Module - 02
Module - 02
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MODULE: 02
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DAMAGE ASSESSMENT:
Assessment: Assessment in civil engineering involves evaluating the condition or performance
of a structure or system to determine its safety, reliability, and functionality.
Damage Assessment (Condition Assessment):
It is the process of evaluating the extent and nature of damage to a structure or system
caused by natural disasters, accidents, or other events.
It is one of the qualitative evaluation techniques to assess the condition or state of the
buildings.
Objectives:
a) To determine the severity of the damage, identify and to understand the extent of damage.
Photos have to be taken in visual observation about damages has to be documented
systematically
The visible distress harmful or causing damage to safety of structures such as cracks
in beams, columns, and slabs, spalling of concrete, sagging of beams or slabs and
major failure of structural members have to be recorded.
Identifying the causes of distress and listing the factors such as deficiency in design,
poor detailing of structural members, poor quality of construction, extreme and
unforeseen loading, inadequacy of the structural system resist natural hazards.
b) Assess the type and extent of damage and carry out damage assessment of structures
through various types of tests.
Conducting tests such as NDT,SDT & DT the extent of distress and deterioration can
be evaluated.
Based on the results from the tests the residual strengths of structural elements can be
determined
c) To develop a repair or remediation strategy to restore the functionality and safety of the
structure or system.
Structural and non-structural repairs required for crucial and critical damages to restore
the structure has to be done.
The methods of repair and retrofitting shall be decided to strengthen the building.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rapid Assessment:
It is also known as preliminary investigation or visual investigation.
It mainly includes
a) Collection of information and details about building design, construction, past utilization,
and past maintenance.
Building design details and drawings.
Architectural details.
Construction details and drawings including the specifications of materials used,
Geotechnical details of the area and foundation particulars,
Details of any repair or retrofitting done from the time of construction.
Details of usage of the building including the loads
b) Visual inspection of condition at site and recording details of distress.
The main objective of visual investigation is to observe and note down all the items of
distress or design deficiency and their locations, supported with sketches and drawings.
Verification of the accuracy of the original drawings. If no drawings are available,
determination of basic building information.
Identification of major alterations not shown in original construction documents.
Identification of visible structural damage, such as concrete cracking or spalling, and
observations on quality of construction.
Identification of potential non-structural falling hazards, including ceilings, partitions,
curtain walls, parapets, fixtures, and other non-structural building elements.
Observation of condition of soil and the foundations.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVALUATION OF CRACKS:
The cracks in a structure are broadly classified into two categories:
a) Superficial cracks or surface cracks
b) Structural cracks
Surface cracks refer to cracks or fissures that occur on the outermost layer or surface of a
material. These cracks are typically visible to the naked eye and can vary in size, shape, and
depth. These cracks are usually shallow and do not penetrate deep into the material. Superficial
cracks does not affect the structural integrity or functionality of the material
Structural cracks are cracks that occur in load-bearing elements or components of a structure,
such as walls, columns, beams, slabs, or foundations. These cracks can be more severe and have
implications for the structural integrity and stability of the building or structure. Structural cracks
are typically larger, deeper, and may exhibit signs of displacement, such as opening or shifting.
The structural cracks may be active or dormant. A crack where movement is observed is called
active and cracks without movement is called dormant.
The following information may help in diagnosing the cracks
Age of cracks whether the crack is new or old.
Type of crack whether the crack is active or dormant.
Evaluating whether the crack is appearing in opposite face of the member.
Identification of pattern of crack.
Weather conditions during construction of structures.
Study of information, method of construction and test results.
Before proceeding with repair, the investigations should be made to determine the location and
extent of cracking, the causes of damage, and the objectives of repair.
The evaluation of cracks is necessary for the following purposes:
To identify the cause of cracking.
To assess the structure for its safety and serviceability.
To establish the extent of the cracking.
To establish the likely extent of further deterioration.
To study the suitability of various remedial measures,
To make a final assessment for serviceability after repairs
Apart from visual inspection, tapping the surface and listening to the sound for hollow areas
may be one of the simplest methods of identifying the weak spots. The suspected areas are
then opened up by chipping the weak concrete for further assessment.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Semi-destructive testing systems (SDTS): Semi destructive test are used for assessing the in-
situ concrete strength. These tests cause localized damage, which do not cause any loss in the
performance of the structure.
The Semi-destructive tests are conducted to determine the following
i. Determination of cement content.
ii. Determination of water content.
iii. Determination of water-cement ratio.
iv. Determination of pH value of concrete.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Test procedure:
The test procedure consists of applying the hammer on the concrete surface and observing
the rebound reading indicated by a rider over a scale.
