KEMBAR78
Criminal Profiling & Financial Profiling | PDF
Criminal Profiling &
Financial Profiling
Obedience of the Law
Instrumental Theory vs Normative Theory
Instrumental Theory
The punishment for disobedience of the law outweighs the merits of
obeying the law.
Normative Theory
Voluntary obedience of the law due to being morally invested in the law.
Criminology
The study of crime.
Criminology Schools of Thought
Classical Criminology
Positivist Criminology
Critical Criminology
Feminist Criminology
Postmodern Criminology
Social Milieu Criminology
Classical Criminology
Summary of Key Premises
Classical Criminology
• All persons are equal before the law.
• People are motivated by pleasure to commit crimes (criminals by nature).
• People are rational and their behaviour is the product of free will.
• The focus is on the crime and the law.
• Crime is a voluntary act committed by a deliberate choice.
• Punishment must be used to control/deter criminal behaviour.
• The punishment must be proportionate to the crime.
Page 20, Neser et al (2010)
Positivist Criminology
Summary of Key Premises
Positivist Criminology
• The focus is on the criminal.
• Human behaviour is determined by biological, psychological and socio-
economic factors that individuals have little control over (criminals by nature,
nurture and environment).
• Crime can be prevented with medical/psychological treatment and
improvement of poor socio-economic conditions.
• The purpose of punishment is to allow for treatment/reform of criminals.
Page 22, Neser et al (2010)
Other Schools of Thought
Feminist Criminology
• Neither positivist nor critical criminology
explain low crime rates among women.
• The focus is on discrimination against
women in the criminal justice system.
• Further focuses on crimes against
women (i.e. domestic violence & sexual
crimes).
• Considers it unjust to expect victims to
protect themselves against crime.
Pages 23 & 25, Neser et al (2010)
Critical Criminology
• Crime is a rational, deliberate choice.
• Assumes that the state is biased/selective
and chooses to focus on certain criminal
acts committed by powerless people.
• Economic and political discrimination are
the causes of crime.
• Considers that criminals are oppressed by
the state.
• Proposes that crime could be prevented by
empowering people (i.e. through
community policing).
Other Schools of Thought
Postmodern Criminology
• Not bound to any school of thought.
• Rejects theories based on social
class or culture.
• Emphasises community-based
policing and punishments.
• Focuses on victims’ rights and needs.
Social Milieu Criminology
• The focus is on the criminal’s social
environment.
• Assumes that improved social
conditions will prevent crime.
Pages 21 & 26, Neser et al (2010)
Criminal Profiling
Sources of Motivation
Internal Motives: Needs
• Biological needs: food and water.
• Psychological & social needs: sense of belonging, competence, interpersonal
relationships, socialisation, need for achievement, etc.
Page 90, Neser et al (2010)
Internal Motives: Cognitions
• Beliefs, expectations, and individual values.
Page 91, Neser et al (2010)
Internal Motives: Emotions
• Feelings: joy, sadness, anger, pleasure, etc.
Page 91, Neser et al (2010)
External Events
• Environmental sources of motivation: i.e. economic recession in a
country causing unemployment, COVID-19 pandemic industry shutdown
causing layoffs, etc.
Page 92, Neser et al (2010)
The Process of Motivation
Goal
Action
Goal
Attained
Need
Page 96, Neser et al (2010)
Financial Profiling
Risk Appetite
• For crime, it is how much an individual is willing to risk.
• Increases as the crime goes undetected due to logical fallacy (appeal to
tradition).
Interests, Goals &
Relationship with Money
The Fraud Triangle:
Pressure
Rationalisation
FRAUD
Opportunity
Further Reading
Neser J et al, INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINOLOGY: CRIME, OFFENDERS
AND CRIMINAL BEHAVIOUR, University of South Africa (2010).
Terpstra, BL, Instrumental and normative pathways to compliance: results
from field research on moped drivers, Universiteit Leiden (2022).
Thank you.

Criminal Profiling & Financial Profiling

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Obedience of theLaw Instrumental Theory vs Normative Theory
  • 3.
    Instrumental Theory The punishmentfor disobedience of the law outweighs the merits of obeying the law.
  • 4.
    Normative Theory Voluntary obedienceof the law due to being morally invested in the law.
  • 5.
  • 6.
    Criminology Schools ofThought Classical Criminology Positivist Criminology Critical Criminology Feminist Criminology Postmodern Criminology Social Milieu Criminology
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Classical Criminology • Allpersons are equal before the law. • People are motivated by pleasure to commit crimes (criminals by nature). • People are rational and their behaviour is the product of free will. • The focus is on the crime and the law. • Crime is a voluntary act committed by a deliberate choice. • Punishment must be used to control/deter criminal behaviour. • The punishment must be proportionate to the crime. Page 20, Neser et al (2010)
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Positivist Criminology • Thefocus is on the criminal. • Human behaviour is determined by biological, psychological and socio- economic factors that individuals have little control over (criminals by nature, nurture and environment). • Crime can be prevented with medical/psychological treatment and improvement of poor socio-economic conditions. • The purpose of punishment is to allow for treatment/reform of criminals. Page 22, Neser et al (2010)
  • 11.
    Other Schools ofThought Feminist Criminology • Neither positivist nor critical criminology explain low crime rates among women. • The focus is on discrimination against women in the criminal justice system. • Further focuses on crimes against women (i.e. domestic violence & sexual crimes). • Considers it unjust to expect victims to protect themselves against crime. Pages 23 & 25, Neser et al (2010) Critical Criminology • Crime is a rational, deliberate choice. • Assumes that the state is biased/selective and chooses to focus on certain criminal acts committed by powerless people. • Economic and political discrimination are the causes of crime. • Considers that criminals are oppressed by the state. • Proposes that crime could be prevented by empowering people (i.e. through community policing).
  • 12.
    Other Schools ofThought Postmodern Criminology • Not bound to any school of thought. • Rejects theories based on social class or culture. • Emphasises community-based policing and punishments. • Focuses on victims’ rights and needs. Social Milieu Criminology • The focus is on the criminal’s social environment. • Assumes that improved social conditions will prevent crime. Pages 21 & 26, Neser et al (2010)
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Internal Motives: Needs •Biological needs: food and water. • Psychological & social needs: sense of belonging, competence, interpersonal relationships, socialisation, need for achievement, etc. Page 90, Neser et al (2010)
  • 15.
    Internal Motives: Cognitions •Beliefs, expectations, and individual values. Page 91, Neser et al (2010)
  • 16.
    Internal Motives: Emotions •Feelings: joy, sadness, anger, pleasure, etc. Page 91, Neser et al (2010)
  • 17.
    External Events • Environmentalsources of motivation: i.e. economic recession in a country causing unemployment, COVID-19 pandemic industry shutdown causing layoffs, etc. Page 92, Neser et al (2010)
  • 18.
    The Process ofMotivation Goal Action Goal Attained Need Page 96, Neser et al (2010)
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Risk Appetite • Forcrime, it is how much an individual is willing to risk. • Increases as the crime goes undetected due to logical fallacy (appeal to tradition).
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Further Reading Neser Jet al, INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINOLOGY: CRIME, OFFENDERS AND CRIMINAL BEHAVIOUR, University of South Africa (2010). Terpstra, BL, Instrumental and normative pathways to compliance: results from field research on moped drivers, Universiteit Leiden (2022).
  • 24.