Object-Oriented Analysis and Design

Baozhong Cheng (Bob Cheng) School of Software Engineering BUPT

Textbook:
<Applying UML and Patterns, An Introduction to Object-Oriented Analysis and Design and Iterative Development>, Criag Larman,3nd Ed., 2006

Reference:
[1] <Applying Use Case Driven Object Modeling with UML, an Annotated ECommerce Example>, Doug Rosenberg, 2001, < >

[2] <Object Oritented Software Engineering Using UML,Patterns, and Java>, Bernd Bruegge, 2010, < >
[3] <Use Case Driven Object Modeling with UML/Theory and Practice>,Doug Rosenberg and Matt Stephens, Apress Jan 2007

Software Engineering

Theory (Abstract)

OOAD

OOP (C++, Java, C#, or Objective-C)

Implementation (Concrete)

Bloom's Taxonomy of the Cognitive Domain

SIX LEVELS Level-1: KNOWLEDGE Level-2: COMPREHENSION Level-3: APPLICATION Level-4: ANALYSIS Level-5: SYNTHESIS Level-6: EVALUATION

Lab Project
An OOAD for a library management system for our school Finish the project in a group of two people Functional requirements Record new library book Borrow a book Return a book Search a book Deliverablesa MS Word design document, and a zipped eclipse project file 1. File Name: OS_OOAD_GroupLeadName.zip 2. Use JUDE tool to draw UML diagramscopy & paste into a word doc. Team member names and responsibilities Use case diagram, use case (text) Class diagram (domain model & design class diagram) Sequence diagram State chat diagram 3. A zipped eclipse project file Deadline: 28-JUN-2013. Email the project file to: bobzc@163.com, or bobzc@sohu.com
5

Lecture 1 Introduction to OOAD

Chapter 1 Object-Oriented Analysis & Design

Objectives
Describe the book goals and scope. Define object-oriented analysis and design (OOAD). Illustrate a brief OOA/D example. Overview UML and visual agile modeling.

What Will You Learn? Is it Useful?

OOA/D

Patterns

UML notation

Topics and Skills

Principles and guidelines Iterative development with an agile Unified Process

Requirements analysis

The Most Important Learning Goal

A critical, fundamental ability in OOAD is to skillfully assign responsibilities to software component
GRASP patterns, nine fundamental principles in object design and responsibilities assignment

What is Analysis and Design?

Analysis emphasizes an investigation of the problem rather than how a solution is defined (WHAT?)
Design emphasizes a logical solution, how the system fulfills the requirements (HOW?)

Analysis and Design

Division between A&D is fuzzy A&D activities exist on a continuum Some practitioners can classify an activity as analysis while others put it into design category
More analysis oriented

More design oriented

-what -requirements -investigation of domain -understanding of problem

-how -logical solution -understanding and description of solution

What is OOAD?
The essence of OOAD is to consider a problem domain and logical solution from the perspective of objects (things, concepts, or entities)
OO Analysis emphasizes finding and describing the objects or concepts- in the problem domain

OO Design emphasizes defining logical software objects (things, concepts, or entities) that have attributes and methods

OO Analysis
OOA requires domain knowledge and OOA expertise
Hence, there is a need for both a domain expert and an OO analysis expert Domain expert is always right about decisions relating to problem domain If you are lucky, these two experts are the same person

OOA identifies
Concepts in the problem domain Relationships among those concepts Attributes of those concepts

OO Design
OOD defines a logical software solution for the problem
Solution is defined based on findings of OOA phase It includes definition of class methods that represent a logical software solution New concepts, attributes or relationship among concepts are often discovered during design phase. They are iteratively reflected back into analysis phase

Object vs. Function Oriented Analysis

Library Info System

Decompose by objects and concepts

O-O A&D

Decompose by functions and processes

Structured A&D
System

Catalog

Librarian

Book

Library

Record Loans

Add Resource

Report Fines

Object-Oriented Analysis and Design

Example: a catalog system for my books Analysis: what are the concepts in the problem domain? Book, each with a title. Design: what do (should) the domain concepts do? The Book object should give its own title. Construction: realize the logical solution public class Book { private String title; public void print_title() { }; } // Book implemented in Java