Before applying the hammer, the surface of the concrete is cleaned and smoothened.
When the plunger of rebound hammer is pressed against the surface of concrete, a spring-
controlled mass with a constant energy is made to hit concrete surface to rebound back.
The extent of rebound, which is a measure of surface hardness, is measured on a graduated
scale. This measured value is designated as Rebound Number (rebound index).
A minimum of 10 readings are compared and each reading should not differ by more than 7
units.
The average of remaining readings is determined for evaluating the strength.
The procedure for determining the rebound values has been specified in BIS-13311 Part 2
Thus, the hardness of concrete and rebound hammer reading can be correlated with
compressive strength of concrete.
The rebound value is read off along a graduated scale and is designated as the rebound
number or rebound index.
The hammer is held at right angles to the surface on the concrete i.e., in vertically upward,
vertically downward and in horizontal position.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Transducers of 50 to 60 kHz are found to be useful for most of the applications in concrete
testing.
There are three possible ways of measuring pulse velocity by direct, Semi-direct and indirect
method.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In direct transmission the transmitter and receiver are on the opposites faces of the specimen.
In semi-direct transmission the transmitter and receiver are on the adjacent faces of the
specimen.
In In-direct transmission the transmitter and receiver are on the same faces of the specimen.
The maximum pulses can be obtained in direct transmission and 2% to 3% pulses are
measured in semidirect and indirect transmission.
The quality of concrete is determined based on velocity pulse measured.
UPV V = (km/sec) Concrete quality
V Greater than 4 Very Good
V between 3.5 & 4 Good
V between 3 & 3.5 Poor
V between 2.5 & 3 Very Poor
V between 2 & 2.5 Very Poor & Low integrity
V lesser than 2 Large voids suspected
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The deterioration due to chemical causes such as acidic and alkali reactions.
To determine the degree of damage due to fire
The deterioration effects of concrete subjected for repeated cycles of freezing and thawing
can be studied.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
V = Sound velocity
g = acceleration due to gravity
E = Young’s modulus of concrete
f = Resonant frequency
𝜌 = Density of concrete
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
f) Nuclear method:
Use of nuclear methods for non-destructive measurement of some properties of concrete
such as water content and cement content in concrete is a recent advancement.
Two techniques have been reported, namely Neutron Scattering Method and Neutron
activation analysis for determining moisture and cement content in concrete respectively.
The estimation of water and cement content is essential in assessing and preventing
deterioration of concrete due to chemical causes.
These methods are not suitable for finding out the strength of concrete.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
h) Radioactive method:
The use of X-rays and gamma rays as non-destructive method for testing properties of
concrete is relatively new.
X-rays and gamma rays both components of the high-energy region on the
electromagnetic spectrum penetrate concrete but undergo attenuation in the process.
The apparatus consists of a transmitter, receiver, and a measuring device.
The transmitter induces X-rays and gamma rays and emerging rays after passing through
the specimens are measured.
The degree of attenuation depends on the kind of matter traversed, its thickness, and the
wavelength of the radiation.
Gamma radiation source of known intensity is made to pass and penetrate through the
concrete.
The intensity of the incident gamma rays and the emerging gamma rays after passing
through the specimens are measured.
These two values are made use of for calculating the density of structural concrete
members.
Gamma-rays transmission method has been used to measure the thickness of concrete
slabs of known density.
i) Magnetic method:
Battery operated magnetic devices that can measure the depth of reinforcement cover in
concrete and detect the position of reinforcement bars is now available. The apparatus is
known as Cover meter/Pachometer.
The instrument consists of a search head connected by a cable to a metering unit, which may
have a digital or analogue read-out.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The purpose of locating the reinforcing steel, prestressing strand, cladding ties etc, in concrete,
is to avoid them during core sampling, direct pulse velocity surveys etc, and to make
connections for electrochemical measurements.
The search head provides the value of cover of reinforcement and detection of position of
reinforcement.
j) Electromagnetic method:
Electromagnetic wave category of products comprises the range of instruments used to locate
and determine size and depth of steel reinforcing bar in concrete.
The first type (HR rebar locater) most widely used utilizes a low frequency electromagnetic
field to locate ferrous objects within a structure.
The HR Rebar Locator and the Datascan both utilize a low frequency electromagnetic field
to locate ferrous objects in a structure. By closely monitoring changes in the electromagnetic
field the proximity of steel reinforcing bar can be determined.
