable from a device in that a color
space includes the relationship between the numerical representation of a color
and its appearance.
15
COLOR MANAGEMENT FOR DIGITAL LABEL PRESSES
Colorant: Extra ink colors that are called spot or special colors are defined as separate
An ink or toner actually imaged on press. Individual colors defined in the channels or layers within the original digital image. The usual intent is that they
artwork for the job may be color separated to be printed as a build of colorants are printed as special colors on the press, although if this is not available on a
representing the process colors (e.g. images separated into CMYKOGV), or may digital press, they can be merged into a process color set by the color separation
be printed as their own colorants (e.g. a white or varnish). software. While they can be integrated into photographic images (for example
adding a metallic silver behind a car), the process is usually done by manually
Several concepts here are extremely closely related: Color Separation generates defined masks and not part of the automated color separation software process.
data that is delivered as Color Channels to the heads to be marked onto the See Spot Color and Color Separation.
substrate using Colorants.
Turning that on its head, one definition of a Process Color (as opposed to a Spot
Color) is that it’s a colorant that may be marked by any page element originally
Extended (or expanded) Gamut:
specified in a device independent color space. Spot colors can only be knocked
Using a set of inks that can achieve a wider range of colors than the standard
out by such separation, not actually marked.
CMYK set used by non-digital offset lithography or flexography print processes.
The advantage of using an extended gamut process set on a label press is that
Because non-digital CMYK sets were standardized many years ago with relatively
you never need to worry about changing special inks. You may also be able to
impure shades of cyan, magenta and yellow it’s possible to achieve wider gamuts
achieve multiple different brand color matches side by side or sequentially on
with purer, but non-standard CMYK sets. Many digital inkjet presses use purer
the same run.
CMYK sets, so they can credibly be claimed to achieve wider gamuts than offset
or flexo. Even so, their gamuts are still relatively restricted, so some inkjets are also
being offered with additional colors. Spot Color:
A common term for a specially mixed ink color that is not part of a process set of
So far there are no ISO standards for extended gamut ink sets, which means that inks. Also called Special Color or Brand Color. Typically this will be a brand color
digital presses from different vendors often have rather different color gamuts, that cannot be matched satisfactorily by combinations of the standard CMYK
which in turn vary with the substrate being used. four-color process inks.
ColorPro enables the operator to determine whether any individual Spot color
There are many colors that cannot be achieved satisfactorily from these colors
should be printed using a build of process colorants, or if it should be printed as
alone (for example the popular Reflex Blue, and pure shades of orange, green and
a separation in its own right. Also see process color.
purple). Therefore some presses can apply additional (more or less) transparent
colorants, usually a choice of green, orange and violet, but sometimes red, green
and blue. XG:
The importance of these extra colorants being referred to as part of a process Abbreviation for Extended Gamut
set is that they can be part of a modified color separation process and are used
in variable amounts as needed to generate particular parts of the consequently
expanded color gamut.
About the author
Martin Bailey, CTO, Global Graphics Software
Martin Bailey works to analyze and understand current and future needs for workflows across many sectors
of print. This enables him to guide Global Graphics’ industry-leading printing technology. He represents Global
Graphics on a number of industry bodies and standards committees including acting as the primary UK
expert on the committees working on PDF, PDF/X and PDF/VT.
Martin has over 30 years of experience building, using, supporting and improving products for processing
digital documents and the print industry in technical support, product management and programming as well
as in consulting, and production environments.
March 2018 v2
Harlequin, the Harlequin RIP, the Harlequin logo, Harlequin VariData, Harlequin ColorPro and ScreenPro are trademarks of Global Graphics Software Limited which may be registered in certain jurisdictions. Global Graphics is a trademark
of Hybrid Software Group which may be registered in certain jurisdictions. Adobe and PostScript are a trademarks of Adobe Systems, Inc., which may be registered in certain jurisdictions. All other brand and product names are trademarks
or registered trademarks of their respective owners. All specifications subject to change without notice. Global Graphics makes no warranty and accepts no liability for any loss or damage arising from the use of information or particulars
in this document. Copyright © 2021 Global Graphics Software Limited. All rights reserved.