Object-Oriented Analysis and Design

OOAD
Larman

Requirements Analysis

Use Cases

Conceptual Model

System Behavior

Collaboration Diagrams

Class Design Diagrams

Code & Test

Requirements Study

OO Analysis

OO Design

Construction

Object-orientation emphasizes representation of objects

Plane domain concept tailNumber

visualization of domain concept

representation in an object-oriented programming language

public class Plane { private String tailNumber; public List getFlightHistory() {...} }

OOAD Example: A Dice Game

The OOAD Process

Define use cases

Build a domain model

Construct interaction diagrams Develop design class diagram

Define use cases:

Use Case: Play a Dice Game Primary Actor: Player Description: The player picks up and rolls the dice. If the dice total seven, they win, otherwise they lose.

 Build a domain model

In OOAD, we want to create a specification of the problem domain so that we can build models of the objects for the solution.

We decompose the problem by identifying things and concepts, the attributes, and their associations; the result is a model of the problem domain which we are dealing with.

 Construct interaction diagrams

In OOAD, we go on to investigate how the objects in the domain model may interact in collaboration to work out the solution. In a communication diagram, we illustrate how the objects may pass messages between them.

 Construct interaction diagrams

Another kind of interaction diagram is the sequence diagram, which illustrate the sequence of events (due to message passing) between these objects. Sequence diagrams and communication diagrams are collectively known as the interaction diagrams.

 Develop logical class diagram

A structure of the model of classes in the solution detailed models of the software constructs. Ready for implementation: organize the classes into modules; implement each class in code (Java, C++, or C#).

What is the UML?

The Unified Modeling Language is a visual language for specifying, constructing and documenting the artifacts of systems [OMG03a]. It is a notational system aimed at modeling systems using OO concepts not a methodology not a process

Three Ways to Apply UML

UML as sketch
Informal and incomplete diagrams
often hand sketched on whiteboards

created to explore difficult parts of the problem or solution space, exploiting the power of visual languages.

UML as blueprint
Relatively detailed design diagrams used either for
1. reverse engineering to visualize and better understanding existing code in UML diagrams 2. code generation (forward engineering).

Three Ways to Apply UMLcont.)

UML as programming language
Complete executable specification of a software system in UML.
Executable code will be automatically generated, but is not normally seen or modified by developers; one works only in the UML programming language. This use of UML requires a practical way to diagram all behavior or logic (probably using interaction or state diagrams), still under development in terms of theory, tool robustness and usability

UML Diagrams
Use Case Diagrams Class Diagrams Interaction Diagrams State Diagrams Activity Diagrams Package Diagrams Deployment Diagrams
Nodes: Links: Nodes: Links: Nodes: Links: Nodes: Links: Nodes: Links: Nodes: Links: Nodes: Links: Actor, Use (case) Involvement, Extension, Inclusion, Generalization Class Association, Generalization Object Message, Lifeline State, Sub-State Transition Activity Guard, Synchronization Package Dependency Processor, Node Dependency

UML Diagrams
w flo k or s

Use Case

sc en a

rio s

Activity
s r-cla Inte

structures

Interaction

Inte ra sequ ction betw ences een obje cts

Class
ing tur c u str

Int e beh r-clas s avi ors

Package

State

Messages leading to state changes in objects

ors h avi s be

Chapter 2: Iterative, Evolutionary, and Agile

Objectives
1. Provide motivation for the content and order of subsequent chapters
2. Define an iterative and agile process 3. Define fundamental concepts in the Unified Process

Introduction
Iterative development lies at the heart of how OOAD is best practiced Agile Modeling are key to applying the UML in an effective way

Modern approach vs. traditional approach

Iterative and evolutionary development short quick development steps, feedback, and adaptation to clarify the requirements and design.

sequential or waterfall lifecycle promoted big upfront speculative requirements and design steps before programming.

The Most Important UP idea: Iterative Development

Development is organized into a series of short, fixed-length mini-projects called iterations Each iteration has its own requirements analysis, design, implementation, and testing activities

Requirements Design Implementation & Test & Integration & More Design Final Integration & System Test Time

Requirements Design Implementation & Test & Integration & More Design Final Integration & System Test

Feedback from iteration N leads to refinement and adaptation of the requirements and design in iteration N+1.

3 weeks (for example) Iterations are fixed in length, or timeboxed. The system grows incrementally.