The HR Rebar locater is most economical model. It uses a simple analog meter to determine
the strength of the electromagnetic field and correlate this to either the size of the rebar or the
distance to the rebar.
The Datascan MK II utilizes high frequency pulse and observing the reflected electromagnetic
waves features inside a concrete structure.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Semi-destructive testing systems (SDTS): Semi destructive test is used for assessing the in-situ
concrete strength. These tests cause localized damage, which do not cause any loss in the
performance of the structure.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pull-off tests:
The method is also called pull-off resistance method.
The pull-off test is a in-situ test which measures the tensile force required to pull off a
disc bonded to the concrete surface with an epoxy or polyester resin.
The pull off force provides an indication of the tensile and compressive strength of
concrete.
The test setup consists of a hand operated lever which has a dial gauge mounted to it, core
cutter and bond disks and the setup is fixed on test surface with levelling screws.
The disk is bonded with a strong adhesive and with the help of a concrete core cutter the
cut is made around the disk upto certain depth.
The disk is attached to the hand operated lever and the tensile force is applied till the disk
comes out of the concrete.
The force at which the disk pull off is recorded.
The tensile strength of concrete is calculated by dividing the force by the area of the disc.
The compressive strength is also determined by using the relation between compressive
strength and tensile strength of concrete.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The measurement consists of giving an electrical connection to the rebar and observing
the potential difference between the rebar and a reference electrode in contact with
concrete surface.
The potential value becomes more and more negative as the corrosion becomes more and
more active.
Potential Readings Corrosion
More negative than -350 mv >90%
-200 mv to -350 mv 50%
More positive than -200 mv <10%
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The ends of the specimen shall be capped before testing. The material used for the capping
shall be such that its compressive strength is greater than that of the concrete in the core.
Caps shall be made as thin as practicable and shall not flow or fracture before the concrete
fails when the specimen is tested.
The core shall be placed in water at a temperature of 24° to 30°C for 48 hours before
testing. The overall height of the specimens, with capping shall be measured to the nearest
millimetre.
The specimens shall be tested within 7days after coring the sample.
Compression testing is carried out at a rate of 15N/mm2/min and mode of failure is noted.
Correction factors are applied based on length and diameter of specimen to determine the
actual strength of specimen
Corrected strength = Measured strength x [ 1 +1.5(Cr * h / Cc * I)]
Where Cr = diameter of reinforcement bar
h = distance of bar from nearest end
Cc = diameter of core
I = Uncapped length of core
According to IS:456-1978 the concrete in the member represented by the core test shall
be considered acceptable, if the average equivalent cube strength of the core is equal to
at least 85% of the cube strength of the grade of concrete specified for the corresponding
age, and no individual core has the strengthen less than 75%.
Core cutting
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
e) Penetration test:
The test is called penetration test or Windsor probe test since the equipment used is known
as Windsor probe.
The penetration resistance method of assessing strength uses a hardened steel probe,
which is fired into a concrete surface using a special gun and a standardized explosive
charge.
The Windsor probe consists of a powder-actuated gun or driver, hardened alloy steel
probes, loaded cartridges, a depth gauge for measuring the penetration of probes, and
other related equipment.
The device looks like a firearm is used to drive the probe.
The area to be tested is initially cleaned to a smooth surface.
The probe is driven into the concrete by the firing of a precision powder charge that
develops energy of 79.5 m kg.
The depth gauge measures the exposed lengths of the individual probes.
The Standard Windsor Probe System includes a depth gauge and "Strength Chart" for
determining the concrete strength.
The exposed probe length is correlated with the compressive strength of concrete.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
f) Resistivity mapping:
The corrosion of a specific length of reinforcement is dependent on the algebraic
summation of the electrical currents originating from the corroding sites on the steel and
flowing through the moist surrounding concrete to non-corroding sites.
The electrical resistance of concrete plays an important role in determining the magnitude
of corrosion at any specific location.
The parameter is expressed in terms of resistivity in ohm centimeters or kilo ohm
centimeters by four-probe resistivity meter.
The method essentially consists of using a 4-probe technique and the probes are inserted
into the concrete to a depth of 6mm with a spacing of 50mm between the probes in which
a known current is applied between two outer probe and the voltage drop between the
inner two elements is read off allowing for a direct evaluation of resistance R.
Using a mathematical conversion factor, resistivity is calculated as p=2 π R a.
Resistivity ohm cm Corrosion probability
Greater than 20,000 Negligible
10,000 to 20,000 Low
5,000 to 10,000 High
Less than 5,000 Very high
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------