How to Handle Change on an Iterative Project?

Change that occurs in software development is inevitable due to the stakeholders clarify their vision or the marketplace changes, and so on. Iterative and evolutionary development is based on an attitude of embracing change and adaptation as unavoidable and indeed essential driver. Each iteration involves choosing a small subset of the requirements, and quickly designing, implementing, and testing, and this leads rapid feedback. For large scale software system, this is the only way to find out what are the requirements, which can really satisfy the end-users need In an iterative project, end-users have a lot of chance to see a partial system, and say Yes, thats what I asked for, but what I really means is something slightly different

Iterations and Convergence

Early iterations are farther from the "true path" of the system. Via feedback and adaptation, the system converges towards the most appropriate requirements and design. In late iterations, a significant change in requirements is rare, but can occur. Such late changes may give an organization a competitive business advantage.

one iteration of design, implement, integrate, and test

Why is the Waterfall so Failure-Prone?

40 35 30

Requirements change

25 20 15 10 5 0 10 100 1000 10000 Project Size in Function Points

...

20

requirements workshops Imagine this will ultimately be a 20iteration project. In evolutionary iterative development, the requirements evolve over a set of the early iterations, through a series of requirements workshops (for example). Perhaps after four iterations and workshops, 90% of the requirements are defined and refined. Nevertheless, only 10% of the software is built.

requirements

requirements

software

software

90%

90%

50% 20% 2% Iteration 1 30% 5% Iteration 2 a 3-week iteration 8% Iteration 3 10% Iteration 4 20% Iteration 5

week 1 M T W Th F

week 2 M T W Th F

week 3 M T W Th F

kickoff meeting clarifying iteration goals with the team. 1 hour

team agile modeling & design, UML whiteboard sketching. 5 hours

start coding & testing

de-scope iteration goals if too much work

final check-in and codefreeze for the iteration baseline Use-case modeling during the workshop

demo and 2-day requirements workshop

next iteration planning meeting; 2 hours

Most OOA/D and applying UML during this period

What is Agile Modeling?

Adopting an agile method does not mean avoiding any modeling The purpose of modeling and models is primarily to support understanding and communication, not documentation. Dont model or apply the UML to all or most of the software design. Use the simplest tool possible.
prefer low energy creativity-enhancing simple tools that support rapid input and change

The Unified Process

development cycle iteration phase

inc.

elaboration

construction

transition

milestone An iteration endpoint when some significant decision or evaluation occurs.

release A stable executable subset of the final product. The end of each iteration is a minor release.

increment The difference (delta) between the releases of 2 subsequent iterations.

final production release At this point, the system is released for production use.

Disciplines (workflow) vs. Iterations

A four-week iteration (for example). A mini-project that includes work in most disciplines, ending in a stable executable. Sample UP Disciplines Business Modeling Focus of this book Requirements Design Implementation Test Deployment Configuration & Change Management Project Management Environment Iterations Note that although an iteration includes work in most disciplines, the relative effort and emphasis change over time. This example is suggestive, not literal.

Case Study Strategy: Iteraltive Development + Iterative Learning

Iteration 1 Iteration 2 Introduces just those analysis and design Additional analysis and skills related to design skills introduced. iteration one. Iteration 3 Likewise.

Book organization is related with UP phases and iterations

The Book Elaboration Iteration 1 Elaboration Iteration 2 Elaboration Iteration 3 Special Topics

Overview

Inception

Object-Oriented Analysis

Object-Oriented Design

Translating Designs to Code

Topics such as OO analysis and OO design are incrementally introduced in iteration 1, 2, and 3.

Chapter 3: Case Studies

What is and isnt in the Case Studies?
Focuses on the core application logic layer

minor focus

User Interface
explore how to connect to other layers

application logic layer

primary focus of case studies Sale Payment explore how to design objects

other layers or components

Logging ...

Database Access ...

secondary focus

Case One: The NextGen POS System

POS Point Of Sale A computerized application used to record sales and handle payments It interfaces to various service applications Bank (credit card system) Inventory control Third party tax calculator

Increasingly must support multiple and varied terminals and interfaces A commercial POS system that will serve different clients with disparate needs in terms of business rule processing

Case Two: The Monopoly Game System